Analysis Of Equality Of Treatment: Ability Grouping Or Diversity Of Deficit

Improved Essays
EN4017 2014

From the perspective of your school placement discuss the findings lynch and lodge (2002) in relation to either ‘’equality of treatment’’ or the ‘’ diversity of deficit’’.

Equality of treatment: Ability Grouping or
Diversity deficit (any ONE aspect) a. Sexual orientation b. Travellers C. Racial minorities OR other diversity issue.

You must support your arguments with evidence from your school placement experience and the reading list for this module.

From my study of lynch and lodge (2002) it has come to my attention that when studying grouping in schools that its is important to focus on the ‘’ability’’ of students. In traditional Ireland students ability to recite knowledge is often used as evidence to determine student ability and represents a students intelligence levels quite rigidly. Across much of the world with the exemption of new apitudes tests for such as the GAMSTAT to gauge peoples collective intelligence the standardised test to determine peoples collective intelligence is the IQ test. Despite this research by Developmental psychologists such as Howard
…show more content…
The school in question is clearly not exam orientated for non-exam years contrasting with Lynch and lodges (2002) findings. This indicates the schools wants to develop the students collective intelligences on a broader scale which would be more in sync with Gardeners theory of multiple intelligences. ‘’We are conscious that the traditional interpretation of what constitutes an intelligent human being has often been too narrow and has sometimes been interpreted in strictly cognitive terms, ignoring other critical elements of intelligent human behaviour whether of a social, emotional, psychomotor, moral or physical nature. In providing a balanced curriculum, we aim to redress that traditional

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Whether at a job, at home, or in between, any experience can be just as educational as a class at a university. In “Blue Collar Brilliance”, the author, Mike Rose, uses anecdotes from his family’s experiences to prove how although his family members might not have had much formal education, they all were “intelligent” due to the lessons they learned at work. Given my family’s own experience, I can attest to that. Throughout all of the generations of my family, half have attended a traditional university, while the others went to work or had a different experience, some even had both.…

    • 1024 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    - In both articles, authors were talking about how the academic and non-academic learning can be more valuable in the society, we found many facts that tell us how society can respect you if you are an educated individual. “Blue-collar Brilliance”, Professor Mike Rose address that society’s blind views on the intellectual ability of the people operating jobs related to serving or manual workers. Rose indicated that blue collar workers miss focusing on the intelligence needed in their businesses. Besides, he stated that the relationship between certain never proclaims worker intelligence.…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Disparate treatment is the first theory of discrimination, and it sums up the case for the plaintiff Miss Pettigrew. According to the case study, there is a conflict of interest if adjustors enroll in law school. The male employees enrolled in law school and kept their position (Melvin & Katz, 2014). The company fired Miss Pettigrew when she enrolled in law school. According to the lecture, on the surface, it is discrimination called prima facie and is subject to a rebuttal because it is intentional (Bethel University, 2014).…

    • 106 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Intelligence tests are used as a method to asses an individual’s brainpower. These tests can beneficial when it comes to the areas where a person or child is experiencing trouble and devise helpful interventions. These tests can also help identify children who are gifted and may be bored in the class and underachieving as a result. Through testing these students can be identified and gain a better educational experience with more opportunities for success. Although they have proven to be beneficial, intelligence tests to do face some criticism.…

    • 223 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A series of standardized assessments are the most powerful educational hegemony inside schools and influence the meaning of smartness. Students who do poorly in every aspect of life will still be considered as smart as long as they can get good test scores in school. In contrast, students who are talented in the skills that are not included in the standardization will be seen as failure or unintelligent. As Davidson says, “as we narrow the spectrum of skills that we test in schools, more and more kids who have skills outside that spectrum will be labeled as failure”(61). School is supposed to be the place where instructors help students dig out their potential talents so that they can become successful in the future.…

    • 1629 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Disparate treatment are the allegations of discrimination by an employer or organization on the basis of an individual's race or sex (Heneman, Judge & Kammeyer-Mueller, 2012). In order to prove a disparate treatment, there must be evidence of the following four factors: The individual must belong to a protected class; the individual who applied for the position was qualified for the position to be filled; the individual was not hired even though they met the qualifications; the position for which the individual applied for remained open, as the employer continued to search for new applicants that were as qualified as the individual that was rejected (Heneman, Judge & Kammeyer-Mueller, 2012). Disparate treatment does not focus on the motive…

    • 239 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gerald Graff's work, Hidden Intellectualism, is a display of hidden intellectualism in everyday life. In other words, education does not always come from schooling but is also taught from the world around us on the smallest level. In the article, Graff draws attention to what the typical view of what intelligence is often considered to be and why this is wrong throughout several repeated forms. A key strength of this article is presented right away through the debut.…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction Definitions of intelligence vary among scholars, theorists, and laypersons, due to its multidimensionality. However, intelligence typically involves an individual’s ability to learn from experience and adapt to the environment in which they live. I believe that the construct of intelligence should encompass an individual’s ability to effectively communicate in both written and verbal form, to think logically, and to express creativity. Two intelligence tests in which I recently had the opportunity to take and score included the Shipley Institute of Living Scale-2 and the Wonderlic Personnel Test.…

    • 1684 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Education, Intelligence, and Character Walk Together When Martin Luther King-Jr states that “Intelligence plus character-that is the goal of a true education”, his expression resume the key for a students and educators succeed in their lives. Most of parents believe that if their children are enrolled at an expensive school, their children will receive a high education. As adults, high education mean graduate with master degree in a specific area. However, high education is far beyond of pay an expensive school or graduate. Regardless of the school system provides an advanced and comfortable environment, the state of mind of educators, parents and students will define a high education.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The predictive power of IQ for such diverse outcomes suggests intelligence as a parsimonious explanation for individual and group differences in overall competence.” Edward takes the thought in hand of every individual's diversity yet he explains that the exam itself is fit for all personalities and individuals regardless of the exceptions in all personal. The article itself states the definition of both I.Q and intelligence to see the relation to both in the eyes of others “ IQ scores, in contrast, measure the performance of individuals on tests designed to assess intelligence. That is, IQ is an observed, manifest variable, whereas intelligence is an unobserved, latent variable.” In an accurate statement I.Q is not to have an accurate pin on the individual itself.…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the essay “Hidden Intellectualism,” Gerald Graff argues intelligence is not black and white, and there can be different ways for it to be shown. Specifically, Graff believes that in academic settings students should be able to be given the chance to study subjects that interest them. As the author puts it, “But they would be more prone to take on intellectual identities if we encouraged them to do so at first on subjects that interest them rather than ones that interest us.” Although some people believe the only intelligence is shown through academic work and school, Graff insists that schools and colleges are missing an opportunity when they discourage students from turning their interests in nonacademic activities into something they…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the short chapter “Hidden Intellectualism”, Gerald Graff stresses that the modern education systems fails to see the intelligence in that of the person interests of students. He argues that intellectualism is actually the ability to make arguments, compare evidence without bias, summarize the arguments of others, and being apart of intelligent conversation about…

    • 416 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    racism in the classroom is another barrier to access and success formal education. Ethnicity has become a more acceptable and common way of thinking about human diversity. In the UK, there has been increasing concern about the educational achievements of minority ethnic pupils. Socio- economic status is well known to effect on educational attainment, where children from less prosperous backgrounds on average having lower attainment levels than those from more prosperous backgrounds (Cited in Ponsford, 2014). Ethnicity DFE’S statistical returns shows that children from Gypsy and Roma Traveller backgrounds, those who were Irish Travellers and black Caribbean children had the highest rates of exclusion (The Open University, 2014), and evidence…

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    As a society, when we define things such as intelligence in a cookie-cutter fashion, we are only hurting ourselves. When our school does this, we are only hurting our students into becoming one-size fit all members of society. As a culture, we should move away from these ideas into a more fluid education where we can teach students on an individual level rather than telling them to do things that might not be fit to their set of skills. In order for a more intellectually diverse society, our education system and the idea of intelligence needs to…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the history many schools have been teaching lessons only one way. Not only students are suppose to learn in the same way, but also they are evaluated in an identical manner. Although same people believe in this approach, this approach is faulty. There is no doubt that today’s world has been various and this variety should be reflected on educational system. Such alternation create new theories one of which is the Multiple Intelligences Theory, developed by Gardner in 1983.…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays