Lifeboat Ethical Dilemmas

Improved Essays
I presented my 11-year-old daughter with the dilemma of 5 people on a lifeboat from last week’s unit. According to Lilli, “Four of them should throw one off of the boat.” I then asked her why and what determines who is thrown overboard. She replied that the four strongest should throw the weakest overboard because they have the best chance. She said it is survival of the fittest. I then inserted our 5-member family into the scenario, of which she is the smallest. She still insisted she should be thrown over as the weakest. When asked why I shouldn’t voluntarily sacrifice myself for the benefit of my family. She replied, “the four strongest are needed to protect each other to give the group the best chance of survival.” I asked her what her

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In Garrett Hardin’s essay, Lifeboat Ethics, he emphasizes on the ethical issue of how to judiciously help the poor and the argument behind it. In the beginning of the essay Hardin responds to the comparison of Earth as a spaceship, by stating that it can be dangerous when used by misguided idealists to justify suicidal policies for sharing our resources through uncontrolled immigration and foreign aid. Interestingly enough, he prefers to address the issue with a lifeboat metaphor, in which refers to the rich nations (such as the United States) as being aboard the boat, as well as the poor nations who are swimming around the boats for…

    • 109 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “In the Unlikely Event of a Water Landing” Two young psychologists, John Darley and Bibb Latane, put together two well thought out experiments to rationalize the response time of individuals in groups. After reading about the brutal attack of Catherine Genovese in New York in 1964, which ultimately lead to her death, the two men were on a mission to figure out why nobody helped. Even with the witnesses being awakened by her screams, they chose to do nothing about it until it was too late. After Darley and Latane had the results from the experiments, they established five simple steps that would, hopefully, encourage others to help another when needed. Many people feel it isn’t their responsibility to help someone who is in dire need.…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the time of 1912, the sinking of the world’s largest, most advanced ship shook the world” (Bender). The ship was totally unprepared for the iceberg it hit, but it improved ship safety in many ways. However, there were many things that could have been done to prevent the loss of so many lives. First of all, the Titanic wasn’t fully prepared with…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Zaroff Vs Rainsford

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages

    People all over the world run into experiences that land them into life or death situations. Many people go through survival experiences when they are forced into that position that is irrelevant to the person’s choices. For that reason, people should not be held accountable for life or death situations that are unforeseeable. Rainsford was being hunted mercilessly through a jungle by a man called Zaroff, and Rainsford had reached the point of no return there for killing General Zaroff in his defense.…

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Alabama ISSUES AND TRENDS 2 Roles, Ethical Considerations, and Effectiveness of the Adult Gerontological Acute Care Nurse Practitioner In all healthcare fields the providers are bound by a moral code of ethics that are defined within the ethical principles and serve to guide the care of all individuals. According to Hamric, Hanson, Tracy, and O’Grady (2014) ethical principles are a set of core values that are fundamental obligations that healthcare professionals use to guide all care provided in the medical field. Ethical Principles The Adult Gerontological Acute Care Nurse Practitioner (AGACNP) is guided by a set of ethical principles that help provide the kind of care every individual deserves.…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In defense of the survivors’ guilt arising from not helping the poor, he claimed that “the net result of conscience-stricken people giving up their unjustly held seats is the elimination of that sort of conscience from the lifeboat”. He defined guilty about one’s good luck as a type of conscience and the newcomer’s lack of guilt about the rich people’s loss as conscience drain; but the author deliberately omitted the morality of rich people’s indifference to the poor asking for help. Counting the negative effects on total conscience in the lifeboat if no rescue is attempted, the final solution to the lifeboat dilemma might be changed. Essentially, the author’s negligence of social injustice against impoverished people and the ethical issue indifference is just a result of his bias for the rich countries.…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethics is the philosophical study of morality. In other words, it is the study of what is wrong and right, good or bad. Humanity has been intrigued with the answer to these subject matters for hundreds of years. In that time there have been several philosophers such as Aristotle who have formulated moral theories like Virtue ethics. Not all of these theories are put in practice today but they do help in the solving of moral issues.…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Kailani, I congratulate you for taking part on that policy change. Transitioning smoothly from the emergency care (ER) to intensive care (ICU) is not a simple matter. I have witnessed many safety issues due to miscommunication and treatment delay happening between ER and ICU. Consequently, relationships between ER staff and the ICU are commonly known as tensed and conflicting in many hospitals I have worked. Similar to your organization, discerning managers implemented a way to remedy the issue and proposed the ICU and ER staff days of orientation to each unit so that understanding of the routine and responsibilities can be achieved.…

    • 209 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Titanic Research Paper

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages

    There were 2228 people on board of the Titanic, 337 in first class, 285 second class, 721 in third class (“Statistical”). Men woman and children lost their lives that day. The majority of the children were saved if they were in…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Preserved and remembered or left and forgotten? Everyone can come and learn about the tragedy of the Titanic. The Titanic can become a monument. Even though it will cost millions of dollars all of the money will eventually be paid back. I think the Titanic should be preserved so people can learn about the history of the Titanic.…

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Adrift in a Moral Sea Life often throws people some difficult challenges where there ends up being more than one right course of action. Everyone has their own different morals that they have acquired through out their life and this helps them decide which ethical perspective that they believe in. One instance, of where you can look at multiple ethical perspectives to solve a problem comes from the essay “Lifeboat Ethics” by Garrett Harden, which is about being shipwrecked in the middle of the ocean and having to choose who you want to let on the boat. There are 50 people who are on the boat and there is room for only 10 more people, while there are 100 people who are stranded in the water outside of the boat. There are various theories…

    • 1597 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction: In the article “Living on a Lifeboat,” Garrett Hardin believes that our obligations to the poor and hungry are metaphors based on the ethics of living on a lifeboat and the tragedy of the common. The ethics of living on lifeboat is based upon the rich and the poor. Rich people are in the lifeboat and poor people are in the sea. The wealthy has only three options in the situation with the poor people.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Garrett Hardin’s “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor”, Hardin argues about “a world that must solve real and pressing problems of overpopulation, hunger and moral duty.” Hardin sets the stage by first giving his analysis on the structure of the world today by describing the earth as a lifeboat rather than a spaceship. He then dives into how population control, the tragedy of the commons and immigration are some of the main reasons for the problems we have today. Hardin argues that simply helping people and giving charitably will not solve these problems. Peter Singer, in “Famine, Affluence, and Morality” seemingly goes against Hardin by saying that “if it is in our power to prevent something bad from happening, without thereby…

    • 994 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Lone Survivor Ethical Dilemma: Defending What is Right No Matter the Consequences The ethical dilemma in Lone Survivor is one that hits most American viewers close to home. Happening early in the movie, it toys with our morals.…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Picture yourself going out for coffee on a normal New York city afternoon, you stumble upon a high intensity scene. You see a man lying on the sidewalk motionless with a crowd surrounding them. There is a woman who appears to be yelling at a fireman who is washing a fire truck just across the street. As soon as you get closer to the scene you realize there are no First responders or EMS workers near the lifeless man. This presents you with an ethical dilemma since you are Ethical egoist, you chose to stand by and watch, although you question this decision as soon as it is made.…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays