Brokeback Mountain Essay

Improved Essays
From Rotten Tomatoes to Roger Ebert, film reviews are informative literary mediums through which critics analyze a film’s overall quality, with the goal of distinguishing whether or not the film is worth watching. A film review has a typical structure: it is comprised of an introduction that provides basic background information about the film, actors, producers, and directors. It is generally followed by a brief plot summary, film analysis (of themes, film technique, acting, etc.), and a conclusion, which contains the recommendation or disapproval of the film.
In Daniel Mendelsohn’s film review, “An Affair to Remember,” of Brokeback Mountain, he ignores this typical structure of a film review. In fact, Mendelsohn’s review actually serves as a hybrid literary piece functioning as both a film review and a social commentary.
In the opening paragraph, Mendelsohn introduces the background film information in the span of one sentence, which other critics typically do in one
…show more content…
Although film analysis is commonly in a movie review, the way in which Mendelsohn presents the analysis varies. During his analysis of key scenes, he reminds the readers that there is an appropriate lens and mindset that one must have in order to understand and appreciate the movie for what it is, all in combination with his discreditation of the misinformed film critics. Mendelsohn serves as a defender of the movie, he is fighting for the authenticity of the film; he wants others to understand the film in its genuine form without it being misconstrued by heteronormative standards. Essentially, he skips the quintessential structure of a film review, yet somehow still manages to fuse the plot summary, film elements, and background information within his argument. Effectively, it’s all there but just in a appropriately disordered fashion, with a hint of social

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    which is that it "deliberately appeals to all that is worst in us." Of course, we will never forget our real intentions of going to see them in the first place. Instead of using the movies as a form of relief, our subconscious finds an intrinsically good reason to go out and see these films, to exercise the darkness in us. When King presents his subject, his focus is on making sure his audience clearly understands what he is talking about, further evidence on the matter supports the subject, as well as casual inferences, suggesting to the reader that there is some form of emotion we need to study. Finally, King takes his writing to a conclusion that has real world connections, asking a "so what?"…

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Historian David Bordwell believes that the narration in a film cues and constrains its viewer .Directors always find ways to confuse a viewer by adding suspense into a story. The narration in a film cues the viewers by giving clues as well as telling them what to think. A viewer can be constrained because the all the information is not provided in that one setting. Instead the narration only provides bits and pieces as the film…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the film, there are a series of formal elements that help make a film more than just what a person sees. The way you look at a film is called a formal analysis “ film analysis that examines how a scene or sequence uses formal elements- narrative, mise-en-scene, cinematography, editing, sound, and so on- to convey the story, mood, and meaning” (Looking At Movies p.g 498). Everyone has their own opinions and way they perceive movies. But as a film critic, you observe a movie much more than just “oh I liked this”, or “I believe this should have been left out”. The way you critically evaluate a movie is by the formal elements of a film, for an example a film like St. Vincent.…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Rhetorical Pedagogy

    • 426 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Ott and Carl R. Burgchardt's article are very divergent than the other three sources in terms of the purpose of the writing; however, it also shares plenty of similarities on behalf of the narrative approach and the reflection of the historical context. I believe the fact that this article speaks to the educational field about the disadvantages in media can be a special direction to expand on when I am developing my sub-arguments. The reason for that is as referring back to the article about how melodramatic genre can affects the audience's reception about this film, these articles actually offers some solutions for the educational workers on how to guide students to use their sensibilities while receiving messages through media. Moreover, this article spends more space on acquiring the problems in this film rather than applause its achievement, at least to some extents, in other articles. Therefore, it provides me with a fresh angle to observe and analysis details from the film and to rethink about if my own claims in the later writing process are accurate…

    • 426 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    The imagined world is shattered and replaced with a world that one might not agree with. According to Bettina Kümmerling-Meibauer, “each medium calls for specific abilities on the part of the reader/viewer” which means that in order to enjoy an adapted movie one must look past the book and view the movie as its own separate entity; however, it is rare that one actually views an adapted movie…

    • 1800 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In The Bedroom Analysis

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Some of the differences was how Matt, Frank’s father and the ex-Richard channel their anger into destruction in the reading. While, in the movie, it was more entertaining and everything goes in chronological order. The movie was more suspenseful because you don’t know what’s going to happen next. The reading gave me more details on how Frank…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sample Literature Review

    • 1017 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Baglione expands by saying that the author should also address the strengths and weakness of each school of thought. Upon review of the research paper, I do not believe that the author adequately does this in the literature review. The author does a good job of explaining the components of traditional decision-making theory and the scholars who proposed the theory. The author then goes further to explain the weakness of traditional decision-making theory by saying that one cannot prediction human behavior, or what he terms “actor rationality”. Nevertheless, where I feel that the literature review is lacking is the application of decision-making theory to the Yom Kippur War.…

    • 1017 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The format of Clint Eastwood movies is evident in American Sniper, according to Taibbi. He then goes off topic and makes a film comparison with the film, Forrest Gump. Taibbi says, “the mere act of trying to make a typically Hollywoodian one-note fairy tale set in the middle of the insane moral morass that is/was the Iraq occupation is both dumber and more…

    • 1330 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The End Of The Tour Analysis

    • 2334 Words
    • 10 Pages

    It is concerned with the breaking down of known truths, systems, frameworks, certainties, and definitions. It feels that there is no singular truth or answer, and rejected the sentiments that there is one true God, history is progress or peace on Earth. Instead of one overall truth, things are understood on a micro level, ideas like reality are realized by how we see them individually. In literature, or movies in my case, this is characterized by self-referentially, moral relativism, cynicism and irony. The End of the Tour is a film centered around the life of David Foster Wallace, a writer who often criticized postmodernism and talked about the movement he thought would follow, post-postmodernism or New Sincerity, which would then influence the way the film on his life would be made.…

    • 2334 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The intricate plot functions as a diversion to overlook what is literally in front of the audience the entire movie. Furthermore, Robert stated in his review that “the "solution," when it comes, solves little - unless there is really little to solve, which is also a possibility”. He acknowledges what the author was trying to do; but neglects why the author framed it this way. Specifically, if the plot wasn’t perplexingly complex; the movie would lose its “magic”; the “usual suspects” would be a “usual”, easily predictable movie. Likewise, the movie is told in “Verbal’s” protagonist point of view; yet he can also be regarded as the antagonist of the film since verbal is revealed to be Soze at the end of the film.…

    • 1275 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays