Analysis Of Alan Mcmonagle's Short Story 'Liar Liar'

Improved Essays
In most families, the role of a parent depends solely upon the relationship that they have with their children. In Alan McMonagle short story entitled Liar Liar, the author portrays the main character of the story—the father— as the epitome of a great man, in the eyes of his naive son. The main theme of Alan McMonagle’s short story Liar Liar is relationships. In the story, the father uses the gangster western films to communicate with his son in order to fulfill the desires of escaping his worrisome life, not being aware of the repercussions that may exist. This is portrayed in the story through the use of characterization of the father figure, incorporating American Gangster Film values and morals in juxtaposing the father’s actions and the …show more content…
According the son’s perspective, the father is seen as an exemplary character due to the boy’s immature brain’s inability to see the underlying flaws of adults—his old man in this case— as he is simply a child. Consequently, this emotional blindness causes the son to see his father as a joyous man as he is described to always be happier when he walks home with a brown paper bag in his hands late at night (McMonagle 53). Moreover, unaware of the concept of inebriation and the way that it alters an adult brain to feel certain unforeseen emotions, the son’s description of his father is naive as he states in the story: “It’s like one person goes out the door and another comes back” (McMonagle 57). Furthermore, this description purely demonstrates the narrator’s way of showing the dubious relationship between the father and the son as the boy does not recognize the same man to be his father before and after his consistent routine. Therefore, by showing two different versions of his elder, the narrator is found to be situated in between two split personalities of his own father, which later influences the son to see his father as a great man with a confusing lifestyle. This miscommunication between the father and his son shows the reader that even with the minuscule acknowledgment of his …show more content…
The parallel between the son and the reader depicts the way in which the misunderstanding of the father’s alcohol addiction led to the son looking up to his father as the epitome of an amazing human. Thus, as the son is a novice to adulthood, he looks up to his elder only when this older individual is in his state of inebriation. For instance, one night his father sporadically comes up with the idea to “move to America”. This idea was found to interest the son as he found it to be an interesting goal to think about as his identity degraded into becoming an American gangster (McMonagle 55). This fondness for gangsters, although not fully developed in the child’s mind, is detrimental as he is only following in his father’s footsteps, which to him is positive but to everyone else is not. As a result, by not being aware of his father’s drunken state, he is made to believe that he and his father will in fact “move to America” (McMonagle 55) to share their newfound passion for gangsters and eventually become one. As the story progresses, the reader demonstrates that the son is validating what he and his father committed such as stealing and lying because of the fact that the father “He has to save money before we can go.”

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    What is the point in even writing a story about a father and son relationship? The relationship between a father and son can vary depending on the person, but “Arm Wrestling with My Father” is a wonderful example as to how a father and son form their own connection. Brad Manning enlightens the reader on how Manning and his father formed their own connection. Unusual to some, but to Manning it is the form of bond he gets to have with his father which is very special. Brad Manning really shows off this father and son relationship by using the following elements of rhetoric; the purpose, thesis, audience, methods of development, and the language his writing.…

    • 1448 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Continually literature and society combine to make a statement about events transpired in the news. Authors such as Arthur Miller of Death of a Salesman and August Wilson of Fences use platforms such as plays to display a lack of reality and common sense present in their days. Both plays above inconspicuously use the Maxson brothers in Fences and the Loman brothers in Death of a Salesman to convey a truth in the underlying of society. With the brothers both authors elaborate on each brother in one way or more disobeying a father’s desired occupation, favoritism, and repeating their history. Undoubtedly Fences and Death of a Salesman showcase a recurring pattern of habits among fathers and sons.…

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “How much you can learn when you fail determines how far you will go into achieving your goals” -Roy Bennett. People do not always learn from their mistakes, even when given a second chance. When people make a mistake they do not always see the problem with their mistake. Sometimes they make the mistake again. In our world, the choices you make and the actions you perform define your character.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The narrative voice of Junot Diaz "Drown" depicts on how the protagonist has a collective amount of strained relationships who are physically and mentally drowning him. Having no father, to selling illegal substances in order to help his mother pay the phone and cable bill to address his engagement of homosexual activities with his former best friend Beto. The argument the protagonist illustrates indicates how it's preventing him from achieving success. The antagonist (Beto) distinguished everything he hated about the neighborhood to put everything in perspective for the narrator in which he "needed to learn how to walk the world he told me. There's a lot more out there."…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Art and literature are the foundation of life. Long before Netflix and social media existed, people used books to entertain themselves. Mason Cooley said “reading gives us someplace to go when we have to stay where we are”. Even in 21st century, the age of technology, people use books as a source of entertainment and writing as a form of self-expression. Books and reading in general has many benefits like mental stimulation, gaining knowledge and much more.…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Johnny’s mother starts talking to the father about the father son banquet, because Johnny is too shy and nervous himself. Before the scout boy meeting Johnny’s father has a couple of drinks to make him seem “normal”. When Johnny goes home he and his mother have an argument about this manner. the main issue of the story is not getting Johnny’s father to communicate with him and he doesn’t pay much attention. Johnny’s father has a drinking problem this has led to not having a great father son bond.…

    • 1257 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    John Updike, author of “Son,” uses an unusual structure of writing to convey a very important point in his story. His story relates to the relationship between a father and a son and uses many generations in his own family as examples. In his story, Updike writes about his feelings and thoughts about having a teenage son and then goes on explaining how his father felt about him and how his father felt about him, and so on. When he first talks about his teenage son, he makes sure that he states the date because the goal of him writing in this order is not to confuse the reader but so that the reader goes in depth in understanding the beliefs and attitudes that are passed down from generation to generation. Updike introduces his story by…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    His first encounter with his intoxicated father was described as he was stumbling around the house, slamming doors, and thumping into things. As the author uses these action words to describes the noises that was heard that night, it is also allowing the audience to experience the fear a young boy, such as the author, was experiencing himself. As the author’s father encounters a near death experience, forcing him to become sober for the next fifteen years, he describes it as an almost blissful time. The father became more content, playful, and a stronger sense of a father in comparison to himself while drunk. As the author and his siblings grow older, the parents decide to move away to start a new, sober life.…

    • 1509 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the short story, “The Father,” by Hugh Garner, the main character, John Purcell had always been unhappy with his life and family. John and his son have never been that close, but a dramatic event could change their relationship for the worse. The father is neglectful, selfish and addicted which lead his relationship with Johnny to its eventual demise. John's broken relationship with Johnny is because of his consequential actions. To begin, John is too preoccupied with other things to pay attention to his son’s activities.…

    • 349 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Allen Woodman’s short story Wallet, the father of the protagonist is portrayed as a mischievous character, as demonstrated by the narrator’s description of his actions. The narrator describes the degree to which the father exaggerates his actions as “an old man trying to act feeble and childlike” comparing it to “stage makeup on a community theatre actor”, noting that “he has even brought a walking stick for special effect” (Woodman 129). The narrator’s use of simile that incorporates theatre when describing the father’s attempt to act feeble suggest that the father views the act of luring in the thief as some type of theatrical performance. Additionally, the father’s decision to bring a “walking stick for special effect” further illustrates…

    • 138 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The circumstances of the father not being able to work forces him to rely on the older son to provide for the family. The father feels helpless that his family is “reduced to eating lobster” and “putting cardboard over the windows.” He whispers his request to his son, “I can’t go tonight,” as he feels ashamed to ask for his son’s help. However, the son dutifully supports the family. The father copes with his head injury and war trauma through alcohol and the support of his older…

    • 1520 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    1. Much of “Brownies” is very funny. What role does humor have in the story—and how does it relate to the decidedly unhumorous ending? The story is very humorous.…

    • 212 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    ESSAY 1 ELEANOR LOUISE WILSON Mrs Kristan ENGLISH 101 09/29/15 In “Knock Knock” by Daniel Beaty the purpose of the poem is is to highlight the importance of a fatherly figure during a son’s childhood. This significance is portrayed throughout the text by the authors use of repetition of symbolic phrases “knock knock”, as well as the narrative of the story being portrayed through the eyes of a child giving us a clearer indication of how it must feel to grow up without a father. The author uses a letter half way through the text which further influences how crucial a fatherly role is in a son’s life specifically, as well as highlighting this through portraying the failed lessons the child in the narrative has missed out on.…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The father-son relationship has flourished from the ancient times of cave fathers who taught their sons how to hunt, to the modern day dads who teach their sons how to play golf. A good father is one who can teach his son how to grow into a mature young man. Some fathers do this in unconditional ways; however, if the father is able to teach his son how to be a man, he has done his job. One writer who dives deep into this father son relationship is Scott Russell Sanders.…

    • 1426 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The young boy is critical of his Father. “The whiskey on your breath could make a small boy dizzy” (Roethke 1-2). The young boy does not like the smell of his Father when he comes home from work. The young boy also does not like the roughness of his Father. Roethke writes, “I hung on like death” (Roethke 3).…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays