The Case For Reality TV By Michael Hirschorn

Improved Essays
Reality television has evolved over the decades and many people see it going in a downward spiral, in greater quantities and lower quality of content. In the article The Case for Reality TV by Michael Hirschorn he defends reality television, claiming that people often take these shows for face value and do not look for the deeper meaning behind them. He uses shows a wide range of reality shows and express that these shows are not only for entertainment value but also good mediums for social commentary. Also, Hirschorn includes how effective competitive shows are adept at explaining what people would do, much like an experiment, and are a good medium when explaining complex ideas. He uses reality television 's underlying factors and themes that …show more content…
His overall argument that reality TV is beneficial matches with this statement because Hirschorn believes to not look at reality shows and take them literally or face value. Instead he believes it is necessary that shows be more deeply observed and says, “The competitions and elimination shows are latter-day Milgram experiments that place real people in artificial situations,”(Hirschorn 1). This statement explains how crucial these shows are in describing what people do in these controlled environments. Hirschorn also includes the Survivor and describes it as a,”fantasy and more a metaphor for an imagined post-­apocalyptic future,” (Hirschorn 1), giving the show a Lord of the Flies storyline, but with fun competitions; and instead of kids dying contestants get voted off the island. Also, in these quotes he makes good use of metaphors by comparing reality shows to “Milgram experiments” and “an imagined post-apocalyptic future,”. As a result Hirschorn makes the reader think of these shows as metaphors for how people will act in real life in these environments given through the reality show. It is also effective because by comparing shows to the “Milgram experiment” says that the shows are able to generate plots and environments that are similar to experiments, with controlled variables and conclusions based on observation. His comparison to experiments is important because he sees realizes that we can use reality shows like The Survivor for reference if we ever go into a similar situation. This supports Hirschorn’s argument because he sees the benefit of using reality television as metaphors for what people would do in real life. and sees reality shows as useful references if a similar situation would

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    He takes a look at earlier shows like The Love Boat and The Newlywed Game and compares them to newer shows like The Apprentice and Survivor. He explains how earlier reality TV is more structured, and the rules are mapped out beforehand, in turn requiring less focus to pay attention. Johnson compares the structural similarities in reality TV today to that of a video game. “…the rules aren’t fully established at the outset. You learn as you play” (290).…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Q: Describe the relationships of Katniss with Gale, Prim, and with her mother. A: Katniss has interesting relationships with all three of these characters. Gale and Katniss are childhood friends, having both grown up in District 12. Katniss isn't entirely certain about her feelings for Gale, but becomes even more confused about her feelings when Peeta gets thrown into the mix.…

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When the Girl Scout Research Institute conducted a survey it was shown that “Many girls think these programs reflect reality, with… 50% saying that real-life shows are “mainly real and unscripted.” This is influencing the way children and teenagers think, making them believe that females are ill-natured creatures. Equally as important as the last statement, reality tv play into stereotypical beliefs. West Virginia Senator, Joe Manchin, says that Jersey Shore, a reality tv show, “plays to ugly, inaccurate stereotypes.” Buckwild being set in West Virginia feeds to the belief all West Virginians are hillbillies or rednecks.…

    • 329 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Reality Show Culture

    • 1035 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The common values spread by reality TV include materialism and as previously mentioned,…

    • 1035 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Real, the Bad, and the Ugly by Cassie Heidecker is an interesting example of analyzing the reality TV epidemic and in addition to the people that view it. The author starts out by listing things that go into a reality TV production and things that happen in real life in order to state that these are two different things despite the idea that reality TV is supposed to be “real”. The mundanity of real life is emphasised here vs. the idea that reality TV is scripted and has a lot of extra work put into it to make reality TV more appealing to a broader audience. The author goes on to say that real life is boring which I thought was funny and a little ironic considering that later the author mentions that she is somebody who sets aside time…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Empire Observation

    • 1289 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The show brought up many topics that trend today, some are not fully accepted, and other topics are forming controversies. Media has advantages and disadvantages, it can help to easily communicate, but it also promotes false advertising. False advertising betrays what life really is like—it’s not real. Instead of being content with who we are, or what we have,…

    • 1289 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Reality television is known for multiple stereotypes that surround it and most of the shows go along with them. These stereotypes include but are not limited to; being confined into one specific space or location, a certain of number people from multiple demographics and backgrounds, and having some type of motivator, usually monetary. The reality show, “Big Brother” follows all of these stereotypes but also brings a type of relevance to its viewers. Following the guidelines from the novel, “1984” , the reality television show maintains a constant watch on the house’s contestants, who perform and entertain in order to be the last housemate standing, and sometimes this performance can reach new heights. The reality show demonstrates the lengths…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mothering the Movement was a lecture examining the active involvement of Black women during the Black Freedom Movement throughout the 20th century led by Dr. Derek Brooms on Wednesday January 18th. “Women are the heartbeat of the civil rights movement. Women are the caretakers and nurturers in this movement and within society,” said Associate Professor of Sociology at the University of Louisville Dr. Derek Brooms. Dr. Derek Brooms began the lecture by playing the song ‘Trouble in Mind’ sung by several Black women of the civil rights era. “I started out with women’s voices, so you can hear the power they had within the community,” said Dr. Derek Brooms.…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a popular TV show “Bones”, lead character Dr. Brennan Bones, socially awkward, but brilliant anthropologist, believes that reality television show “Jersey Shore” is actually a documentary about a tribe called “Guidos”. Although she is mistaken about the genre of that show, her assumptions about their language and customs is not far off. Using the same observation methods, future anthropologists might conclude that the basic human need for entertainment hasn’t changed since gladiator games in Rome, and that people are willing to do anything for money. There is a lot of information that future anthropologists can gather from reality television, but the truth is, it is misleading because most of it, if not all, is scripted. A better question…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Reality televisions portrayal of the “real” while using formulaic scripts and editing clearly begins…

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Reality television ranges from judgement shows, to shows that help others, for example, the show Catfish is where two guys attempt to help average people, who have fallen in love with another person online. This show is very popular because every episode is different. Also, one of the guys has personally gone through this experience in which he met a girl online and they fell in love. When it time for them to meet, the girl he met was different from the girl he fell in love with online. In short, the girl lied to him, and because of this experience, it has resulted in this show which helps others meet the people they have met or fallen in love with online, finally meet in person.…

    • 1255 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In her essay “Getting Real With Reality TV,” Cynthia Frisby examines how Reality TV has became one of the most watched television programs. Frisby then discusses her beliefs that, while watching Reality TV programs, viewers tend to draw comparisons between themselves and the reality star. She then gathers a team of researchers who conduct surveys that ask simple questions about participants relationship with Reality TV, and the team performs a content analysis on these participants while they view certain Reality TV programs. Ultimately, she suggests that her research shows that almost all participants showed some type of comparison between themselves and the reality star. Throughout her essay, Frisby uses adequate amounts of evidence to support…

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even if you do not watch reality television, odds are that you know who Taylor Swift is dating or have tried the Kylie Kardashian lip challenge. In fact, reality television has consumed not only are televisions, but magazines, and even the news. Reality TV was born on May 21, 1992 with the premier of The Real World, ever since reality TV has become America 's new guilty pleasure. Americans and society as a whole is obsessed with reality television, and have even become infatuated with reality stars. Reality shows have flooding the television industry, with over 2000 shows on the network today.…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Reality Tv Film Analysis

    • 1524 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The message presented by Bravo, but more importantly the scope of reality television as a whole is that ordinary people can become important overnight. Wealth can accumulate to any degree. The thrill to viewers of reality television is of the potential to become millionaires and celebrities overnight. How reality television has the potential to make ordinary people celebrities overnight is what will contribute most to our collective memory. “The stories of the past presented in media, especially on television, are far more visceral than those presented in the classroom” (Edy, Journalistic Uses of Collective…

    • 1524 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Reality Tv Influence

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Reality television has been growing more over the past few years. There are celebrities that have their own reality show and normal people could be in one as well. Many people like to watch reality shows. Reality shows don’t only benefit the people that watch the shows, but also the watchers because there are people who get obsessed with the shows. Reality television is about people with an unscripted television show and cameras are following their every move.…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays