Media Involvement In The Justice System

Improved Essays
Media Involvement in the Justice System
When the media becomes involved in the process and begins to express its opinion, people begin to see the media as a subject matter expert, blindly accepting the facts that the media presents as truth whether or not they are. Most people will believe and accept the facts that the media presents as truth. Crime has existed from the beginning of time itself; people have always committed crimes; however, the media has not always been involved. One of the first crimes in recorded history was in the Bible. When Cain killed his brother Able, there were no media there to provide a commentary on that offense. In fact, the media does not cover every crime. The media often covers only the types of crimes that
…show more content…
However, media chooses which cases to cover depending on the high level of exposure they can expect from the case that becomes a way to intrude into the American criminal justice system. (Leisshman & Mason, 2003).
The media affects the criminal justice system on several different levels. The introduction of the press into the courtrooms was the first step in allowing the media to interfere with the criminal justice system. Today’s media record and report on some high-profile cases from inside the courtroom, sometimes offering a live feed of the courtroom with added media commentary (Leisshman & Mason, 2003). Mass media has also begun to police the police. The media has become very involved in the criminal judicial system and has scrutinized law enforcement for the way they handle their cases. The media has been able to influence the criminal justice system by expressing strong opinions about different cases. In some of those cases, the media has picked a side. People tend to pick sides depending on whom they believe; there are always two sides to every story. When the media chooses a side, the media opinion influences some people, and that makes the job of the criminal justice system more difficult. There are people who are swayed by media opinion, and that
…show more content…
The media has a lot of influence on the criminal justice system, and that can affect the judicial system. It is understandable that the press has every right to report a story, but when did the American society become a society of guilty until proven innocent? The evidence and facts of a case should be the only factor in judging the case, so people should not allow the media to take on the role of the judge by predicting a person’s guilt or innocence while reporting on the case. A person is innocent until proven guilty. Part of the problem with the media is that it believes that its first amendment rights allow them to trample on people 's rights to be innocent until proven in a court of law beyond any reasonable doubt that they are guilty. In the justice system, shortcuts should not be taken, and allowing the media to take these shortcuts by expressing its opinion as a fact without hearing all of the evidence is detrimental to our justice

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Crime In The Media Essay

    • 1309 Words
    • 6 Pages

    So, by constantly accusing someone of committing a crime on the media, the judges and officials of the law could also be infected by this conception, thus giving them an unbiased decision of the person’s fate. Take for example the OJ Simpson case – “after the OJ Simpson trial some jurors admitted that the pressure generated by the media added significantly to the difficulties of deliberation. The inescapable consequence of the media reporting on violent crimes is that people cannot help internalizing the public opinion when it stands against a person on trial.” (1.3.7-14) Some may argue that the law should always have an unbiased opinion no matter the scenario, but this still does not change the fact that the brain will automatically create a misguided conception on someone based on what we are told daily by the…

    • 1309 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The language media uses to represent crime is a crucial feature which can add to the distortion the media intends to paint the story with. The media’s choice of language in constructing opinions of certain groups can also cause stereotypical labels and the public distancing themselves from those groups (McCreanor, 2014). Numerous studies have shown that crime reported in the media does not match up with official crime stats (Davis, 1952; Ditton & Duffy, 1983; Jerrin &…

    • 2072 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    In order to create the slight aura of anxiety, the media restricts its stories down to the most dramatic and shocking facts (Newhagen 266). They do this in order to create suspense and fear, and it works extraordinarily well. The restraint of information makes it hard for people to empathize with criminal; a lot of times, the news doesn’t report on motive or underlying reasons for the crime, closing off an essential connection that would allow people to connect and forgive with the offender. This was further supported by a study discussed by Karen Gelb in which two groups of people were given a report of the same case. One group of people, however, were given just a brief description, which Karen says is “similar to a media report,” while the other was given “a more detailed description with information on incident and offender characteristics” (Gelb 288).…

    • 1690 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    This is the initial concept of labelling potential criminals before their case has even been heard before a jury. The impact of television and newspaper coverage has had a tremendous impact on the way ‘criminals’ are perceived. This is done by creating a bad prejudgment of that person, e.g. creating images that the person is/may be a criminal even if he/she may be innocent. The idea of “innocent until proven guilty “is not considered viable due to the way that the media creates false concepts of people.…

    • 1739 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a result of the arguments that I have introduced and explained in this essay we can conclude that there is a strong relationship between what media is showing to the world and how the people are influenced regarding to the criminals and criminal justice system. However, it is important to know that even if the media is exaggerating with some of the serious problems that we have in the world the media is the only mean of communication through which people can be aware of everything that happens, whether there are good or bad news Chris Greer (2007) In the end, I can state that I have answered to the following question: to what extent the media influences offending behaviour and our attitudes towards crime and criminal justice and I repeat that the amount of impact that media is having in offenders behaviour,criminal justice and people’s attitude towards crime is very high and is a very concerning problem in today’s social scientists mind because people need to be more realistic and not living any more in a life full of fiction Chris Greer…

    • 1486 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Theories Of Moral Panic

    • 1623 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Some examples that are used frequently are when news stations report and use clickbait headlines, like crime is at an all time high in order to try to put labels on certain activities, people, and cultures. Labelling theory points out that specific individual or groups are seen as more deviant because of predetermined biological factors, like skin colour or gender (Young, and Cohen. p.7). Which is why when a news report comes out and it is untrue, but it is turned in to a moral panic, it can have very dire consequences. Results of labelling theory are not just seen as effecting people who, reading or listening to the report but also the people that are being labelled (Young, and Cohen.…

    • 1623 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How media negatively influences court outcomes Social class, cultural beliefs and commitment to religion were the only influences society built their trust in when it came to adopting normative behaviors and determining justice within a controlled society. Unfortunately, those influences are a thing of the past. The most powerful influence in our society today, is the news media. News media have dominated the ability to Impact our daily lives and now has the power to influence judicial outcomes in the courtroom. This paper will examine the relationship between, the news media reporting on high profile criminal cases and the negative influence they have on society’s thoughts of justice in the courtroom.…

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Our criminal justice system is deemed unsound due to effects the media has on the public. For instance, the debate on capital punishment has been around since the beginning of time, although it truly became misconstrued when media coverage became widespread. The media wields a tremendous amount of influence in our society through newspapers, televisions, computers, and other outlets (Media Influence in Capital Cases). Once news such as this became available at our finger tips, you started to see a shift in opinion throughout the nation, especially in court rooms, statistics, and politics which has a lasting effect on legislation. The more the media grows, the more they are scrutinized for their influence on values and understanding.…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Which is a key issue to how the public view our society today. As it is commonly understood that the public believes everything the news tells them, as they automatically assume that if the information is coming from the news media, then it must be true. But majority of what we know about crime today from the media is in fact NOT always based on the truth and is NOT a true reflection on crime today. As well spoken by Jewkes “ The media is not a window on the world, but a prism subtly blending and distorting our picture of reality” (Jewkes 2004:37) For instance the public perception on crime and criminals, is quiet contradictory and complex. As on hand one the public would portray criminals as the villain’s, anti hero’s and often see criminals as evil, devils and monsters and assume that they were born this way, because of the crimes that they have committed.…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When turning on the television, radio, or just viewing the newspaper, you are flooded with news of murders, homicides, serial killers, and other tragedies. It is an uncommon occurrence to make it through a day in this world and not hear of these tragedies. So what can be done about these crimes? Today, there is an ongoing debate over capital punishment, questioning whether it is morally right or wrong. We, as human beings, have an undeniable privilege on our own lives, but do the lives of others belong to us as well?…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays