Metaphysics: Same Real Memory Argument

Decent Essays
One of the primary arguments within the topic of metaphysics is “same real memory, same person” argument. With that you have the conflict between the “duplication argument” and “memory argument.” The duplication argument essentially states that you have two identical people with the same set of original memories. The memory argument says that if person one transfers all their memories to person two, then person two has now become person one. In other words, wherever the memory or consciousness goes, so goes the person. The duplication argument is a direct attempt to refute the claims made by the memory theory. It does so by contending that if you have two people with the same memories, they will eventually become different people because

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Memory is what we remember, and gives us the capacity to learn and acclimate from past ordeals as well as establishing relationships. It is also the process of being able to recall previously learned knowledge, experiences, beliefs, talents and habits. One aspect of memory is called semantic memory. Semantic memory is how we are able to understand and comprehend the meanings of various things such as words and knowing facts about the world. It is the second part of declarative memory along with episodic memory.…

    • 175 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The dynamics of any family can be complicated. A family that is in a strange country will have even more stress than the average family, especially if that family does not speak the language of the land, and is unfamiliar with the customs. This is the situation for Richard Rodriguez 's family as explained in his autobiography Hungar of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez. In his memoir, Rodriguez explains the transfermation he makes during his education.…

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In The Impossible Knife of Memory, life for Hayley Kincain isn’t like the typical teenage girl. Hayley deals with living with her dad Andy, who struggles with PTSD. The terrible memories Andy deals with from post war in Iraq makes him unstable and on the road frequently. Five years after traveling around in a truck across the country, Hayley and Andy move back into their home town in order for Hayley to live a normal life and go to high school. Hayley, who has been schooled by her dad and hasn’t had much physical contact besides her dad and his war friends, struggles to fit into her so-called “zombie” high school.…

    • 359 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In comparison, recalling memory can be an extremely complicated process; not only the memory of the fact itself, but also ways of interpreting the memory are required to recall memories. Especially when interpreting…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although there are a lot of arguments raised against the memory theory, I believe personal…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Well, I was reading about this philosopher Gretchen Weirob and she argues that following the operation in which Julia’s brain is transplanted into Mary Frances’ body, the resulting person will be identical to Mary Frances for the reason that the body is what makes the person, and I disagree for the reason that I believe that it is same consciousness same person. Weirob when making her position on the Mary Frances case is very careful so that she does not give any room for any other case other than the body is what makes the person. A lot of her arguments are very well formed so that they both improve her point while rejecting the other's points. Her very first argument she starts by saying “ if my refusal to submit to this procedure amounts to suicide, then the survivor of Julia North’s operation must be reckoned…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Twin of the Truth is One’s Memories Memories are a recollection of experiences one recalls and keeps with them in their hearts and mind. Kan Gan’s interactive novel, To The Moon, primarily illustrates the differentiation of truth and memory throughout the entire play. Gan establishes that a memory is not necessarily the truth, even though one may gain greater happiness from it. Some memories are fabricated by people to remember happier times and to forget the worst.…

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Crebrum Research Paper

    • 376 Words
    • 2 Pages

    the memories that you made live in The cerebrum ( the pair short term and long term). Scientists have a theory that The cerebrums 2 sides have different characteristics about you. The right side Being the more creative side and the left side being the more intelligent side. Plus Scientists absolutely know that the right side of controls the left side…

    • 376 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Brain's False Memory

    • 1796 Words
    • 8 Pages

    This syndrome “...has been reported since the late 1980s” (“False Memories” 278). A group of people can vividly remember an event. But, when it comes to recalling what occurred, each individual recalls it in a different way in correlation to how their brain was able to store it. Therefore, each individual has their own false memory stored.…

    • 1796 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    You are the same you just learning and experiencing new things everyday. When you start throwing in silly conditions like the duplicate argument is when it is questioned, but the duplicate theory is nearly impossible there can’t be two you’s at a time the argument can not be true. Even if you are duplicated the duplicate will start to wonder of different things and go through different experiences so he will be going down a new path and you are no longer numerically duplicates. That 's why the replies to the argument seem very flimsy as well. It 's hard to go against things that is to great of a thing that is nearly impossible.…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Personal Identity Concept

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages

    An example of this is having no memory of being asleep while not dreaming, or being completely unconscious. It can be argued that even under these conditions personal identity can be preserved. So, even after this period of unconsciousness, a relation still remains among the mental contents of past and present persons. An individual has the capacity to preserve memories from the earlier experiences of the past individual; thus, even without having absolute clarity of recalling preceding events, the mental contents of the present individual are continuous of that of the past person.…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Furthermore B would not be justified in his belief of P as he/she would have justification for retaining the apparent memories but would not be justified in his/her acquisition of the memory. I would respond by asserting that if we were to blindly question A and B, there would be no way in telling whose memory acquisition is genuine or not. The fact that they have the same memories makes it so that their thought process and knowledge in general is exactly the same. Using Russell’s hypothesis, it is clear that Huemer’s theory fails, as it does not offer the full answer for how we can be justified in our…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They say you cannot repeat the past no matter how much you want it to reoccur. Many are stuck on the idea that a past event, a significant memory, can happen again. Like in the book The Great Gatsby, Gatsby, a young man trying to get the attention of his old flame, Daisy, wants things to be like they were before. He left for the war and later made a fortune in order to be with Daisy and marry her. By the time Gatsby went back for her, she was already with another man, making Gatsby do anything in his power to get Daisy back.…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A madman can mistakenly think that he can remember leading the French troops at the battle of Waterloo – those memory-like experiences cannot be genuine memories. Only Napoleon could genuinely remember leading the French troops into battle. (Beebee and Dodd, P. 11) This passage is an example of the circular objection theory transpiring. The theory does not intend to falsify other theories, however in order to figure out if person A and person B are the ‘same person’, we are depending on the true (facts) memories and experiences of both individuals (Beebee and Dodd, P. 11).…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Distortion Of Memory

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Memory is the encoding, storage and retrieval of past events and experiences, it is present in the short term memory store and then transferred to the long term memory store. The retrieval of memory isn’t always accurate as memories become distorted over time. The distortion of these memories are due to some influencing factors such as language, age, reconstructive errors and emotion. Taking all these factors into consideration leads to the point that memory is only to some extent reliable. Language plays a big role in how we remember, language is used to convey how we remembered the event but it is also a influence on how we remembered the event.…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays