Madame Butterfly Comparison

Improved Essays
The opera Madame Butterfly written by Giacomo Puccini is a story about a young maiden from Japan who is in an arranged marriage to Lieutenant B. F. Pinkerton a soldier in the U.S. Navy. Lieutenant Pinkerton sees the marriage as a business deal, purchasing a house and servants, as well as receiving the fair maiden Madame Butterfly as a wife. Yet, Madame Butterfly believes that Lieutenant Pinkerton is marrying her for love. Not long after their marriage, Lieutenant Pinkerton tells Madame Butterfly that he is leaving. He reassures her that he will return when the robins nest again. Madame Butterfly maintains faith in her husband and waits patiently for three long years. One day Sharpless, a friend of Pinkerton’s, arrives with a letter …show more content…
Although in the beginning of the opera Madame Butterfly is a young and naive girl who easily believes that Lieutenant Pinkerton is in love with her, we later find Madame Butterfly to grow into a strong, independent woman, who is able to run a household and provide for her son. Likewise, Madame Butterfly is not really a passive, weak character. On the contrary, Madame Butterfly is portrayed as strong and active. She shows this especially in the final scene where she decides to violently kill herself with a dagger, rather than live with …show more content…
Although, one thing in the performance did surprised me. I was surprised that Madame Butterfly was such a strong female character. The reason why I found this to be surprising is because in most Romantic operas the heroine is usually weak, fragile, and passive, the complete opposite of Madame Butterfly. It was hard to understand the true passion and strength of Madame Butterfly just by reading about her. But after watching a talented performer portray her character, I was able to understand the the role of Madame Butterfly far better. Truly, it made the opera more enjoyable overall to see a strong female heroine. Overall, seeing the performance live in the opera allowed me to appricate the power of the singers’ voices and to hear the beautiful melody of the orchestra in live performance. In addition, getting to see the whole opera allowed me to piece together the story and truly understand the meaning behind the opera, as opposed to just watching excerpts and reading the synopsis. I truly enjoyed this opera, and hope to see another one again

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Great Gatsby Recklessness

    • 1292 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Daisy was born into wealth, and the delight of having no occupation, but the spouse aspect of her American Dream was clouded. Since she broke things off with young Gatsby to pursue more socially well-off men, the reader would presume that she found love in Tom, her rich husband. However, Tom was having an affair, and she was well aware of it. When she attempted to do the same by reconnecting with Gatsby, the happiness seemed short lived. In no time, the magic seemed to have ended, and reality set back into her mind, causing her to distance herself from Gatsby and settle for Tom.…

    • 1292 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I really enjoyed the play, for many reason the actors were very vocal they did an amazing job at keeping the audience intrigued, they successfully played there characters well to believe they were who they were playing which is incredibly important in a play for some plays, the actors are not a big intriguing and sound as if they a reading dull and right off a piece of…

    • 1235 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Hi, I am Louis Giaquinto. I was born in Flagstaff, AZ, but I have grown up over the valley most of my life. My favorite movie of 2015 and one of my favorite independent films is Room (2015), directed by Lenny Abrahamson. Room is about a young woman and her son who were held captive for seven years, but then escaped and experienced the outside world. Most of the cast was unknown or they had been in supporting roles.…

    • 200 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I, Randy Rivas, attended a performance with two separate chamber groups and a soloist. One of the chamber groups was Christine S. Lopez and Sung Ae Lee both performing on piano, the other was Paul Da Silva playing piano and Manon Robertshaw on cello, and lastly Sung Ae Lee doing a solo performance. This was performed at Cerritos College in the music building at BC-51. It began at eleven in the morning on February twenty sixth. First musical performance was the piece of Muzio Clementi’s sonata in B flat major for two pianos.…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The narrator of the short piece The Moths is a fourteen-year-old girl. She is an unusual girl, who is quite different from everything and everybody, especially the feminine world. The girl from the story is entitled as being rebellious due to lack of respect, non-stop confronting her family members and being immature. She is not as “pretty or nice”, nor does she do "girly things". The story itself has many stages, themes and it gives the ability to the reader to sympathize with the protagonist while she is going through different situations.…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My expectations walking towards the production for “Betty’s Diner” were not very high. I was not looking forward to seeing the play because I really dislike musicals. The singing after every six minutes bored me as a child watching movie musicals so why would I want to watch them now? As a kid I was unable to watch “High School Musical” and most other musical movies because the singing absolutely annoyed me whenever a character felt any type of emotion. All of my experiences of past musicals had clouded my mind making me not want watch the play.…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Princess Bride Comparison

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Stories and fairytales play a role in a person’s lives from the time the young age of reading stories every night before bed to adulthood when reading is a rare pleasure. If written well, a story captures a person’s mind and imagination. Every character, place, and adventure is pictured, making it feel as if the reader lived it with a character. After the success of a novel in bookstores, many novels transform from pages in a book to actors on the silver screen. Often, the portrayal of the movie differs greatly from the ideas of the characters and adventures readers pictured in their head.…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rent: Play Analysis

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As the actors spun the set design I became filled with anticipation for what was about to occur, but as the musical progressed my excitement toward the play dwindled. It was almost as if the initial spinning of the stage disoriented me and I was dizzy and confused for the rest of the night. Without the girls beside me explaining the play to each other during intermission I never would have known what was going on. The actors all performed wonderfully, but there were too many actors with unspoken problems to follow.…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One day after she comes home from the Opera she feels ill and eight days later she dies of pneumonia. M. Lantin is obviously devastated and he becomes poor as his wife was in charge of the finances in the home. He, with much thought, decides to go sell her favorite pearl necklace, as he became hungry and was…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Comparison Between William Shakespeare 's play, “Othello the Moor of Venice” and Oliver Parker’s Film. The story of Othello is told in William Shakespeare’s play, as well as in Oliver Parker’s film version of it. Although the plot of the story is the same in the play and the film, as well as other details, there are some differences. Focusing on the character, Iago, and his plan to destroy the main character, Othello, the play and the film use similarities and differences to help show the progression of Iago’s rage.…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unit 4 Individual Project (Dramatic Writing and Poetry) The dramatic one-act play used for this project is entitled The Stronger, written by a man named August Strindberg in the year 1889. The characters in the play are two females known as Madame X and Mademoiselle Y. Madame X is very well spoken and proper. She appears to come from a higher class of society from the proper way that she speaks as well as the way she spoke of having servants.…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Power Her Face Analysis

    • 2251 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Powering her face, the duchess has been painstakingly enhanced and edited, hiding her inner insecurity and loneliness carefully. In “Power Her Face”, the libretto and costumes show the audiences that the duchess is just a victim of gender inequality in this patriarchal society at her time. Excess indulging and squandering, plus her several failed marriages made the duchess become the public scandal. According to Cowart’s “Women, Sex and Folly: Opera Under the Old Regiment”, conservative publics critics tend to consider female as “fragile sex” living on the edge of sexual infidelity even deviance. As opera was considered a bad place, which encouraged passions of wrong kinds and senses and discouraged a humble devout spirit in the early 20 century,…

    • 2251 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For a long period of time, our society was accustomed and perhaps encouraged to maintain a certain level of secrecy regarding many components of our society. It was not acceptable to openly condemn and express personal opinions about topics, such as, women rights, religion, and politics. However, during the enlightenment, in the seventeenth century, there was a slight change. Authors such as Mary Wollstonecraft and Moliere, deliberately expressed their concerns about this “controversial” topics, through their literary work. For one, Mary Wollstonecraft, in 1776 published, A vindication of the right of women.…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    For many, the mundanity of real life is disappointing. The realities of the complex and oftentimes boring nature of life can leave people dissatisfied. Gustave Flaubert depicts one such person in his novel Madame Bovary, which details the life of its eponymous protagonist, Emma Bovary. Emma has dreams of an exciting, romantic life, but is quickly disappointed by her marriage to an unambitious man and immovable place in the middle class. Throughout the novel, Emma’s idealistic outlook on life, also called romanticism, is undermined by the stark reality of the realistic situations she finds herself in and by other characters whose beliefs directly clash with hers.…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The formation of dance has lived on this world for many generations as we continue to pass through history. When I went to the wonderful performance at Pierce College I experienced a whole new perspective on dancing. The concert had many types of students performing mixed dance projects of all types like solos and duets. There was an average size of one to eight dancers per project which made it the ideal size for the concert. I really enjoyed the creativity and effort put into this performance.…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays