Personal Narrative: Ethical And Justice Oriented Levels Of Moral Development

Improved Essays
Laura is in her mid-twenties, grew up in Baltimore, African American, comes from a long line of educators and is starting her teacher career. I’ve placed her within the Ethical and Justice oriented Levels of Moral Development. For her ethical moral development, I believe she’s at Level 2, Caring for Others, Ethic of Conventional Goodness, with the possibility of 2.5. She holds onto an emphasis on responsibility, commitment, and a parentlike morality that seeks to provide care for the dependent and unequal. She is self sacrificing in her care, which can be seen through her belief that, “you just take the risk sometimes”. Because of her lack of concern for herself, she is not at Level 3. On her justice development, I placed her at a loose stage …show more content…
Stage Five: Prior Rights and Social Contract fits because of her active efforts organizing a social group to compare notes on breaking the rules. She has also made comments that show she is critically thinking of the current social structures and recognizes her social contract and attempts to change these conditions. Stage 3: Mutual Interpersonal Expectations, Good Relations states that the “justifications for acting morally focuses on the desire to be seen as good person in one’s own eyes”. Lenora creates maxims for herself that aren’t universalized in order to fit what she sees to be as a good person. She’s able to make these exceptions to because she conceptualizes justice personally as “taking consideration of person’s worthiness, goodness, and circumstances”. This is connected to the worth of the innocents mentioned earlier. The stage of justice influence the evaluation of the Justice Perspectives: Consequentialism and Non-Consequentialism. Under the consequential perspective, her actions are justified and ethical, while unethical for the Non-Consequentialist. Lanora intentions with her actions are meant to minimize the suffering of …show more content…
Throughout the case, there are clear signs that she believes herself to be an exception. Part of this is influenced by her teacher identity and as a middle class black woman. The basis for her actions is a recognition that the larger society holds responsibility and fault for many of the student’s circumstances. She frames things on the context of capitalism, even with her understanding of education. She’s quoted saying, “education is the critical element for advancement” but eventually shifts in saying that “‘old school belief that you can overcome everything if you get an education’ has been tattered”. Despite holding onto a framework that understands the flaws of social institution and larger society, she uses this as a justification for her to be an exception. This is also affected by her membership to a marginalized population. Her lack of a non-Consequential perspective influences her relation to the overarching teacher community and other professionals. She mentions not approving the idea of just “any old teacher” taking a child home, but she believes it’s okay for her to do so. This mentality is alienating her from the rest of her community and places her on different standards in her

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Family Interaction

    • 1379 Words
    • 6 Pages

    said he would absolutely like to be part of IEP meetings for Emily, or go to parent-teacher conferences but his way of supporting his family is different from others. Another aspect of family interaction that I thought was interesting was the relationship between Emily and her grandma. Erin’s parents live right down the road from her and she thought it was going to be a great support system to have. At first Emily’s grandmother would watch her but as time went on and Emily’s behaviors got more intense, her grandma refused to watch her. This was another aspect that I thought differed from what our text said.…

    • 1379 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both have stated Keshawna ignores and defies their directives and “does just what she pleases.” Both Barbara Morris and Lavern Davis reported they “do not want to give up on Keshawna,” but at her age, they feel Keshawna should be more responsible and accepting of efforts from others. Her family provides some opportunities for growth, but inconsistently provides love, caring and support. Keshawna does not have a close relationship with her legal guardian or extended family. Keshawna said she is close to Barbara Morris and respects her. It appears the family members are unreliable and inconsistent informants.…

    • 1086 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This theory asserts that a person should act as one who cares and seek a mutually beneficial solution. In the other moral theories that we examined, Mary’s situation is a conflict of interest with only two solutions; she could either disregard her personal desires while pleasing her parents or fulfill her dreams while disappointing her parents. However, ethics of care erases this conflict and finds a way for everyone’s needs to be met, making a mutually beneficial solution possible. Particular to Mary’s case, ethics of care does not promote running away. This is because running away is inconsiderate of both Mary and her parents’ needs.…

    • 1449 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Templeton also underestimates the emotional state that Mrs. Bhave is in. When they first meet, Judith states, “Someone mentioned that Mrs. Bhave is a pillar--because you’ve taken it more calmly,” (437). The calm state that Shaila Bhave seems to be in does not mean she is handling the loss of her family well, instead her reaction implies that she is cut off from the world and is trying to find a way to deal with her tragedy. Shaila is experiencing both sides of the situation. She is being asked to sway people into accepting that their loved ones are gone, when she is not ready herself.…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With moments such as these in the book, the reader focuses more on whether or not Hulga ‘exaggerates’ her disability, rather than taking time to admire her for her confidence. Hulga is not allowed the readers sympathy or respect, since her successes of education being the item of commentary and her education being downgraded by her living with her…

    • 1370 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In my opinion, I strongly believe she will not change because of her experiences have a impact on her traits and values. In the text, she says “Why wouldn’t I be nice? I’m not a monster, after all.”(259, paragraph 2) This quote proves that Constancia will not change because at the beginning of the story, she thought she was already a nice person, but her actions showed that she clearly wasn’t. Sometimes we can’t trust a 1st person narrator. She strongly dislikes her grandma and doesn’t want to be next to her.…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social Norms In Brave

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Associated with the notion of social norms is conformity, where individuals perform certain behaviours in order to receive rewards whether it be social recognition or approval (Scheff, 1990, 71). Through punishments, feelings of shame and embarrassment, society maintains their current social order, which reinforces specific norms, values and beliefs (Scheff, 1990,71). Merida’s mother’s reactions and discourses directed towards correcting her daughter’s behaviour could be seen as acts of shaming. Instances of disapproval, discontent and disappointment can all be linked to processes of shame throughout the film. Although, the feelings of shame often go unnoticed, actions driven by the need to conform on the other hand can be observed (Scheff, 1990, 79).…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Rich could have factored the difficulties of many women not envisioning themselves as successful in a male dominated profession. Seeing that women were often expected to be mothers and housewives, the direction. This is why Rich says that women should claim their education. If women take control of their education, regardless of what others will say or think, they will take control of their futures. She says that students should “take responsibility towards ourselves” in our school work.…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The genre effectively explains the struggle of both women and people of color by using first person perspectives to help the reader more empathize with their situations. Maya Angelou’s “I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings” delivers an emotional autobiography that describes a black woman’s habits as an adult through her childhood experiences in a harsh society. This lasting work of merit effectively expresses the most common themes of the genre: self-identity only becomes solidified through men, society doesn’t allow black women to have control of their own bodies. A woman’s happiness in a household represents the last priority and the assertion of black woman’s power is threatening to white…

    • 2031 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Biss’s case, her family is more of a token of pain rather than a message of encouragement. She hides her pain from others, especially family, for the embarrassment it causes her. The scales of pain used by her family are not inclusive of her pain. The scale is based on the values of her parents’ perception of pain which do not acknowledge her…

    • 1569 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays