Mike Lynn: Whistleblower

Good Essays
Mike Lynn was a professional and as a professional it is sometimes your duty to speak out for the right moral reasons. He decided to be a whistleblower because he thought the information that he is hiding needs to be told to other people. He may have cost his company a lot of money or even have exposed them to legal matters but in the end he did the most responsible thing a man could’ve done in his position. It’s wrong for a company to hide its flaws. Even though a lawsuit was filed against him, he didn’t regret the decision of being a whistleblower. There is a responsibility for each person to think of society instead of only thinking about his business or company and Mike Lynn did exactly that. The company wanted him to be a controlled puppet …show more content…
Cisco and ISS also had a responsibility to protect their own data and also the data of their clients to whom they provided cyber security. In future maybe the company would’ve changed its way without being exposed to lawsuits and hackers. Mike Lynn left them in a really bad situation as they had to change or modify their systems to avoid problems that were created by the leakage of company information. Mike Lynn may have done the right thing but it was still illegal and harmful to the company. It’s extremely illogical for a company to reveal its own secrets and flaws at a conference where they know it can hurt them very badly. Cisco’s internet systems were also protecting their client’s data which might have been compromised due to this leakage. Cisco had to calculate the risk of exposing that information and it just wasn’t in favour of the company in any way and that’s what businesses are about. Cisco and ISS were right because they didn’t want their organizations to be compromised or to become liable to legal action against them. They both suffered or may have even lost some valuable information to their competitors. Mike Lynn as an employee also had a responsibility to do what the employer told him to do but instead he revealed sensitive information that could’ve …show more content…
Cisco Systems were trying to safeguard the interests of their clients but they were not able to find the right way to assess a solution in their system which will provide better security of the data of their clients. Cisco and ISS also needed to be a little more cooperative in solving the problem rather than throwing a blanket over it so that their business is not affected. Cisco and ISS could’ve assured Mike Lynn that this problem was going to be looked upon but instead they gave him a different topic to talk about which resulted in resignation of Mike Lynn. The internet routers were also at constant risk of getting hacked into since they weren’t completely protected by Cisco. Cyber security is a very sensitive matter as internet is supposed to be a place where your data could stay private but lately it hasn’t been the case. The problem could’ve been addressed by insurance from both parties that they won’t take a rash action without consulting each other first. Mike Lynn got frustrated after he was forced to stay quiet over a matter which he thought was necessary for others to know but also it wasn’t good for Cisco’s business. There needs to be an understanding between the employer and the employee which wasn’t present in this case causing a near disaster situation. Mike Lynn could also have been more patient and waited a bit more

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    To begin with, the company ZZZZ Best didn’t have the best internal control. It felt like falsifying the information would never come out and bring consequences. To maintain an ethical environment internally, the company should have constructed a strong internal control to avoid any unethical events leading to fraud. Another flag would be the way how the contracts were created with some miscalculated and false information. There should…

    • 1404 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Kick The Habit Essay

    • 768 Words
    • 4 Pages

    But if the person is free from any criminal record, then the employer mustn’t interfere with his personal information. You want security? Well, we do as well! But along with security, we need to be reassured that our personal privacy is secure. Governments around the world are failing to keep people’s privacy since they do not keep the data they have confidential, they use social networks to invade people’s privacy doing so without informing them about it, and the whole process of privacy invasion hasn’t proved to be totally efficient in most countries.…

    • 768 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Mark became uncomfortable with the change because it would impact the latter phases of the project’s design, milestones and consequently the business objective. Upon investigating how the alteration took place, Mark learned that Harold was the decision maker in an effort to put his own personal touch in the software (Columns Besieged: Rogue Employee or Managerial Void, pg. 132). Harold’s decision to make a change in the software without his lead-producers approval is of technical ineptitude as he clearly was not aware, misunderstood, or simply disregarded the organizational values and goal objectives. We can determine that his decision on this matter was influenced by his personal, professional and organization values, along with role conflicts that led him to that unethical choice of views, values and goals as charted in Figure 2 Role Episodic Models of Ethical Dilemma in HRM (KC Wooten / Human Resource Management Review II, 2001, 159 – 175).…

    • 1121 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the case of law, “reasonable efforts” must be taken by the company in order to fully make a strong claim in court if there was dismissal of trust between the company and its relative employee (Evans, 2012). CleverTech did not focus on claiming full intellectual rights over the the designs and ideas; however, with their management consistently reminding employees about the importance of their trade secrets - this may suffice in the court of law that needed precautions were taken. If CleverTech somehow found OpenTech to be using their trade secrets in a design product, CleverTech may be in a fair position to submit a lawsuit against OpenTech (Evans, 2012). This could be highly detrimental to the much smaller company, OpenTech. Likewise, if CleverTech does not win the lawsuit, OpenTech’s decision to use the trade secrets and make them OpenSource and available to all could put CleverTech out of the race to market.…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Metaethics is the ethical value in which each individual has to determine for themselves what is right and what is wrong for each situation. For example, the idea to release the fact that a high ranking official with very sensitive information was using this information on a private non-secured (or at least not as secured as government regulated computers are) might have seen right to the individual at the time but could prove to be wrong in the eyes of society. Whistleblowers in general face backlash by the media and in turn the people who only hear the side that the media portrays. Many times, the full story is never known to the general public unless there is criminal activity involved and even then, you are never fully sure of what is the complete story. In this case, bringing to light the email server issue might have been the right idea but only of done to an agency such as the FBI for investigation and the CIA or NSA because of possible data breeches from their departments.…

    • 1708 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Ipremier Case Summary

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Ultimately he should be making the decisions since the responsibility relies on him. Because they were not aware of the severity of the attack, Turley should have ordered the system to be fully shut down, even if it meant losing the data that would help the company figure out what happened. If the website was hacked, not shutting it down could have meant risking customers credit card numbers. Dealing with stolen data and expense of the fallout of people’s personal information leaking is far more detrimental to the company than losing information about how the attack…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This policy would have given advice to avoid issues that would arise by careless use of the media by being derogatory, offensive or derogatory even though it was satirical. Whoever, sees the site it can create the wrong image of the company if an employee like Allen can try to undermine ExtremeNet and continue to work for…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Ethical Dilemma Situation

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages

    My best friend seems to be more concerned about the arrest becoming public information and having his name and reputation ruined. His actions also call into question his ability to be an honest and trustworthy police officer. The simple fact that he lied on his application tells me that. He is also placing a huge burden on my shoulders. I do not want to see my best friend get in trouble or fired for something we did many years ago, but I also am not willing to lie on my application and start my career in law enforcement off on a lie.…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Owen may be upset to find out about Luke knowing all along, however, the ethical thing to do is to keep company information private. We can also apply the Utilitarianism method to conclude that the most affected or harmed by this situation would be the company since Luke’s decision may lead to other consequences. If more people find out about the change in property value, then more people would be opposed to the announcement. Luke cannot guarantee that Owen won’t tell others either voluntarily or involuntarily, as in someone over hearing him speaking about the situation. With that in mind, Luke should keep to himself what he knows.…

    • 1878 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The first being the security of personally identifiable information. Now in this instance the company itself is not fully responsible for this release but they are indirectly responsible. The hackers are directly responsible for the dissemination of the users personal data but the company could have avoided this incident by shutting down but chose not to which directly constitutes a breach of privacy and security proposed by the company to protect the users information. The next issue is the release of users information that paid the company the fee of $19 to delete their information. The company decided not to delete the users information for some reason from their servers.…

    • 1516 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays