Mary Beth Whitehead Surrogacy Case Essay

1110 Words Jun 6th, 2016 5 Pages
CRAM Exclusive
Essay Sample
Basics of Bioethics Katie Houp Fort Hays State University February 14, 2014 Basics of Bioethics Introduction Ethics is a term encountered in any professional field today. It refers to the moral principle that people are supposed to uphold. These moral principles are expected to guide people in making informed choices. Bioethics is moral principles that guide people, mainly in medical and biological research. There are several ethical questions that arise during researches such as

middle of document…

The Whitehead’s were having financial difficulties. Is it completely unacceptable and unethical to bank on another person’s financial vulnerability for personal interest? It is evident that Whitehead’s felt they were pushed into the deal because of their financial situation. The Stern’s felt they were also placed in a difficult position as well. An opportunity for ‘renting’ Mary Beth’s womb presented itself, and they decided to do so. Some may hold a different stand on this, in this situation the Stern’s felt they were behaving in an ethical manner. According to Sanger (2007) at the time of the contract, surrogacy contracts were not allowed in New Jersey; however the contract was written in New York. It is the moral principle that drives people to respect the law. In this regard, it was immoral of both parties to get into a contract that was unlawful as both parties resided in New Jersey. The Stern’s however had a different point of view about the whole issue.

Sanger (2007) argues that determining whether surrogacy is moral is a hard question. Equating motherhood to financial value might be considered unethical to some; however for those unable to bear children in the traditional manner, this is not, nor was a consideration. For the Whitehead’s this decision eventually resulted in a divorce. Bill and Elizabeth Stern had other options like adoption but they chose to take the path of insemination in order to obtain
CRAM Exclusive

Related Documents

  • The Ethics of Surrogacy Essay

    The Ethics of Surrogacy There is controversy surrounding the concept of surrogacy in the United States. There is nothing in federal legislature the addresses the issue directly. Different States have different laws concerning surrogacy. Some forbid it and some enforce surrogacy contracts in court. Finding a surrogate mother, for some is their last chance to have a child that is biologically their own. There are people that believe that surrogacy is morally wrong for several reasons. I believe

    Words: 2402 - Pages: 10
  • Essay on Ethical Discussion About Surrogacy

    Surrogacy is a modern medical treatment, which is the process that a woman carries and delivers the baby for another person or another couple. Ethical problems of this medical technology have been discussed frequently in recent years. Some arguments support surrogacy, some against. Those arguments and ethical issues involved in will be discussed in this paper. From the scientific point of view, there are two major types of surrogacy, which are traditional surrogacy and gestational surrogacy

    Words: 3555 - Pages: 15
  • Surrogate Parenting, Research Paper

    (Zimmerman 1). Juditz' surrogate explained that her motivation stemmed from her own uncertain ancestry; she wanted to help someone to have their biological child (Zimmerman 2). Having a biological link is the reason many prospective parents choose surrogacy over adoption. Surrogate parenting is an effective method of fertility treatment because the surrogate allows a childless couple to have their biological child. To

    Words: 2322 - Pages: 10
  • Mary Adelaide Nutting Essay

     Mary Adelaide Nutting a Nurse Leader Abstract For this paper we were required to write about the life of a particular nursing leader. The purpose was to document about their lives and to include things like their backgrounds, credentials, and their influences on nursing. These women are considered some of the most influential people to nursing. But the most important questions are, “What exactly is a leader and what makes someone a leader?” As defined

    Words: 800 - Pages: 4
  • Surrogacy and Kant Essay

    Ethical Decision Making Paper The following case involves a seventy one year old male patient who told his family if the time ever came when he could not sustain life on his own he didn’t want measures taken to do so. This patient found out in the late summer of 2008 he had stage four pancreatic cancer. The doctor gave him about four weeks to live. At this point he took things into his own hands and made his daughter durable power of attorney for his healthcare needs. Over the next few

    Words: 1571 - Pages: 7
  • The Process of Surrogacy and Its Different Types Essay

    Surrogacy is an international practice. The use of other women to carry people’s babies is a common and legal practice in many countries. To fully understand why this is a moral issue, you need to understand what it is. A surrogate is a woman who is carrying a baby for another person. Surrogacy is used for many reasons by different couples. The crowd drawn to surrogacy is couples who are infertile and cannot have kids. Such couples include: couples who are too old, couples who are in a homosexual

    Words: 898 - Pages: 4
  • Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, by Robert Louise Stephenson and Frankenstein, by Mary Shelley

    know it is there, instinctly. It is from the separation of morals and the conscious mind that creates the perfect example for the duality of mankind, separation of good and evil, but often times we let the evil get the best of us or at least was the case for Dr. Jekyll and Victor. In the story a message that was very basic, yet again, timeless is the thought of the importance of ones reputation. In Dr. Jekyll this theme is greatly expressed through the doctors continued denial of knowing of the existence

    Words: 1832 - Pages: 8
  • Essay about Hca 322 Week 5 Assignment

    Deeper Look into Ethics and Laws Regarding Surrogacy HCA 322: Health Care Ethics and Medical Law A Deeper Look into Ethics and Laws Regarding Surrogacy When one or more persons contract with a woman to gestate a child than relinquish that child after birth to the person or couple is known as surrogacy. It is a course of action that goes outside of natural reproduction. For some, it is the only method of having children, extending family. Surrogacy has been stirring up many controversies over

    Words: 2521 - Pages: 11
  • Mary Rowlandson Essay

    The Struggle: Mary Rowlandson’s Story of Survival “All was gone, my husband gone..., my children gone, my relations and friends gone, our house and home, and all our comforts within door and without, all was gone except my life and I knew not but the next moment might go too.”(Edmund, 19) These were the words of Mary Rowlandson, a woman taken into captivity after Native Americans raided her colony, tortured and murdered the people of the land, and took Mary and a few others and turned them into

    Words: 1185 - Pages: 5
  • Mary Mahoney: Breaking the Nursing Color Barrier Essay

    Mary Eliza Mahoney Biography Mary Eliza Mahoney was born May 7, 1845 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Smith, J, & Phelps, S, 1992) Mary Mahoney was the first African American professional nurse. She spent over 40 years as a private duty nurses going to sick people’s homes nursing them back to health. She was such a wonderful private duty nurse that after joining a nursing directory, Mary was called upon time after time by the families that hired her all over the country near and faraway. Mary Mahoney

    Words: 1186 - Pages: 5