Lincoln Popular Sovereignty Analysis

Improved Essays
On Popular Sovereignty

While he opposed slavery personally, Lincoln also thought it his duty, and the duty of all Americans, to combat not only the practice itself, but also any notion that might provoke its prosperity. While defenders of popular sovereignty claimed it maintained a neutral approach to slavery, it created other dangers for the nation both related to the issue of human rights and beyond. As a northern statesman, Lincoln believed that the principle of popular sovereignty directly assaults the country’s foundations on basic ethical beliefs and system of justice.
As the founders intended a moral background for the Constitution and the country, Lincoln states through his speeches that popular sovereignty violates that morality
…show more content…
Though he does not necessarily believe that slaves were equal to white men in all things, he holds a certain reverence for the Constitutional ideal of all men, having been created equal under the doctrine of consent, all enjoying the same unalienable rights. Even the south cannot fully deny the humanity of the negroes (“Speech on Kansas-Nebraska” 326), as Lincoln puts it, as they annexed slave trade piracy on punishment of death, though they surely would never do so for the piracy of livestock, and even try their best to distance themselves from slave traders. Lincoln trusts both in the humanity of the slaves and the wrongness in one man owning another, and hopes to explain those ideas amongst those who had even the slightest chance of understanding. However, while Lincoln intends to determine whether or not blacks count as human beings and therefore have rights, the popular sovereignty that Douglas proposes bypasses that argument …show more content…
Stephen Douglas, as the principle’s main defender, supposes that their “liberty and independence are based upon the right of the people to form for themselves such a government as they may choose…and no limitation ought to be applied to this power” (“Speech at Chicago 1858”, 20). Here, the supposed power of democracy surpasses any virtuous ideologies, religious or not, and likewise ignores any true meaning behind the Constitution. The law exists, for Douglas and his followers, as a mere guideline for how the majority can vote on their rulings, but does not limit them. Meanwhile, Lincoln asserts that slavery acts as a violation of the mantra that all men are created equal. He quotes his ancient faith, and the faith shared by many other Americans and the founders themselves (“Speech on Kansas Nebraska”, 328), to help make his point and combat the power Douglas hands to the majority. While Lincoln insists the majority—and therefore those who would rule in popular sovereignty—must have limits upon the rights of mankind, his opponent upheld the right of democratic rule above basic human decency. This is exactly what Lincoln fears may happen to the rest of the American people. He “object[s] to it [popular sovereignty] as a dangerous dalliance for a free people…that

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    By highlighting this disconnect Douglass is able to argue that all citizens in the United States are morally implicated by the calamity of slavery, regardless of location and personal political beliefs. Therefore the burden of responsibility lands on all citizens, for politics are central and involve every aspect of a good democratic citizen’s…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lincoln was a republican candied that ran on a platform of preserving the Union and preventing the expansion of slavery. Through the speeches that he gave, we can learn about his platform and his core beliefs. During Lincoln’s House Divided speech he talks about how important it is to know were we are as a whole nation. In his speech he said,” If we could first know where we are and whither we are tending, we could better judge what to do and how to do it”. Morals are changing in the world so Lincoln wants to have laws that suit where the country is heading.…

    • 367 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1861 Abraham Lincoln took office as the President of the United States and with it he inherited a nation at odds. While there are numerous issues that could be mentioned during this volatile time in America, the focus of this research is on the tensions surrounding slavery and the abolitionist movement and the role Lincoln played in the establishment of the 13th Amendment. At the time of Lincoln’s presidential appointment, America had already seen the secession of the Confederate States and was on the verge of all-out war (source?). What takes place during Lincoln’s presidency is well documented as is his role in the eventual abolishment of slavery; however, the purpose of this research is to determine Lincoln’s reasoning for implementing…

    • 1363 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Lincoln had a strong opinion about the races and where each stood. In one response highlighted in the book, Lincoln expressed that he thought the two races would never be able to live together. He also said that his race, the white race, was the more superior of the two. This type of thinking goes against what we have believed to be true of Lincoln. As we read the Declaration of Independence, we often think of Lincoln when we hear the words “all men are created equal.”…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Apush Dbq Analysis

