Montgomery Case Law: Adapting To Informed Consent

Improved Essays
Introduction
It has long been established that every doctor has a duty of care towards their patient. Therefore, a doctor will have breached their duty if they have been found to be negligent during the course of treating the patient. A breach of duty can arise in the form of being careless in the way that they treated a patient or in failing to alert them to any risks associated with procedures, which will be the focal point of this essay. It will identify how the law has changed in regards to the standard of care that should be offered to patients and whether it has succeeded in finding an appropriate balance between what the doctor thinks that the patient should know and what the patient actually wants to know in light of the Montgomery case.
…show more content…
Next, the previous and existing case law relating to informed consent will be looked at, examining the pros and cons to each of the tests laid out in them. It will then move on to focus on how Montgomery eradicated these problems, but also with it still contained some issues such as the objective reasonable manner in which the needs of each individual patient is judged. By reviewing cases, past and recent, it is hoped that there will be a clear comparison as to what tests have been successful in satisfying the conflicting struggles that arise in regards to both factors and overall it will be argued that the Montgomery case seems to have perfectly balanced the way in which good medical practice can be carried out whilst protecting and respecting patient

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    New York City College of Technology City University of New York Law and Ethics Case: Jeanette M. and the Phone Call Erica Rotstein October 7, 2017 Professor Bonsignore HAS 3560 -Legal Aspects of Health Care Abstract The advancement in the field of medicine over the years has led to doctors and health care providers having more responsibilities on their hands. This brings into question what should and shouldn’t be done, as well as what is morally and ethically right. However, this isn’t so cut and dry.…

    • 1877 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Informed consent was virtually unheard of in the early 1950’s. It was not until the early 70’s that informed consent began to play a significant role in healthcare. This time frame greatly affected the ethical lapses in Mrs. Lack’s case. Looking at this case in 2017, Mrs. Lacks autonomy was violated. Her decision to make choices on the potential circumstances of her situation was nonexistent (Butts & Rich, 2016).…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1962, Congress passed the Kefauver-Harris amendments; these laws placed restrictions on drug testing and also put in place a requirement for informed consent (Sparks). However, these laws were quite obviously ignored; if they had been more strongly enforced this case would have been over before it was started. Because of this, doctors like Golde were able to do things like this for years without informing their patients of their intentions. In order to take control of and revise this issue, stronger policies were made in 1980. One statement, released by the Committee of Ethics, is known as “Ethical Considerations Associated With Informed Consent:” this statement depicts the importance of patients’ autonomy and the control they have over their own bodies (ACOG).…

    • 1247 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He does this by laying out a four part list on which way the physician should guide the decision making process. This list is sorted by routine low risk procedures, minimal risk procedures, procedures with large benefits but high chance of success, and procedures where the risks can outweigh the benefits. These rules lay out a solid foundation unlike the other models of consent where the physician’s responsibilities are questionable. He also states that this is done by the physician explaining their thoughts to the patient and welcoming questions.…

    • 1486 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although both, Skloot and Callaway, assert that patients must receive an informed consent, Callaway’s argument is based…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1960s, doctors were more reserved by not telling their patients the truth about their diagnoses. The majority of physicians will not revealed the truth to their patient for the reason they wouldn’t want to harm them in any way leading them to any desperate acts. “Physicians now emphasizes patient autonomy and informed consent over paternalism.…

    • 359 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Often times doctors’ offices have long documents that must be signed in order for a person to see the doctor. Obtaining consent now a day is not as tricky and unlawful as it used to be, but most people do not know what they are signing. Lindy Marie Fields, MA; and James Douglas Calvert, PHD, MSCP are both associated with Southern Methodist University and say, “Obtaining consent continues to evolve and has come a long way since reliance upon simple consent, in which consent was presumed if the patient did not explicitly dissent” (Fields, Calvert). Patient consent has evolved dramatically, however most people still do not know what they are consenting to. There has also been a large step in patient confidentiality laws over the last forty years.…

    • 1995 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Informed consent is essential in nursing practice as it allows patients and health care providers to communicate effectively. It is not just signing a document instead it is used to inform the patient of, risk, alternative, benefit, and understanding of a procedure or treatment. Informed consent gives the patient the right to received treatment and the right to refused treatment or any other intermediations. However, there are three elements that the Joint Commission necessitates that health care providers must consider before offering the patient an informed consent including the information, voluntary consent, and competence (Westrick, 2014).…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Medical Malpractice Theory

    • 1563 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Literature Review: Theory The literature review is vital to the success of this paper as it will look at the past relevant theories and studies to help define important terms while theory in this paper will serve to help define medical malpractice. The first step is to determine when a doctor is liable to their patient, and the courts can use the entry rules (Stein, 2012) to help determine when a doctor is liable to their patients. Also entry rules also help determine when medical malpractice occurs (Stein, 2012), but the theory also acknowledges when these medical malpractices should be exempt with the creation of the exit rules (Stein, 2012). Ideally according to Stein's theory, medical institutions should govern entry rules as they…

    • 1563 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Doctor’s responsibilities are to help the patient to get them well and make them healthy and sound. But Some of the procedure which can be denied by the doctor because of its negative effect on patient. A doctor may refuse a patient’s request provided the refusal leaves the patient no worse off than the patient would have been had the patient never met that doctor in the first place. Even though sometimes, Doctors have more objections to filling patient request for certain procedures or objections may be on the medication that patients are having. When a doctor tries to figure out what is best for the patient, they must find out in both way how it is going to affect the patient or not but more consciousness is issue when someone comes to the…

    • 343 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Consent divides in three categories • Voluntary consent for treatment is solely based on individual decision, this must not being influence by anyone involved in individual life. • Informed individual has being given all the relevant information about treatment, the benefits and the risks and consequences if treatment is refused. • Capacity individual must…

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Medical treatment helped millions of people, but there are responsibilities that all health care professionals must abide by to ensure patients’ rights are supported. The established presumption is that every adult of sound mind has the right to decide what will be done to his or her body. Before any treatment is carried out on the patients’ body by any HCP, their consent must be obtained. Consent to treatment can be verbal, written or gestured/implied. The patient must have the capacity or competence, consent is given voluntarily and covers the procedure in question and the patient was informed clearly of the treatment and their risks.…

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The steps health care providers need to take in order to ensure patients understand the consent is go over treatment option, outcomes/complication, and likely of success and complications. Health care professionals must comprehend issues and trends; more lives could be saved. Based on individual right to self-determination and autonomy I don’t think that patient consent form adequately informs patient to their medical rights. Self-Determinations and Autonomy give the patients moral and legal right to what will be done to them. Health care professionals must respect individual’s wishes and this must be followed by legislation, ethics standards and overall society value.…

    • 1282 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The refusal of observations by John could potentially place his health at risk by preventing early detection of deterioration, this left the MDT with a moral dilemma. When discussing ethical dilemmas it was important in John’s case to involve all members of the MDT. Rich and Butts (2014) suggest that ethical decisions should involve all healthcare professionals in a patients care intervention. Similarly Finlay (2008) encourages the involvement of the patient in discussing ethical problems along with the healthcare professionals (in Ellis, 2015).…

    • 1540 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abstract Law is formed for a motive and it regulates in many areas like medicine, before practicing any medical procedure or conducting a form of administrative position each medical specialist or non-medical specialist operative must comprehend a difference between ethical or unethical. Ethical and Unethical plays a significant role in our humanity every way it is whether up to how you want to approach it. According to “The case of Jeanette M. And the phone call” altered from the beginning of chapter 1 of “Medical Law and Ethics” inscribed by Bonnie Fremgen, it exemplifies how a medical receptionist and the doctor action resulted in death of Jeanette M. This case falls into so many categories of violations and code of ethics such as being…

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays