Martha Nussbaum's Education For Profit, Education For Democracy?

Great Essays
The academic system of current society attempts to prepare students for working in the real world. The majority of students are encouraged to pursue studies in areas such as business and technology because it will ensure a high paying job and promote economic growth. Lately, students have begun to question whether studying the humanities are worth the tuition costs, and if a technical or science based major is a better option. Martha Nussbaum, in her essay “ Education for Profit, Education for Democracy”, brings attention to how “the current focus on education as a form of career training fails to teach students the skills necessary to participate in the political process” (61). Liberal arts schools aim to strengthen a student’s range of knowledge through the studies of arts and humanities. Such an education would provide a student with the resources required to think critically about the world, specifically politics. Since the government acts on behalf of the people, they should be …show more content…
In the workforce, being able to communicate effectively is key to standing out from the average worker since machine labor can be done by almost anyone. A person needs writing and communication to speak with a boss, advocate for a raise or promotion, and draft proposals or arguments. Employees that encompass these skills will work in favor of the company to promote its overall growth and benefit. Paulo Friere, in his essay about the academic system “The Banking Concept of Education”, writes that “the teacher talks and the students listen – meekly” because the average employee listens and does as told by his/her employer (2). This relates to a work environment because an employer wants more than someone who can just get the job done; they want a person who is capable of going beyond their job description and show that they are capable of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Higher Education To begin with, this essay deals with two authors and their opinions about higher education. Sandford J Ungar is the president of Goucher College in Baltimore, Maryland . He wrote “The new liberal arts”, in this essay he clarified the misperceptions of obtaining a liberal arts degree. The second author, Charles Murray works at an American enterprise institute, conservative think tank in Washington, DC. He wrote” Are too many people going to college? ” .…

    • 1368 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Super Cool Title- Change Later Is higher education worth it? Which kind of higher education? Debates over questions like this regarding college education have been going on for generations and will likely continue into the foreseeable future.…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The article also gives a better understanding of what should be taken into account before choosing whether or not to study the liberal arts. By understanding what Stanford Ungar is saying in, “The New Liberal Arts,” readers are able to make decision on future plans based on fact rather than belief alone. By knowing that studying liberal arts is not irrelevant, or impractical for any background a reader is shown that race or income is not as important as earning a degree which allows student to think critically, and communicate effectively no matter the career…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Giroux views colleges as a space of democracy and intellectualism, where democracy and individualism ought to be encouraged. However, he believes that university, and the democracy it supports, are being threatened by right-wing extremism and excessive capitalism. Giroux states that many individuals hold the idea that “education is now about job training and competitive market advantage” (3). He believes that educators see students as little more than cash cows, and that colleges have essentially become businesses, interested more with money than providing their students a decent education. As a result, humanities and other important classes are overlooked in favor of classes which provide raw economic value.…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Engineering is widely regarded as not only a rigorous course of study, but also as a centerpiece for the development of the industrialized world. As the global market becomes increasingly competitive, institutions of higher education around the world continually make efforts to prepare their students for the quickly-advancing field of engineering. Through different approaches, countries around the world succeed and through their efforts we advance as a global society in our technology. Of the many approaches taken to education, one discussed by Martha Nussbaum in her piece, Education for Profit, Education for Democracy as the “single-subject model,” is characterized as an education that is structured and focuses for the most part on developing only one area of study. While it is subject to criticism by Nussbaum, it is well-worth considering how thorough structure, subject-focused study, and specified funding are assets to the…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ungar and his Liberal Arts Degree Sanford J. Ungar, the writer of “The New Liberal Arts”, argues that a liberal arts degree isn’t as questionable of a decision as believed to be. He trusts that a smaller independent college is a much more intimate setting where students continue learning habits that only better their mentality in terms of education and personality and will stick with them throughout the rest of their lives. More specifically Ungar believes that attending a liberal arts school provides as close connection with faculty and a chance for young adults to learn responsibilities while getting an education at the same time, just to name a few (Ungar 232). Overall, Ungar goes about his argument in a very unique and organized manner…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    They Say I Say Analysis

    • 2196 Words
    • 9 Pages

    With the questioning of the traditional educational system, many offer alternate solutions to combat these misperceptions such as the article written by Sanford J. Ungar, “The New Liberal Arts”. While liberal-art degrees rarely statistically illustrate much success,…

    • 2196 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As far back as I can remember, reading has always been a tremendous part of my life. Growing up, my mother introduced reading as one of the most important skills I could learn. Throughout my childhood, my entire family constantly incorporated reading into my daily schedule by helping me complete word searches, reading books, or rehearsing the ABC’s. Every night before bed, my mother and I would read a page out of a children’s bible book called Blessings Every Day as opposed to the classic Green Eggs and Ham. Reading has taught me how to exercise my imagination, how to effectively communicate with others, and relieves my stress.…

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Only Connect…”, William Cronon writes about the qualities gained through a liberal arts education. Cronon (1998) believed, that best type of education, is based off “nurturing human talents to expand the amount of freedom”, experienced in a society (p. 1). Even though not many people really understand how a liberal arts education work, it instills values that make effective leaders. Liberal education has changed quite a lot throughout history. This education was once solely for aristocrat males that focus on bettering themselves, to separate themselves from the population.…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    03 Feb. 2016. Emily Hanford, writing from the American RadioWorks, discusses the value and importance of a college degree and a college education. Hanford briefly provides a history of education prior to and after World War II and discusses how only a small group of Americans went to college because of the job in the 70s didn’t require a degree. Hanford then continues her article by introducing today’s standards for education and how education is required to survive in today’s society. Hanford then continues her article by introducing subtopics such as the rising value of education, “a class dimension”, and value in “some college”…

    • 1631 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cognition is something that must be owned by anyone who has a goal of finding a place in today’s job market. This is because the ability to process and acquire information through thought experience and sense is crucial in ones working environment. In Sanford J Ungar’s essay “The New Liberal Arts” he believes that obtaining a college education focused on liberal arts is the best way that the workers of tomorrow will be prepared for the constantly changing job market that they will soon have to explore in the future. Because of Ungar’s argument one may ask the question, is a liberal arts degree the only way to obtain the skills needed in the workplace? While some may jump to answer yes to this question others may have something else in mind.…

    • 1428 Words
    • Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his arguments, Ungar points out that while many believe a “liberal-arts degree is a luxury,” it is not (227). It may indeed be true that pursuing such a degree is more expensive and that families are struggling financially, but Ungar argues that it “a better investment” as it teaches the students how to communicate in an effective way and how to be critical thinkers which allows for them to be “innovative and creative” (227-228). He then supports this by making a claim based off a survey in 2009 that the majority of the employers are indeed looking for those with a liberal arts education instead due to them possessing the abilities already mentioned. Another argument he makes is that one should not just focus on the STEM fields and that one should expand and diversify their learning, which is what a liberal arts education can provide (229). While Ungar admits that while it is possible to gain such an education through a larger university, it does not provide “a close interaction between faculty members and students” and that there isn’t a “sens of community” (232).…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ziegler 1 Rachel Ziegler Sarah Chapman English 151-03 21 October 2016 Essay Final Draft (Problem Solving Report English 151) Louis Menand expresses his view on the importance of re-imagining liberal education, “but the only way to develop curiosity, sympathy, principle, and independence of mind is to practice being curious, sympathetic, principled, and independent” (536). Menand’s point describes an experience all students should want to gain through liberal education. Liberal education provides students with depth in all studies and broad knowledge for the real world.…

    • 1279 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She makes her stand clear on the issues of profit in educational system by arguing that education for profit must not be alone without a consideration for education for democracy. Nussbaum makes vital suggestion of how nations that are key to promoting humane, people-sensitive democracy needs to invest more on opportunities for life, liberty and pursuit of happiness for each and every countryperson. Her recommendations incorporate the skills that would make the citizenry critical about the political issues affecting their nations; to see every citizen as equal being before themselves and the law regardless of their gender and sexuality, religion and race; and to understand and examine the quality of life and how the position of leadership contributes to the success and failure of…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He evokes Tom Gillis, writer for Forbes magazine, to lead into this assertion, “The next billion-dollar company will be run by history majors who are skilled in wading through a massive jumble of facts and who have the ability to distill these facts down to a clear set of objectives that a global team can fulfill.” (Jones 28). Jones goes on to say that because of all of these skills that were acquired through liberal arts degree programs liberal arts degree holders are not at any kind of significant disadvantage compared to other degrees. Edward Conard, American businessman and author, challenges this claim in “We don’t need more humanities majors,” where he talks about the inadequacy of Liberal Arts degree holders filling in jobs in STEM-related fields, “It’s true some advanced degree holders may have earned undergraduate degrees in humanities, but they quickly learned humanities degrees alone offered inadequate training, and they returned to school for more technical degrees.” (Conard 42).…

    • 1426 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays