Louis Uchitelle A Nation That's Losing Its Toolbox Analysis

809 Words 4 Pages
Louis Uchitelle’s “A Nation That’s Losing Its Toolbox” is an article focused on the decline of craftsmanship in the United States. Uchitelle points out that this decline is a cause for the deteriorating self-image of American’s can-do attitude and that the president should take this matter as a concern for the country’s future. In addition, he explains how the rising irrelevance of craftsmanship has led to a downfall of available jobs in America. In essence, Uchitelle claims that the decline of craftsmanship is a social, cultural, and economic problem that needs to be remedied. This claim that craftsmanship has to be brought back into relevance for the good of the country and its citizens is done in a thoroughly effective way with Uchitelle’s …show more content…
The essay starts with a narrative: “The scene inside the Home Depot on Weyman Avenue here would give the old-time American craftsman pause…And if you don’t want to be your own handyman, head to Aisle 23 or Aisle 35, where a help desk will arrange for an installer” (Uchitelle). This story helps to engage the reader and creates the common ground of going to a home improvement store. In addition, Uchitelle uses cause and effect to give his claim more impact for the reader. An example in the text shows how the irrelevance of craftsmanship in the work force is a negative for the country’s citizens: “Traditional vocational training in public high schools is gradually declining, stranding thousands of young people who seek training for a craft without going to college” …show more content…
If Uchitelle had inserted personal experience regarded how the knowledge of craftsmanship had positively affected his life then his credibility would have been more impactful and could have established more common ground with his specific audience of native born Americans. Another weakness is the lack of a presentation of an opposing view. He did not include rebuttals to arguments against his claim which negatively affected the impact of his essay. The strengths in his essays were the use of the appeals of pathos and logos. He impressively appealed to the reader’s emotions in regards to patriotic strength and independence which positively impacted the effectiveness of the essay. He also used reasonable arguments such as how less vocational training in high school can lead to less available jobs. This is potent because of the knowledge that many Americans cannot attend college due to tuition. In conclusion the impactful use of appeals and reasonable arguments used in this essay led to an effective persuasive argument aimed at native born

Related Documents