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the late 18th century, the Constitution of the United States was ratified and the unification of the union along with it. Although the Constitution was created to produce order and unity, the nation was split into two by the mid-19th century. After a vast amount of territories being brought into the union due to the nation 's’ Manifest Destiny, the issue of slavery became the center of politics. The cause of such political and social chaos was the fact that the Constitution had not specifically addressed the issue of slavery and what was to be done about it. It’s consequences were that the nation had felt it’s repercussions years later.…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Douglass’ “The Constitution of the U.S.: Is It Proslavery or Antislavery,” similarly argues, “This is said by the slaveholders in America...but it is not said by the Constitution itself” (Douglass 270). Douglass talks about the Preamble of the Constitution and how the rights and blessings that the Constitution gives to the people. He tries to say that in the Constitution in never stated that slavery was a part of the American culture and the rights given. The people who hold slaves, the rich and powerful whites, are the ones that claim slavery is a given right to them. The same white Southerners were the ones that claimed that the "Northerners had betrayed the Compromise and the Constitution" (Roark 363).…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thomas J. DiLorenzo’s book, The Real Lincoln: A New Look at Abraham Lincoln, His Agenda, and an Unnecessary War, is about unveiling the side of President Lincoln that is not told in today’s history books and is overlooked by the monumental Lincoln legend. DiLorenzo’s book exposes the myths that made the Civil War seem vague. DiLorenzo is an American economics professor at Loyola University Maryland Sellinger School of Business. He has written many other books regarding mostly history subjects. DiLorenzo is certainly qualified to write this book based off of his previous education and knowledge regarding Abraham Lincoln.…

    • 1518 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While many people in America debated the morality of slavery, Northerners thought slavery was unnecessary, cruel, and inhumane, while on the other hand southerners felt they needed slavery. They needed slaves to grow the crops and allowed the farmers to be extremely successful. Also, they wanted slaves for free labor that allowed the farmers to save money. Congress passed many laws and acts to appease the two sides of the nation. While the presidential candidates shared their thought and opinions on the issue.…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Civil War Dbq

    • 1703 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The latter half of the nineteenth century saw a bitter and bloody Civil War fought over one underlying factor: slavery. Though many, including President Abraham Lincoln himself, claimed this war was to ‘protect the union’, the south clearly wanted slaves, and opposed anyone who could take their slaves away. To all, this contention for slavery brought up questions as to what American liberty and freedom really meant in relation to African Americans, questions that yielded an incredibly wide array of answers within the country. What caused this array of answers differed with the race, sex, socioeconomic demographic that Americans were a part of. These perspectives on liberty and freedom in relation to African Americans, though different because…

    • 1703 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The constitution is identified as “the fundamental law” by many lawmakers.(16) He defines what the constitution is supposed to represent in order to draw attention to the cynicism as it “guarantees the right to hold and to hunt slaves is a part. ”(15) When Douglass says “...the Constitution is a GLORIOUS LIBERTY DOCUMENT.”(16), he capitalizes “glorious liberty document” to emphasize the irony in which this document that represents freedom for white men, is seen as “sanction of the hateful thing”(16) for the slaves he represents . The constitution represented the forefathers liberation while further enslaving black people.…

    • 1313 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Fiery Trial by Eric Foner is a book about Abraham Lincoln and American Slavery. Abraham Lincoln was perhaps one of the most influential American politicians of all time and served as the 16th President of the United States. Lincoln was born in Kentucky, where he was certainly surrounded by slavery being that one in every five people there was a slave. There was also slavery in Lincoln’s family, many of his relatives owned slaves. Such as his Uncle Isaac who owned forty three slaves at the time of his death.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book, “Abraham Lincoln and the Second American Revolution”, McPherson elaborates on the trials of Abraham Lincoln to keep the Union together despite the growing division between the northern and southern states. The book discusses the legacy of the Civil war in relation to politics, economics, and post-war relations. McPherson presents the question: was the civil war revolutionary? In order to address the question, he defines revolution as “the overthrow of the existing social and political order by internal violence”. McPherson describes the overthrow of slavery as an economic and political revolution.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the speech What Does the Fourth of July Mean to a Slave, Frederick Douglass address the hypocrisy of slavery in the United States by the use of examples, where the law or constitution contradicts with real action. First, Douglass mentions that while America proclaim it is a country that grants everyone the natural right to freedom, slaves were exempted from freedom, prosperity, justice, and independence, and these are all passed down only to the whites. Second, Douglass also mentions how the country America contradicts with the constitution and the Bible, how liberty is not equally granted, and how there is no humanity. In addition, Douglass points out that though everyone on Earth knows that slavery is not right and is against God, no one…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Daniel Webster describes the challenging of state rights during this time. In his text, he talks about one of the complaints of the South being the North holding the escaped slaves from the South, rather than returning them to their slave owners. The South believed that it was the duty of the North to return these slaves to their owners (Webster, 46). Stephen A. Douglas alludes to the power of the rights of the states with his affirmative opinion of popular sovereignty. He states, “The government was founded on that principle, and must be administered in the same sense in which it was founded (Douglas, 75).”…

    • 1255 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The speech What to Slave Is the Fourth of July given by Fredrick Douglas; the purpose was to help in the celebration of the Declaration of Independence Day. Indeed, Douglas begins with a sense of a humble unturned. Later offering an apology, Douglas explains for not taking the time to prepare properly for the occasion. Meanwhile, in the middle of the speech, Douglas becomes hostile to the idea of trying to convince the people to join the fight with him in this revolution against slavery.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays