Lily's Tragic Flaw

Improved Essays
The novel The House of Mirth written by Edith Wharton follows the tragic story of main character Lily Bart. The novel focuses on this upper class group in society and Lily's constant struggle and ultimate failure to keep her place in this group. Her decisions causes her social decline, ending ultimately with her death. Lily’s story follows the classic structure of a tragedy, most importantly including a tragic flaw and a great deal of suffering. After carefully analyzing Lily, it is clear that her tragic flaw is the need for a high financial and social standing. She is willing to give up a life of happiness and love for the more superficial aspects of a relationship. Due to the fact that Lily is aware of her own declining status, her story …show more content…
In this novel, Lily’s flaw is her need for a high financial and social standing. She does not see herself in any class below her. She even denies a proposal from a not so wealthy man named Selden, due to his financial differences. This can be inferred after Lily and Selden kiss at the party in chapter 12, “Ah, love me, love me — but don't tell me so!" she sighed with her eyes in his; and before he could speak she had turned and slipped through the arch of boughs, disappearing in the brightness of the room beyond (Book 1, chpt 12, pg 112).” Even though Lily does not say that she cannot be with him outloud, her actions are very clear. It is pointed out early in the novel that Selden does not have a high financial standing. From analyzing the types of men that Lily prefers, it is clear that she has the sole intention of finding wealthy and well established …show more content…
It was the strangest part of Lily’s strange experience, the hearing of these names, the seeing the fragmentary and distorted image of the world she had lived in reflected in the mirror of the working-girls’ minds. She had never before suspected the mixture of insatiable curiosity and contemptuous freedom with which she and her kind were discussed in this under-world of toilers who lived on their vanity and self-indulgence. Every girl in Mme. Regina’s work-room knew to whom the headgear in her hands was destined, and had her opinion of its future wearer, and a definite knowledge of the latter’s place in the social system. That Lily was a star fallen from that sky did not, after the first stir of curiosity had subsided, materially add to their interest in her. She had fallen, she had ‘gone under,’ and true to the ideal of their race, they were awed only by success-by the gross tangible image of material achievement. The consciousness of her different point of view merely kept them at a little distance from her, as though she were a foreigner with whom it was an effort to talk, (Book II, chpt. 10, pg 232).

This excerpt reveals a memorable moment in Lily’s downfall as she is able to begin to become absorbed in lower-class society. She hates her room in the boarding-house, she feels useless at being a working woman, and she learns how others view

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Kidd Quotes

    • 625 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The character Kidd makes me particularly admire was Lily. The traits she showed throughout the story showed how strong mentally and emotionally she is. Being a child and going through many hardships such as her mother dying and her father verbally abusing her shows the emotional toughness she has. “ I knew that the explosion I'd heard that day had killed her. The sound still sneaked into my head once in a while and surprised me.…

    • 625 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the short story, Marigolds, Eugenia Collier wrote in the eyes of a 14 year old girl that’s transitioning to adulthood during the Great depression. Lizabeth and the other children feel like their world is falling apart. They try to pretend that their world is fine, until it starts to affect their families. In Marigolds, Collier constructs a theme of self struggle through the eyes of the innocent. The theme is shown throughout the story.…

    • 338 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Similar to the indirect characterization of Lily, Kidd symbolizes the slips of paper located in the wailing wall as evidence of May's suffering, in order to demonstrate May’s struggle to deal with her concern for those around her. For example, during the novel, August explains to Lily that the wailing wall is similar to the one located in Jerusalem where the Jewish people go to mourn. Additionally, while discussing the wailing wall August expresses, “All those bits of paper you see out there stuck between the stones are things May has written down-all the heavy feelings she carries around” (98). Nevertheless, the phrase “All those bits of paper” emphasizes that the wall contains numerous bits of paper, hence proving the great deal of suffering…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Samantha Tsang Tsang 1 Mrs. Fenn ENG4U1-02 6th January, 2015 The Unbeatable Not every woman in the world owns human rights, and treated equally as men. Lots of women suffer a lot of pain through their life. But they do not surrender. Instead, they power up and face the problem together.…

    • 2907 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    is forgiveness, prejudice, and female power. The first obstacle Lily has to face is forgiveness. She needs to face forgiveness for many reasons. The first reason is the guilty feeling she carries daily.…

    • 117 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With her “stand-in mother” Rosaleen, Lily runs to Tiburon, South Carolina from her abusive father who still has not moved on from Lilys mother’s death. Finding a place her mother had inscribed on one of her old pictures of a black Mary, Lily and Rosaleen stay under the care of the Boatwright sisters on their honey farm. As the novel continues, Lily becomes a member of the Boatwrights religious community and finds a sense of a mother figure from their religious idol, black Mary, as well as the women who participate in their religious beliefs. In the end, Lily finds acceptance with her mother’s leaving and resolves hot tempers between herself and T.Ray while being able to continue staying at the Boatwright’s house. The major theme the feminist lens focuses on is that there is strength in a female community.…

    • 1395 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She is raised up to believe that blacks are second-class citizens, and the world is logically structured that way. Lily also thinks that all African Americans are likewise uneducated and ugly. However, when Lily meets the unique, educated, thoughtful August Boatwright, she must adjust her assumptions and combat her prejudice. At first, Lily feels stunned that a black person could be as creative, smart and sensitive as August. Combating and recognizing her shock allows Lily to realize the truth about racism.…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Compared to herself at the start of the novel, she is not self-doubting anymore. Her big decision to get away from the bad setting she lived in, changed her life and herself for the better. She learns how to keep bees from the Boatwright sisters and goes to high school in Tiburon now. Throughout Lily’s journey of finding her self-assurance and a good environment for her to live in, she experiences a good change in…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the beginning of Lily life, she wasn’t care by anyone in her family. Her mother ignored due to the facts that first off she is a girl, and a third child. Lily stated “For my entire life I longed for love… I dreamed that my mother would notice me and that she and the rest of my family…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the novel House of Mirth, written by Edith Wharton, one can argue many different perspectives about the character of Lily Barth. Many will argue that she was a beauty who only wanted to have a nice life, like those she surrounded herself with. Others will say that she was a girl who wanted to have it all but due to lack of a proper upbringing she was never guided the right way. However the novel is best described as a series of ups and downs, for the character of Lily Bart. She wanted to have it all…

    • 2142 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The House of Mirth written by Edith Wharton explores the harsh realities of the society surrounding New York City in the late 1800s. Focusing primarily on the threat of scandal and preservation of public image in New York’s elite social class, Lily Bart is withering away on the marriage market and confronts the constant question; marry for love, or marry for…

    • 62 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Message that the Author has About the Society/ Times Money. Money is delicate. Money if handled wrong by the rich or poor has the power to destroy a whole lifestyle. In Lily Bart’s case, money destroys a life. The message the author of “The House of Mirth”, Edith Wharton has about the society in this book is that money runs things.…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Examining the text from a feminist view point shows the narrative is a phallocentric text, concerned wholly with Gabriel’s perspective and his role as master of ceremonies at the party, presenting Gabriel as a stereotypical male; part of the dominant patriarchal culture of that time. As aforementioned, the conventional syntagmatic structure is that the novella is in three parts, and in each part Gabriel makes a mistake which has a profound effect on his sense of self with a woman; Lily and her bitter dismissal, Miss Ivors ' humiliation of him, and Gretta’s revelation. With each woman Gabriel is shown to be condescending, dismissive and guilty of underestimating all three, perhaps, it can be argued, because they are female. However, in each of these three interactions, the women as a whole do not respond in the way women of that time may have been expected to, their actions disturb Gabriel’s poise and wound his self-image and are representative of women challenging the traditional male supremacy.…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When Lily gains consciousness she calls Atlas for help, he takes her to the hospital. There Lily finds out about her pregnancy. She is really scared of Ryle so she hides in Atlas home for few days to heal herself and also to decide what she wants for herself and her baby. During her pregnancy Ryle maintains his distance from Lily and gives her space to choose whether she wants to get back together or wants a divorce.…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Artist And Sexism

    • 1057 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Through his portrait of Stephen Dedalus in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, Joyce suggests that being an artist is difficult because one must rebel against societal standards, values and ideals. This includes the rejection of religion, politics, and sexual morality among many others. In To the Lighthouse, Woolf agrees with Joyce that there are certain values and morals that the artist figure must reject, however, Woolf shows that female artists have more obstacles to overcome, mainly gender roles and sexism, in order to create art. Woolf 's novel shows that the struggle is harder for female artists because of the criticism they face from men through the characters of Lily, a painter, and Mrs. Ramsay, a housewife, and how the novel showcases their struggles and success compared to the novel’s male figures.…

    • 1057 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays