Civil Justice System In Mr. Harr's May It Please The Court

Great Essays
The story by Mr. Harr captures vividly, the civil justice system as discussed in the class text “May it Please the Court” by Brian L. Porto. According to Porto, there are five main actors in the judicial process, especially in a civil proceeding. These players include the plaintiff tell me what they do, the defendants here too, the lawyers for the plaintiff and the defendants’ side, as well as the judge who presides over the civil case. For instance, the case in A Civil Action by Mr. Harr fits within the civil proceeding guidelines as detailed in the class text. Notably, Woburn is the plaintiff, with Jan Schlichtmann and his as plaintiff’s lawyer. The defendants in the case are major cooperate companies, W, R Grace, and Beatrice foods. The defendant’s legal representatives are Cheeseman for Grace and Facher for Beatrice with Judge Skinner presiding over the proceedings (Harr, 1996). As is common practice in most judicial system, the plaintiff files the charges within the limitations as provided under statutes. In the story by Mr. Harr, the Woburn took three years. On the defendants’ side, Beatrice through lawyer …show more content…
Indeed, the class text and the assigned reading give a clear vision of how law and politics intersect. For instance, lawyers work in the legislature while judges and are appointed and approved by the elected officials. In Harr’s A Civil Action, there are cases in which Woburn’s case took a political angle. For example, the mayor of Woburn at one point politicized the case arguing that it was likely to affect industrial economy of the city. Additional, there were influences on some key judicial personalities are institutions. Notably, political influence was also committed by Non-legal actors such as Mr. Facher, who tried to influence the judges by asking for more time to prepare for the trial by an attempt to put forward his reputation and

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    This behavioral information can explain some of the behavior for legislators who are in swing districts and why they craft the legislation in particular ways. With regards to the judges and the courts, political scientist can help the legal field understand the behavior of the different judges and the different courts. This information can help with the understanding of how and why judges’ rule in certain courts verses other judges in other courts. This behavior can lead to lawyers to venue selection for their cases that will be filed in the suits. Now, while venue shopping is not always the most courteous thing a lawyer can do, it does allow for a potentially larger jury pool (the difference between state court and federal court), jurisdiction selection could allow for a better outcome for the different law suits that a lawyer will file with many jurisdictions that would cover the…

    • 2016 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Prepare a partial balance sheet to show how the information related to this contract would be presented at the end of 2006 using the percentage-of completion method. 4. Prepare a partial balance sheet to show how the information related to this contract would be presented at the end of 2006 using the completed contract method. Exercise 5-3 Percentage-of-completion method; loss projected on entire project ( LO4 On April 13, 2006, the Pagano Construction Company entered into a three-year construction contract to build a mall for a price of $12,000,000. During 2006, costs of $3,000,000 were incurred with estimated costs of $6,000,000 yet to be incurred.…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Supreme Court System

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Summary: The court system plays an important role in American society. The court system is able to give orders and dismantle laws that are deemed unconstitutional. The belief that courts have the function as policy makers is predominantly seen within the history of the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court is able to be involved in policy making by exercising judicial review. Through judicial review, courts are able to strike down on policies made by elected officials or legislatures.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Politics involve a tremendous amount of social networking and negotiating. Politicians have the power to create the laws and rights of our cities, counties, states and country. The outlook of a politician in moving society forward must be focused on several key concerns. To name a few, these include economics and trade, religious views and the security of a society. Ethical issues such as resolving racism and inequality, and protecting individual rights are also concerns to which people look to politicians for guidance.…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This case examined whether First Amendment “Freedom of Speech” rights applied to government employees when directly correlated to the employee’s official duties. Richard Ceballos, as a calendar deputy in the district attorney’s office, handled some supervisory responsibilities over other lawyers. In doing so, he sometimes was approached by defense attorneys and asked to review and investigate aspects of pending cases. In one such instance, Ceballos was asked to look into a case where the defense attorney had challenged a warrant due to what the attorney felt were inaccuracies in the affidavit used to acquire the warrant. Once Ceballos investigated, he agreed that the warrant was ill obtained.…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Veasey Model Case Study

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages

    the fact that “up-the-ladder” reporting to job controlling CEO’S and other member’s of senior management is a common theme in the corporate world (Veasey & Di Guglielmo, 2006). These lawyers may feel that prioritizing integrity ahead of company goals may sour their relationship with such authority and therefore jeopardize their personal future. This pro-co-operation approach by lawyers falls under the advocacy model of corporate counsel, in which lawyers engage in zealous advocacy whilst serving a client, even fighting for causes which they deem immoral (Coffee, 2006). I believe that this is a detrimental role for lawyers to assume however, as non-ethical behavior is not only a negative for their career, but also to the long term stability of the corporate…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Wrongful Conviction In CIU

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The chapter focuses on the importance of conviction integrity units (CIU), which were designed and produced by attorneys who started taking up the issue of wrongful convictions. The formation is relevant because CIUs seem to result from the innocence movement, which helps to bring the issue of wrongful convictions to the public’s attention (as cited in Zalman & Carranno, 2013). The chapter states two arguments: on the one hand, CIUs should be celebrated, and on the other hand, and the rise in CIU might also be a political reaction from wrongful convictions. CIUs might seem appealing enough because prosecutors appear to have control over the constant pressure to convict that each attorney faces. There are reasons to be skeptical because wrongful…

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    A “DUI and DWI Attorney”, helps deal with DUI and DWI cases, aggravated DUI, drunken biking, felony DUI, and commercial DUI regulations. A “Property/Real Estate Attorney”, is needed when it comes to foreclosure, landlord-tenants and any property situations An “Employment Lawyer”, can work with a variety of problems and issues that can arise in diverse workplaces. Employment lawyers can help assist both employees and employers alike. “Private Practice Lawyers”, technically work alone in an office or can work alongside other lawyers at a law firm. Private Practice Lawyers can have cases from divorce and child custody to malpractice suits.…

    • 1692 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Haik Family My three-generational family includes my paternal grandparents, Charles and Winnie Haik, my maternal grandparents, Jimmy and Elise Lee, and my parents, Charles Haik and McCall Ainsworth. My parents divorced in 1994, which is the explanation for different last names. My father remarried a few years after the divorce, however, my mother got remarried in 2005. From my father’s marriage,…

    • 1346 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In other words, public speeches are the elements that plays an important role for citizens to better understand the candidates that they are going to vote for based upon the purpose and promises that the candidates are going to perform after receiving the power of a representative. Thomas L. Friedman is a well known op-ed author who have been rewarded for international reports and often produce different political articles based upon his perspective like that of, “Politicians Seeing Evil, Hearing Evil, Speaking Evil,” saw the negativity in these speeches. Friedman identified that bigoted candidates are “dragging their whole party across civic redlines” by starting off his article with the desire of wanting to watch a movie called “Rabin: The Last Day,” for it is relevant to that of America’s society today. He then explained that the movie is similar to our country as it is “about what can happen in a democratic society when politicians go too far.”(“Politician - What They Do.”) And within his work, he provided an example politician, Donald Trump, to specify how politicians tends to exaggerate themselves into gaining supporters. This presentation of the candidates may lead to an unnecessary detriment of the…

    • 1148 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays