Long-Standing Explanatory Model Of Transgressive Gender Identity

Improved Essays
I. Introduction: Magical Trans-Formation Transsexual Narratives

How individuals seek to articulate their transgressive gender identities not only informs their biographies but how they understand their present selves. For instance, in the West the “wrong-body” paradigm (Benjamin 1966) that describes a gender identity at odds with the sex-assignment of an individual’s physicality/ biology at birth resulting in cognitive, emotional and physical distress (or dysphoria) is commonly referenced to explain the imperatives of transsexual identities. The more a transsexual encounters dissonance between their internal sense of gender and their material form the further increase of stress, until medical and surgical intervention is warranted. As a long-standing explanatory model, the “born-into-the-wrong-body” model has been one of the most pervasive – and, to gain access for various aforementioned medical and surgical remedies, most widely accepted – of transsexual narratives. Yet it is not the only way transgender individuals in binary-gendered societies attempt to understand their identities
…show more content…
Individuals who specifically identify as transsexuals (unlike other, non-binary transgender people) have reported the wish, the dream, and/or the desire to understand or alleviate their dysphoria through some type of magical transformation. Utilizing components of folklore and mythos, such personal stories describe a comprehension and/ or correcting of gender dysphoria by granting a seemingly enchanted bodily transformation; a revelatory discovery of individuals as gendered changelings in desperate need of transposition, or that through sheer strength of will, desires could act as catalyst to initiate physical alterations to the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    From childhood into adulthood, a person is bombarded with societal pressure to personify the roles assigned to their gender– gender meaning how the individual identifies (male, female, transgender, gender fluid, etc.) not their biological sex. Traits or behaviors typical to one gender are deemed socially unacceptable. Aaron H. Devor–previously Holly Devor, before his gender reassignment in 2002– professor of sociology and former Dean of Graduate Studies at the University of Victoria in British Columbia, illustrates this in his essay, “Becoming Members of Society: Learning the Social Meanings of Gender.” In his essay, Devor explains how characteristics such as behavior or physical appearance (apart from one’s reproductive system) define individuals…

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article, Trans Women Manifesto, Julia Scrano elucidates the unstated idea that trans women are the most maligned and misunderstood (10) sexual minorities. This is consistently reinforced throughout the article with examples of the many prejudices that trans women face: transphobia, cissexism, and misogyny. Although expressed differently, these prejudices are all rooted in oppositional sexism: the belief that female and male are rigid, mutually exclusive categories (12-13). In this article a recurring, subconscious, question I faced was, what is gender and how do you tell the difference between man and woman? Every time this question came to mind, Scrano reinforced the fact that there is no such thing as gender - there is only the gender we experience ourselves as and the gender we perceive others to be (13).…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From this point that institutions rely too heavily on codified identities, leading them to re-identify populations in ways that counter individual’s meanings (124), all informed by a “politics of accommodation” that informs a “theoretical split…(that is) problematic in that they are unable to account for…(trans) subjectivities” (CITE). Valentine picks up this tension is the crafting of his own ethnography, an ‘impulse to open up transgender for both theoretical and political purposes, and the recognition that in some cases, the work of many of my activist informants aims to do just the opposite”…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When talking about how intersex individuals fit into the theory’s model, she concludes, “[…] gender causes us to perceive the natural world (the body) in a particular way, and thereby to impose upon it the dichotomous category ‘sex.’ Sex, then, is no longer the raw material from which culture produces gender. Instead, sex is in some important sense an effect of gender” (17). When thinking about transgender individuals, then, this would mean that from their gender identities comes their sex. There is still a tension here, however, because physical attributes like genitalia and hormone production are evident before conscious thought.…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Observational Documentary, “Growing up Trans”, we are able to peer into the lives of transgender children, observing their everyday struggles as they live a life once considered an unadulterated taboo. This Documentary explores the different ways gender identity can affect the course of a child’s life as well as their quality of adolescence. From a young age, people are trained by society, ie, socialized to become participants in the gender to which they were assigned. This gender assignment and socialization based on sex, more often than not results in the systematic acceptance of gender norms( the conformance of gender identity and expression of an individual). Girls are customarily taught to be more feminine and end up spending more…

    • 238 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Boundaries of Application Boxes While I was filling out my application to The University of Charleston’s School of Pharmacy summer program for undergraduate students I was stopped abruptly when reaching the biographical information section. The speedy pace with which I was writing in my emergency contact information, such as my address and telephone number was disrupted when I reached the gender identification section. The gender ID section contained more than the two ordinary male and female boxes to be filled in. The sight of three boxes alone was enough to throw off my focus from the application.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stories involving transgender people have been in newspapers, magazines, and tabloids for over fifty five years and have captivated and intrigued the American audience from the start. It all began in 1955 when Christine Jorgensen, born George, publicly announced her gender confirming surgery and began life as a legally recognized women. There was a media frenzy with headlines such as “Bronx GI Becomes a Woman!” and “Bronx ‘Boy’ Is Now A Girl”. But instead of “withdraw[ing] from public attention [Christine’ turned the notoriety to her advantage with a series of lucrative tours on the lecture and nightclub circuit” (McQuiston 1989).…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One Of The Guys

    • 1564 Words
    • 7 Pages

    “Just One of the Guys?”: Reflection “Just One of the Guys” is a book that showcases transgender people, a group that is otherwise overlooked in many cases, showing how social parallels that foster forms of inequality affect everyone not just those in the gender binary. Kristen Schilt’s main objective is to show that these “natural difference schemas” some people continue to abide by are to blame for the continuous of gender inequality. Schilt proves this in her writing by drawing on interviews and observational data to prove that despite the differing experiences of individual transmen, that in regards to their journeys toward transitioning, their stories are a testament to systematic gender inequality.…

    • 1564 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both of these works portray the difficulties that transgender and transsexual people face on a daily basis. Through the stories of Brandon and Jennifer, one can see that the social attitudes and stigmas toward the transgendered has not changed…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout history, society has shaped the lives of individuals by assigning individuals a specific way to be a part of society while deviation is most likely viewed as unacceptable and censured. Betty Friedan in chapter 1 of her novel “The Feminine Mystique” describes society’s assigned role for women and how women sacrificed their desires to fulfil this role and assimilate into society. E.J Graff in his essay “The M/F Boxes” describes how transgendered and intersex individuals suffer humiliation and alienation because they were not what society expected of what a man or a woman is. Stephen Hinshaw in an excerpt from “What is the Triple Bind?” brings to attention the contemporary issue young girls are facing as they are expected to accomplish…

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Medicalization Essay

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages

    A group that we looked at closely, radical lesbians who rejected trans women, were very adamant about how only those they identified as “real women” were acceptable in their spaces. Trans women were, to them, the pinnacle of patriarchal invaders of female spaces; Janice Raymond, author of The Trannsexual Empire, even went as far as covertly comparing trans women to Nazis, and “real women” the victims of concentration camps. Raymond also says that those who go through medical transition are inherently rapists: “all transsexuals rape women’s bodies… appropriating this body for themselves”. The decision to transition medically seems to be a double edged sword: if one decides against it, they will not be taken seriously because they are not succumbing to the societal expectations of what a trans identity should be. If someone does transition, they will be subjected to endlessly invasive physical procedures, legal difficulties, psychological evaluations, and so on.…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender dysphoria goes all the way back to the Greeks and has been recognized throughout Europe, Asia, and America. The Gallae were people in ancient Greece, Rome, and Persia, who displayed some kind of gender or sexual variety. “ The ancient mythology was replete with stories of those we now call transgender people, which clearly indicates that transgender was something that was commonplace in those times”. The Gallae were known as the transgender people back in the ancient era. During the seventeenth through nineteenth, centuries Europe helped the male and female transgendered people.…

    • 1342 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    ‘“Night to His Day’: The Social Construction of Gender,” Judith Lorber’s article written in the mid 90s, describes western societies as having two genders: men and women. Lorber explains that, while they not wholly separate genders, transvestities and transexuals are “crossover genders” (2007: 43) floating in between society’s two genders. Society’s framework for gender affects everything a person does from the moment that person is born, without them even knowing it. The clothes a person wears, the friends a person makes, the job that person ultimately does or does not get: all affected by gender.…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis: What Makes a Woman? In What Makes a Woman, Elinor Burkett argues that in order to truly be a woman one must understand the hardships associated with being a female in today’s society. She supports her claim by utilizing the logos of scientific arguments, establishes ethos by using her status as a woman (who has spent her life fighting for women’s rights) to declare the barrier between the male/female genders, as well as euphemism to present potentially offending ideas formally. Furthermore, Burkett assesses what it means to be a woman on the trans spectrum, but more so according to the brain’s chemical responsiveness to the binary “male and female” genders.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the world today, individuals tend to measure success in life by happiness and the ability to advance in society. Organizations constantly compete to gain power by making new discoveries day by day. But when does that search for knowledge cross the line and become too dangerous for humanity entirely? Sex Reassignment Surgery (SRS), a medical accomplishment poses a great threat not only on individuals but society as a whole. Similar to the monster in Frankenstein, who transitions through the challenge of being rejected by society and his creator, transexual individuals deal with similar psychological issues.…

    • 1169 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays