Mirror Neurons Debate

Great Essays
Mirror Neurons: Discussion and Debates
The average human brain weighs only three pounds, yet the intricacy surrounding its capabilities are one of the most sought after mysteries, with regard to human anatomy. Dr. V.S. Ramachandran (2010) explains that the brain is the housing for approximately 100 billion neurons all interacting in a phenomenal number of differing connections. In studying how neural processes develop, mirror neurons were identified. Although this is a complex topic which involves knowledge of specific sections and functions of the brain, for the purpose of this paper, a broad sense of how mirror neurons work and some of the debates surrounding these explanations will be discussed.
Dr. Ramachandran (2010) asserts that it has been long understood that ordinary motor command neurons located in the frontal section of the brain will fire with certain actions such as reaching for an object. Interestingly, the same neurons will fire while observing an individual reaching for an item as if the neurons are adopting an outside perspective simply by observation. This discovery is due to mirror neurons which are subsets of motor
…show more content…
This claim is to say that mirror neurons have the capacity to see an action performed by another, take that information in, and understand the meaning behind the action. Thus, observing information creates insight into the meaning of the action observed. Problems arise with this explanation because an individual may perform an action which has no meaning or purpose behind it. For example; thrashing about may have no meaning, yet it is performing an action, nonetheless. This is different from reaching for an object for the purpose of grasping it. However, it should be noted that there are varying degrees to the definition of “action understanding” (Rizzolatti & Craighero,

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    When Brains Attack Summary

    • 1800 Words
    • 8 Pages

    “When Brains Attack” Podcast By: Robert Krulwich & Jad Abumrad (1 hour long) Brains are amazing. They have so much power and control over us; that sometimes one feels as if they are a completely separate force from us that can go against our will. In this podcast they tell us four stories of how the brain took a course of it’s own. From a fiber optic wire in a mouse’s brain, to a change in space position, to secrets our brain keeps from us, to a complete power out of a section of the brain, we will learn of how our brains control our viewpoint of the world surrounding us.…

    • 1800 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1988, Willian T. Newsome and Edmond B. Paré have conducted a research on motion perception. One of the goals of their research was to find out the importance of the middle temporal area in mammals’ brains. In order to achieve this goal, they had to use nonhuman primates for the fact that monkeys’ brains are closely similar to the human brains. In their released article, the researchers explained point by point how they proceeded such experiment and also left possibilities for future research. Newsome and Paré trained a group of monkeys on how to identify motion by looking at dots in motion.…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The man who explored the mysteries of the human brain in a series of best-selling books succumbed to cancer at the age of 82. According to a report from Daily Mail, renowned neurologist and writer Oliver Sacks, who announced last February that he has rare eye cancer that had spread, died at the age of 82 today, August 30. Sacks, who had lived in New York since 1965, authored several other books about unusual medical conditions, including The Man Who Mistook His Wife For A Hat and The Island Of The Colorblind, BBC reported.…

    • 423 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The human brain is a complex organ. No one fully understands how the brain works; therefore, how can we decide whether a person is brilliant or insane? A vast amount of untapped potential still lays dormant within us. Slight abnormalities, people who appear to act or look different, are often seen as appalling and rejected by society. However, these differences are sometimes the keys to advancements in knowledge.…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Empathy In Footloe

    • 1813 Words
    • 8 Pages

    When a primate, (or human) observes a particular action, for example a jump in ‘Footloose’ or a punch in ‘Rocky I’, the brain cells activated are the same as those that would be activated had the audience member engaged in the motion themselves (Landay, 131). This system is more accurate and active depending on the viewer’s level of understanding of the movement performed. Someone who is not a professional boxer or who has not undergone significant training may not experience the empathy of mirror-neurons when watching the montage scene in ‘Rocky I’. Similarly, aside from recognising the natural movement of the flashback scenes and the act of drinking from a bottle, in the angry dance scene in ‘Footloose’, the dance movement is not guaranteed to activate the mirror neurons of the audience unless they have experienced the similar motions, themselves in the past. An audience member’s initial response to action can motivate their positive embodied response, or negative disembodied response just as the mirror-neuron system is more active depending on the viewer's level of understanding.…

    • 1813 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Is there only one way to recount history? According to the countless classes, textbooks, and aisles upon aisles of nonfiction - no. Evidently, history is in the eyes of the beholder. A Different Mirror by Ronald Takaki and Stories from American History by Myrtis Mixon are two such texts that show how the same history can be recounted in different manners.…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Computers and Craniums: A Continuing Cycle of Connections The enigma of the human mind is a puzzle that has fascinated many great scientists. From the earliest musings of the ancient philosophers to the advanced neuroscience research going on today, many intelligent people have worked to understand what is going on in our own heads. In an interesting phenomenon, our understanding of the mind is intimately linked to the technology that is used to study it, and the new findings that arise feed directly back into the development of new tools. As scientific equipment has become capable of better observing the brain and human behavior, the mind has come to be understood more as an incredibly complex machine than as an incomprehensible mass residing…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For my response paper, I decided to reflect on Synesthesia. Synesthesia is a nerve condition where a person experiences two senses at one time. This condition happens when one sense triggers another one. For example, if someone sees an image they will be able to hear what they see within the image. This phenomenon’s name derives from the Greek, meaning "to perceive together", comes in many varieties (Carpenter, 2001).…

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Measuring Brain Activity to Reconstruct Visual Experiences The principle of perpetual evidence states that brain activity is not random, and that the processes we use in mental visualizations are used in visual perception as well. The firing of neurons that occurs when one imagines shooting a free throw are the same neurons that fire when actually doing so. The fact that brain activity is complex and calculated has helped scientists see how the brain functions, and what areas are associated with certain tasks or thoughts. Nishimoto et al conducted a thorough and unprecedented experiment that has helped many understand the functioning of the brain, specifically, how brain activity relates to the perception of visual information (1).…

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In an article written by Alan Kingstone, Chris Friesen, and Michael Gazzaniga they are discussing a study about gaze reflection and reflexive joint attention. They used two similar people to conduct multiple experiments to test out their hypothesis. In the article, Reflexive Joint Attention Depends on Lateralized Cortical Connections, their hypothesis was that the reflexive attention in response to gaze direction correlates with the hemisphere specialized for processing faces.…

    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For example, if someone were to hit you when you did the wrong task at work or school then you will be more inclined to do the same to another person because that is what your mirror neurons have observed. For Aylmer, his mirror neurons have seen perfection in his scientific studies. They know nothing different so when his wife, all but perfect in regards to the birthmark on her cheek arrives they know not what to do. They must fix it and his pride-the part of his brain that would normally dampen the impulse to make everything perfect- goes along.…

    • 1740 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Indirect realism as the more plausible perception theory Indirect realism is a more plausible theory of perception than direct realism. Direct realism was first described by Aristotle. He described how a seer learns about an object by directly seeing it impressed on the eye. In other words, it is where external material objects are directly experienced, without sense-data (Bernecker, 2008).…

    • 1301 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Because of my new understanding of our Mirroring Neurons (77) I would love to find a great leader and work with or under their guidance to develop these skills. When our program at…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ramachandran knows how to get the facts by asking the right set of questions. He examines questions throughout the book and points out fallacies in the work of past philosophers. Positives: • Clear and fluent descriptions of neurological phenomena and their relationship with physiological mechanisms, philosophy of mind keeps the reader enthralled • Dr. Ramachandran comes across as an enthusiast in search of the secrets of the human mind and keeps the reader involved. • The illustrations, informative drawings and images of human brain add value by helping the reader understand better • Illustrations on optical phenomenon engages the reader Negatives • It has repeated mentions of same patients and this reappearance could have been done away with • Dr. Ramachandran focusses too much on his work and does not mention much about research by others in this field Ravneet Singh, NMIMS | Roll No…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In virtually every language, the term for Abirthmark@ can be translated as some variant of the terms Aenvy,@ Awish,@ Alonging,@ or “mother’s mark.” Does this suggest anything to you about what people in the past thought might be the causes of birthmarks? something the mother did caused the birth mark?…

    • 10459 Words
    • 42 Pages
    Great Essays