Summary Of Consider The Lobster By David Foster Wallace

Improved Essays
Lobster, often named the king of seafood, is often seen as one of the most scrumptious seafood delights; yet poses some serious questions in the realm of morality. At least, that is what David Foster Wallace, the author of “Consider the Lobster”, proposes to his readers. He does this through his experience of the Maine Lobster Festival, or MLF, as well as examining the ways in which lobster is handled, prepared, and how people justify these practices. Knowing that the vast majority of lobster is boiled alive, the question posed is important not only for our morality but for the sake of all lobsters. Wallace takes this issue and looks at both sides of the argument; he questions the evidence provided by supporters of the status quo, while presenting evidence and emotional appeals in opposition that cause the reader to really reflect. By highlighting the ways in which we are possibly mistreating lobster, Wallace successfully makes readers reconsider how we handle our lobster and whether we should …show more content…
He accomplishes this rhetorically through making logical arguments that show a possibility of lobsters feeling pain, and counter local rebuttals that propose false premises about the nature of lobsters. And adds his own emotional appeals in his own experiences with boiling lobster and experiencing the festival. While diving into reasoning on both sides of the argument Wallace makes logical arguments to reveal the possibility for lobsters experiencing excruciating pain. At the same time, he pulls emotionally charged language and imagery to cause readers to really second guess their assumptions. I believe that in the end Wallace does prove successful in evoking these emotions and causing readers, like me, to rethink our morality on this food

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Food, Inc., a documentary by Robert Kenner, informs the American people in the food industry’s malevolent side. It uses compelling images, such as chickens being brought up in small spaces, and incorporates stories of farmers, government officials and victims of the food industry. Food, Inc. exposes the food industry and the audience realizes wealth has become more of a priority than safety. But, the end of the film invokes a sense of hope when the show reveals how the audience can make a difference. Food Inc. uses rhetorical strategies to build a warning to consumers about the somber side within the food industry.…

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    David Wallace Foster’s Kenyon College Commencement Speech is extremely successful for a multitude of reasons. It is not so much inspirational or revolutionary or epic, just simply honest. His speech is blunt about what people will face in their life after education. That adult life is boring, repetitive, trivial, tiring. Yet despite being adult life being unsatisfactory, Wallace always says it will only be those things because of your perspective.…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Joy Williams “Save the whales, Screw the Shrimp” is ultimately only partly successful because, while it has reasonable ethos and logos and is a good example of expository text, the author seems to place too much blame on the reader that today’s culture has all but entirely lost touch with what nature really is. Throughout the text, Williams uses a variety of rhetoric devices to make her writing more effective. Logos, ethos, pathos, style, tone, audience, and mode are used in a way that seems to give readers the impression that she has authority over them. In the source of “History and Humans/rest of nature”, it’s been said that humans respond to change and in turn feed the climate.…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This writer loves to eat different foods and enjoys experiencing the cultural tradition of each morsel as it excites my palette. For this discussion, I will share two of my favorites; lobster with drawn butter and gumbo. My family proudly declares they are from the south and cook with precision and care of a five-star chef. Part of the rich culinary tradition is our family gumbo recipe. My family origins are from South Carolina and Louisiana, and the combination of the regions can make a mouth water.…

    • 329 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1990, author Wendell Berry released an essay titled “The Pleasures of Eating”. The essay focused on the responsibilities of eating, which includes self-awareness regarding what one’s consuming. Berry discusses how to eat responsibly throughout his piece, often citing the hidden dangers of the food industry, which includes the unjustifiable treatment of animals. Berry uses the rhetorical appeals in relation to these matters which allows him to connect and convey his message more strongly toward Americans, especially those living more rural lifestyles.…

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Payton White Professor Hunsaker 3 September 2016 Articles 26 & 27 After analyzing article 26, “Puppies, Pigs, and People: Eating Meat and Marginal Cases” by Alastair Norcross, a couple things become apparent. Such as (only use “such as” if you are continuing the sentence, but not to start a new sentence.) our author opening up his piece with a fictional scenario that seems a tad bit crazy, but serves as a very serious philosophical point. According to our ( it would be best to just say, “the” author instead of “our” author.) author, Norcross sees meat-eaters-at least those who know of the treatment of factory-farmed animals-are completely at fault for the consumption of meat.…

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He captures the emotional state of an amateur dumpster diver: “Every grain of rice seems to be a maggot. Everything seems to stink. He can wipe the egg yolk off the found can, but he cannot erase the stigma of eating garbage out of his mind” (145). Readers cringe at his vivid and effective language, imagining the dive into the dumpster, and then envisioning the effects that one might experience after. Eighner speaks of the ever-present fear that something he is eating is contaminated, knowing that there are people who purposely contaminate food; he tells of a pizza shop that put jalapeños on all of their pizzas hoping to discourage him from taking those discarded from their dumpster (144).…

    • 1081 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The narrative goes as far as to examine the anatomy of the lobster to determine if it is truly alive. Just as the title proclaims Wallace’s true intentions for writing the article are not to focus on the lobster but rather the way humans view the lobster and their relationship with other living things. This is just one narrative of many that exhibit guilt and critique on the relationship between humans and animals. This narrative demonstrates the worst aspect of this relationship by showing how despite holding festivities, events, and procedures to enjoy certain animals to the fullest human beings struggle to determine whether it is correct to view the harming of animals as morally correct. By analyzing “Consider the Lobster” by Wallace one can conclude that although people may enjoy celebrating, consuming, and cooking large amounts of animals they do not seem to enjoy thinking about the suffering and conscious of the animals they consume.…

    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While William enjoys many of the various stories his father tells him as a young child, William’s enjoyment of them as an adult gradually morphs into intense embarrassment and annoyance to eventually resentment. This is evident from William’s reaction in the very beginning of Burton’s film to hearing his father utilize his stories in public speaking (Burton 0:5:35). It is only with the inevitable death of his father that finally forces William to make some effort to repair the damage his relationship with his father has suffered with throughout the three years that they have gone not speaking to one another. While both Burton and Wallace’s William attempt to reconcile with his dying father, the motives to achieve this is different from Daniel Wallace to Tim Burton. In the novel, Wallace uses William’s attempt to reconcile and understand his father’s motives for story-telling is what brings the two men to reestablish the desired relationship that they both wish to have with each other.…

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages
    • 2 Works Cited
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It has been three to four years since, “Mr. Tawney’s Pasta Incident,” has taken place. It was a spring buffet lunch day when Mr. Tawney served himself a plateful of baked ziti from one of the serving dishes. However, before he sat down, he opted to go for the sandwiches he had just seen carried out. Torn between his meal options, he chose to not be wasteful and put the baked ziti from his plate back into the serving dish, grabbed another plate, and served himself a sandwich. After hearing all the details of this controversial story, I have concluded that Mr. Tawney should not have put his pasta back into the serving dish.…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Michael Pollan’s “An Animal’s Place” Pollan provides an argument on whether or not Americans should consume animals, and specifically, if the fashion in which animals are farmed and slaughtered respects their capacity to suffer. Pollan illustrates his personal dilemma particularly when he ironically points his debate on whether or not to eat meat began while he was dining at a steakhouse. To develop his argument, Pollan initially exclusively uses the citation of animal rights activists, but then gradually cites experts that support his conclusion that Americans eat animals as long as the principle behind it is correct, and animals are treated with respect. He asserts to accomplish respecting animals that Americans need to regain their contact…

    • 1386 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    An Animal's Place All beings are aware of animal slaughter for food purposes. One may either look away with guilt and still consume meat knowing in fact the process within animal slaughter, or on the crontary, not consume meat at all. Michael Pollan makes several points throughout his journal from “ The New York Times Magazine”, in which he advocates the idea of equality, factory farming, and humane farming. Within his several points, he arrives to a conclusion in which he proclaims that animals’ rights may still be honored during the preparation of the slaughtering of an animal. Equality is one point Pollan shares with his readers, stating that there is not much equality among animals themselves.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The animal rights movement consists of privileged ideology based off emotion and no logic. Nathanael Johnson explores these ideals in “Is there a Moral Case for Meat?” and a couple in the film “At the Fork” explores the morality of farming. While the article and film seem to take similar stances on the farming of animals, I disagree. Humans do not have a responsibility to avoid meat or mitigate the suffering of farm raised animals.…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Don’t Blame the Eater” by David Zinczenko, he warns the consumers of the deception of fast food chains. He states the dangers of eating fast food and he agrees that it harms the body. Throughout the article he argues that the consumer isn’t at fault, the one to blame are the fast food chains. To put across ideas he asks questions, he uses his own personal narrative, imagery, and tone, with these tactics he’s able to argue against the deceitful tactics of the fast food industry.…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Honestly, when I first read the article I skipped through the footnotes, but after the class discussion I went back on to read them, and you can sort of get how the author feels personal about Lobsters and the footnoted that were presented throughout help support his claim. Both stories were great and unique it different…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays