Ugly Byproduct Analysis

Superior Essays
Bibliography: Merchant, G. (n.d.). SUSTAINABLE ENERGY TECHNOLOGIES: TEN LESSONS FROM THE HISTORY OF TECHNOLOGY REGULATION. Widner Law Journal, Vol. 18(3), p831–858. In-line Citation: (merchant, n.d.), retrieved from http://web.b.ebscohost.com.ezproxy3.lhl.uab.edu/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=5&sid=4090b5f0-7ad9-4764-942b-653defd97698%40sessionmgr120&hid=107

Overview
Technological innovation is what drives the economy. Innovation brings to the world many of the products and services society enjoys. An ugly byproduct can lead to impacts to the environment. The author points out that while these innovations from the past have contributed to pollution, they can also be the solution to the inherent downside to these innovations. He refers
…show more content…
If a one-size-fits all approach is used to deal with the problem of pollution or reduced energy consumption, it could negatively impact a region where a certain required application is ill suited. Some states may be better suited to wind power as opposed to solar power. He refers back to the California LEV program.
Other states could opt into these standards, however, California’s sulfur standards were much lower than in other states. In order for the program to work, the standards were based on the sulfur content of the fuel.
LESSON 9
This lesson shows the constraints of regulatory deadlines. He states that there is no particular significance of a deadline. Sticking to a hard deadline can limit what positive progress is made. He again refers to the California ZEV program. The state chose a hard deadline which caused an all or nothing effect. This was unfortunate because battery technology continued to progress even though it may not have made the deadline. He suggests that had California been a little more flexible, EVs may have made further progress over a longer time
…show more content…
He attempts to show that technology is not all good, nor all bad. Progress, technology and government support is neither good just one either. He uses examples from different situations to show how technology, government, special interest groups, society, regions and states can either make or break a policy, a technology or methodology. He shows how the diverse influences can make life better or even inadvertently restrict a break through even though there may be technical data to prove otherwise, or even no data at all, to support an adverse position. His point seems to be to first dispel the fact that there is no magic potion to cure all environmental ills. It may involve many groups and approaches, but that even these need to be given their proper due diligence. If nothing else, mistakes will be made, but that we can learn from the missteps of the past and if not eliminate them, at least gain insight to future approaches to solving large issues dealing with the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The final outcome essentially depends on one’s personal values. For those that are money and development driven, ensuring that all risks are completely mitigated without any scientific reason may prove cumbersome and a waste of resources. However to those that have the best interests of the environment and the health of other humans at heart, the precautionary principle is a viable approach. Cameron and Abouchar (1991) indicates that even though not all the scientific evidence has been presented to the world on many environmental issues there is enough evidence for educational mind to act upon. Waiting for all the evidence will result in us waiting forever thus action should be taken now to prevent future disasters as it costs far less in implementing preventive measures.…

    • 1293 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Renewable energy sources such as water, the wind, biofuel, and solar have little or no carbon emissions and, therefore, scores highly well in the replacement of fossil fuels. However, the cost of eliminating these emissions through renewable energy is high for all the alternatives. However, when considering the potential for the reduction of the emissions, wind power holds the best potential for reducing the emissions followed by biofuels and solar energy scoring the lowest on the list. Even with the existing differences in the cost of reducing emission from the fossil fuels, it is possible to control the cost and amount of carbon emissions under certain conditions. With the available alternative sources of energy such as the wind, solar, biomass, and nuclear energy for fossil fuels, the article outlines that renewable energy remains sidelined due to not only the costs and availability but also due to the low net energy ratio and capital intensity (Timmons, 2015).…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Yes. A well designed cap and trade system and carbon tax both have the potential to cut emissions cost effectively in line with climate and energy objectives while offsetting the disproportionate impact of higher energy prices. However, with the cap and trade system, the price of carbon emissions may be more than the estimated benefits of carbon emission abatement. The cap and trade system would also be more difficult to implement, as there is the additional process of allocating a carbon emission allowance. Increasing the gasoline tax is also not as effective as the carbon tax.…

    • 1324 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Jaffe and Palmer (1997) first distinguished among the “weak,” “narrow,” and “strong” versions of the Porter Hypothesis. First, properly designed environmental regulation may spur innovation (as shown in the first two boxes of Figure 1). This has often been called the “weak” version of the Porter Hypothesis because it does not indicate whether that innovation is good or bad for firms. Of course, the notion that regulation may spur technological innovation is not a new idea in economics and would not itself have led to the controversy about the Porter Hypothesis. Second part of the Porter Hypothesis (the lower right-hand side of Figure 1) is that in many cases this innovation more than offsets any additional regulatory costs—in other words, environmental regulation can lead to an increase in firm competitiveness.…

    • 1670 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    You can prevent this by cleaning your solar panel regularly. #3 Rechargeable Battery Could Be Faulty If the batteries in your lighting equipment are faulty, it may reduce its performance as well. Another possible thing that could lead to this is if the battery is already dead. As long as this continues, you can enjoy your lighting equipment, as you should because the performance will be subpar. #4 Mismanagement of the Solar Light This is another strong reason you could be getting a low performance from your equipment.…

    • 985 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Disadvantages Of Syngas

    • 2133 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Syngas, though has lower energy contents when compared with methane, which has been previously utilized [17-24] as reactive gas in OTR. Notwithstanding, syngas is considered in the present work due to its great stability and predictability, high thermal and electrical efficiencies, can be produced from renewable sources and has reduced carbon emissions. Mesh of 36000 grid points was generated using GAMBIT 2.4 software and the computations were carried out using the CFD commercial code FLUENT 14.0. The membrane type LSCF-6428 was utilized for oxygen separation in the modelling as they are reported to have high oxygen partial pressure and are chemically stable at elevated temperature. The transfer of oxygen through the membrane was modelled with the aid of user defined functions (UDF).…

    • 2133 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Zachary Schwadel 301331148 Tutorial D107 November 15, 2017 Word Count: 1162 Is Pollution Exaggerated? Background In the article “The Truth About the Environment”, Bjorn Lomborg challenges the global concern of atmospheric and oceanic pollution by suggesting it is “exaggerated” or simply “transient” due to early industrial revolution. He continues to claim that an increase in economic prosperity and becoming “rich” (defined in this analysis as high GDP per capita in a global context) will reduce pollution as wealthier nations become more concerned with pollution. Later in the paper Lomborg suggests facing every facet of an issue is necessary to have proper discourse relating to pollution, and currently it is impossible as bias based off who…

    • 1163 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Madyira et al.,[5]. In This paper, Daniel M. Madyira reports on analysis and study of using sunflower oil as an diesel blends for the production of biodiesel as alternatives to diesel fuel. Biofuels are now recognized as an alternative viable option. Some of the difficulties of using biodiesel in conventional diesel engines are their higher viscosity, acidity levels that influences the structural integrity of the engine and low density which results in low calorific value and leading to incomplete combustion. In this process, in the presence of Sodium hydroxide catalyst and methanol batch transesterfication is applied to sunflower oil for the production of biodiesel.…

    • 1110 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The disadvantages are the cost up front and some of the technology is not adequate enough. The more solar panels the companies have the less pollution there will be. The cameras will also stop pollution because they can detect gas and they can collect it before it pollutes the environment. The cameras and solar panels cost a lot at first, but they save money in the long run. They will only have to pay for repairs.…

    • 1622 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    They have a clear objective that they want to offset emission of some Co2 intensive energy. However, they do not clearly show how they act to get the target achieved in the report. According to Poulsen, Tobiasz, Pattiiha, Stensborg (2014), Carlsberg would purchase the certificate to offset the Co2 emission. With the certificate to prove that Carlsberg use the renewable energy to emit so that they can reduce the Co2 emission. They did not have a clear action on what they have done .Otherwise, they just claimed that they have brought the 372800 megawatt-hour of electricity but do not have the clear action to show that .Their target is not measurable so that it is not clear to show that their target.…

    • 3754 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Great Essays