Mark Edmundson's Essay Why Teach? In Defense Of A Real Education

Great Essays
In today’s society, the American education system is not at its peak; it’s corrupt and polluted with twisted appeals towards money and business. This makes a real education hard to earn, but easy to be handed over via a sheet of paper. Unfortunately, there’s not much individuals can do except raise awareness and hope for a fix. One individual, Mark Edmundson, a professor at the University of Virginia, discusses these ideas in a book titled Why Teach? In Defense of a Real Education. One of his essays in particular, “Liberal Arts & Lite Entertainment,” talks about the numerous phenomena happening in American school systems. About halfway through his essay, while on a rant about colleges competing against one another for students, Edmundson …show more content…
Many people grow up and have their thoughts and beliefs trained and suppressed, and all throughout their early academic career, they spew out their parents’ thoughts, nothing more than a tape recorder replaying its message over and over for other tape recorders. Although there are people who grow up unsheltered with the freedom to seek out the answers to their own endless curiosities and form their own beliefs, it’s hard to find someone without some kind of value on a mental “constraint” or belief passed on from their parents. When someone is looking to settle their curiosities, being exposed to rigorous courses, especially in philosophy, psychology, and ancient literature could reshape a person’s entire outlook on life. The humanities is by far the most powerful division of education in regards to soul-shaping; numbers and formulas won’t do that, not even when you learn there are infinitely many numbers between 1 and 2 alone. But discovering the answers to their curiosities makes students question the world around them, their personal motives and values, and what they live for; confrontational and bold questions are raised that cannot (and will never) be answered through hypothesized experiments or calculated with a formula of variables. Students need to sweat and squirm in their seats under these kinds of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Higher Education To begin with, this essay deals with two authors and their opinions about higher education. Sandford J Ungar is the president of Goucher College in Baltimore, Maryland . He wrote “The new liberal arts”, in this essay he clarified the misperceptions of obtaining a liberal arts degree. The second author, Charles Murray works at an American enterprise institute, conservative think tank in Washington, DC. He wrote” Are too many people going to college? ” .…

    • 1368 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As an English professor at the University of Virginia, he writes from the perspective of an educator and describes the ideal student. According to his description, an ideal student is self-motivated and hardworking. However, more than often, the ideal student does not have the opportunity to attend the nation’s top universities due to the lack of finances. Similar to Delbanco and Jaime Escalante, Edmundson sees education as a tool for shaping one’s own identity and believes that everyone should have equal access to it. It defines not only an individual’s career, but also his values, beliefs and…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Coffee and Rhee support Guggenheim’s claim that the educational system has serious problems in the way they function. Coffee and Rhee are active in spreading the word around the country, as well as creating potential solutions to attempt to begin solving these problems. By including two credible, knowledgeable sources, Guggenheim portrays the significance of the problem throughout the country and offers credible attempts currently being made to better the situation.…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They get wrapped up in their research and work that will help them increase their status at the university. These things combined create an unspoken pact between the students and teachers, where neither party puts their all into the classroom and both will focus on other matters. Edmundson wants the teachers to engage students in the classroom and ask them to think deeply and on a personal level what they took away from the text. You should take what you read and analyze what you believe to be the essential truths. The consequence of all this is that most of what you learn in college will be forgotten by the time you graduate.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Today, however, the No Child Left Behind law and the Race to the Top program have undermined this ideal curriculum and restricted it to only the most affluent communities (107).” This block of text gets the audience to think of how unfair…

    • 1041 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Equality in Education Education policy is judgmental for differentiating between levels of education. In “Making Sparks Fly,” Mike Rose argues education policy supports more academic education for skills; however, vocational education creates just as skilled and efficient workers as academic education. Rose builds up his creditability by providing three vivid examples —Elias, Cynthia, and Bobby— and relatable emotional appeals to make his audience empathize with the students, additionally, to strengthen his support, Rose includes pieces of reasoning. Rose starts his essay by showing the journey of Elias, Cynthia, and Bobby surviving through a welding program.…

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Education is a resource that is available to most people in the United States. The value and the ways it is administered often various from person to person. Michelle Obama and Mike Rose are both advocates of educational value. They exhibit their positions on education in two documents; Blue-Collar Brilliance by Mike Rose and Bowie State University Commencement Speech by Michelle Obama. Rose’s document focuses on the degrading of educational attributes that are not gained in the preferred environment such as school.…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a student athlete at a NCAA Division II university in 2017, I have personally experienced the recruiting process and can honestly state that I would not willingly do it again. The sales pitches, tours of different facilities, paperwork, FAFSA’s, and compliance forms just to name a few definitely gave me my fill of the college admittance experience for a lifetime and then some. In Mark Edmundson’s piece, “Why Teach,” the aspects of what a true education is supposed to be is defended. Edmundson explains the change that colleges underwent in throughout the 1990’s.…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “College is a waste of time” and “Hidden Intellectualism” both share the concept that the educational curriculum should be changed to interest people’s minds more and that it’s too expensive to waste money on. These two essays make the reader understand that both authors are wanting to change the curriculum to fit people’s interests rather than the curriculum that is being taught today, which fail to teach a variety of subjects. In “College is a waste of time,” Dale Stephens acknowledges that college isn’t right for everyone, he uses his own opinions to back up his evidence. Dale clarifies that college is expensive. He refers to the College Board Policy Center because tuition is about 3.6 times higher today than it was 30 years ago.…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In America, an education is no longer considered to be an option but in fact, a necessity. Many are raised to believe in order to ensure a successful future, education is a key component. In fact, there are others who believe that the educations systems we have in place today, actually does more bad than good. There have been many movements that had an idea to insure that students are properly educated and all receive the same form of education but, the institution of these movements may have caused more damage and simply relied on the forcing of educators to produce a group of workers who are unable to consciously think for themselves. Although there is no way of making sure that the potential of a student is fully developed, possible solutions…

    • 1720 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Public Education Failure

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Tom DeWeese, in his article “Public Education is Failing,” from Opposing Viewpoints in Context, suggests our education system is failing to teach our children the basic subjects of reading, writing, and mathematics. DeWeese is the president of a public-policy organization that promotes less government involvement and more free enterprise. According to DeWeese, the “root problem” with our education system is, “. . . the federal programs and the education bureaucracy that run them.” He also suggests that the education system no longer concentrates on teaching the basics, but is training our children to perform “menial jobs.”…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However it’s time to fix the broken mechanism and like Vilson, ‘who was driven to teach because he knew he could do a much better job and make a career out of doing it better.’ (Vilson, 2014) Congress and big businesses should not be allowed to determine the cause of education. Educators, teachers union, activist, legislators, parents’ administrators and students must come together collaboratively and be more vocal and visible in favor of reform or nothing will change. Like Vilson, a lone ranger in isolation can shed light on the issues but will still remain unheard and unnoticed in a system controlled by the powerful. In a small country I have watched unified groups of individuals on numerous occasion force an entire country to come to stand still.…

    • 1517 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “On the Uses of Liberal Education: As Lite Entertainment for Bored College Students”, was written by Mark Edmundson in 1973. Edmundson conveys his ideas in an authoritative, straightforward manner although his writing is somewhat muddled. His arguments are clear but I had a hard time understanding his writing because he states his arguments after giving an example of what he is claiming. This makes his writing long and drawn out. I had to read and re-read his essay to understand his arguments.…

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Only Connect…”, William Cronon writes about the qualities gained through a liberal arts education. Cronon (1998) believed, that best type of education, is based off “nurturing human talents to expand the amount of freedom”, experienced in a society (p. 1). Even though not many people really understand how a liberal arts education work, it instills values that make effective leaders. Liberal education has changed quite a lot throughout history. This education was once solely for aristocrat males that focus on bettering themselves, to separate themselves from the population.…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Philosophy Of Education

    • 1301 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This practice causes the emphasis to fall away from math and science, and move towards the humanities. The purpose of self-study is to urge students to develop self-awareness and responsibility (Malik & Akhter, 2013, p.89). A teacher tests student’s knowledge through subjective appraisals (Magrini, 2013), while an essentialist teacher uses traditional exams to test his/her student’s knowledge. Science and math are the emphases of an essentialist curriculum, though reading, English, and history are not to be ignored. The teacher leads all learning, with all students participating in one large lesson (Parkay & Hess, 2000).…

    • 1301 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays