Lemon Grove Incident Analysis

Improved Essays
The racial segregation of Latinos in the public school system is discussed in the film, Lemon Grove Incident, where it examines the 1930’s trial of Roberto Alvarez vs. the Board of Trustees of the Lemon Grove School District that ended school segregation of Mexican children in the district of Lemon Grove, California. The trial is known for it’s success to stop the segregation of Mexican children in the public school system. Although, the case allowed for Mexican integration, it only applied to the small district of Lemon Grove, causing little impact on the rest of the state. Furthermore, Mexican children continued to face segregation in public schools until Brown v. Board of Education in 1954, that called for the desegregation of all schools …show more content…
The author Charles Ramirez-Berg in the book Latino Images, he discuses the negative images that are stereotyped against Latinos. Berg argues that the image of a bandido is often perceived as a lazy, violent, criminal, Mexican person (Berg 2002). He further argues that the image of a Mexican bandido has remained in American media through different shapes and forms; the contemporary bandido is now a criminal portrayed through drug dealers or gangsters (Berg 2002). Berg argues that the reason behind this negative stereotyping of Latinos is the underrepresentation of Latinos in the media. Furthermore, the concept of negative stereotyping is seen in the Lemon Grove Incident, when the school board member of Lemon Grove argue that the Mexican school is needed because of the lack of hygiene Mexican children have. One of the argument of the school board was that overcrowding was causing a decline in the cleanliness of the school restrooms, and are quickly to blame the Mexican children. In connection to Berg’s argument of Mexicans seen as bandidos the Lemon Grove board members in fact believed that Mexican children were inferior to white children due to unrealistic hygienic …show more content…
Elena Gutierrez discusses the impact that negative stereotyping has on innocent immigrants that are targeted by a nativist approach to policy making. Furthermore, Charles Berg discuses the concept of negative media stereotyping of Latinos, which as seen through the Lemon Grove case, causes wrongful perceptions of Latinos that results in exclusion from society. As seen in the Lemon Grove case, the Mexican children were seen as “incompetent” unfit for an all white school, furthermore, the Mexican children were seen as a burden and inferior to the white children. The Lemon Grove Incident serves as a constant reminder that Latinos oppression continues to be a problem in contemporary politics, but as scholarly work shows, Latinos continue to fight against these accusations and reach the equality they

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In this essay, “Still Separate, Still Unequal: America’s Educational Apartheid” Jonathan Kozol believes that America's urban and inner-city schools are having another occurrence of segregation. Jonathan Kozol gives great and unbelievable statistics that supports desegregation in schools. Evidence in the essay, blacks and Hispanics are predominantly enrolling in most of the public schools in major cities. According to Jonathan Kozol, white children living in public school districts that enroll in blacks and Hispanics as majority will transfer to private schools where the majority is white students.…

    • 284 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Supreme Court Case Study

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Brown V. Board of Education proved inequality by Linda’s dismissal to a “white” school asserting that segregation in and of itself denied equal opportunity and protection. The court agreed after several months that schools could no longer dismiss blacks and white from sharing a facility in equal parts, making all segregation within the school illegal. This case holds a place in society because it allowed…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Federal Court ruled regarding the state law that segregation of children of Mexican descent in separate schools is not authorized by California statutes. Education Code, Section 8003, 8004, 16004, 16005, 16601. The acts of the California school district officials were performed under “color of state law.” The role of social and political influences on the Federal Court decision came from Thurgood Marshall, who wrote the NAACP’s friend of the court brief for the case.…

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Brown family took their cases to the supreme court, they argue that segregated schools could never be equal. The court decided that segregated schools were unconstitutional and violated the 14th…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The United States is a unique country, Americans have many rights and freedoms, protection from the American government, but most of all America’s independence. While this may seem like paradise for many people living in poverty in third world countries. This idea has been blown out of proportions, leading to many false assumptions. Commercialization of the American Dream leads to many false ideas and assumptions, and to a heavy flow of illegal immigrants. These assumptions are shown throughout Sonia Nazario’s book…

    • 1907 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Mexican-American life in Los Angeles as described by Luis Rodriguez presented a harsh reality that frequently found conflict and contradiction in its narrative. When a teacher would tell young Rodriguez that he was full of intellectual potential, a sheriff would soon remind him that he was simply a vehicle for absent-minded violence. Each stereotype and identity suggested to him wound up as a shoe that did not fit. Rodriguez’ journey through gang culture, Mexican-American life, and a challenging American reality was inherently driven by the conflicting aspects of selfhood. Transitions between neighborhoods, gangs, schools, and individuals in his life created a constantly moving space in which Rodriguez struggled to find himself amidst a variety of stereotypes and expectations.…

    • 1450 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many Americans ascribe to the belief that America represents a “melting pot” of cultures. With so many differing cultures in this country, America would be expected to have a high bilingual population and large support for bilinguals’ rights. However, America is only about 20% bilingual (source). This low bilingual percentage accounts for Americans’ general lack of empathy for bilingual people and their rights. Two bilingual authors, Martin Espada and Richard Rodriguez, portray contrasting perspectives about the issue of bilingualism in America by addressing the meaning of bilingualism, bilingual education, and discrimination against bilinguals.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I was appalled to read how stupid and how racist these legislations were at attacking Mexican students. The bottom line was that most legislators attempted to segregate Mexican students on the ground the most of them were non-white. This section of the chapter offered an interesting view of how Mexicans students were segregated in public schools. This racial segregation of schools would not be dealt with until Brown v. Board of Education would go to the Supreme…

    • 433 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The ‘equality’ looked good on paper but reality was rarely the case, especially when it came to schools. Substandard buildings, supplies, and transportation often made the educational experience for African Americans inferior to whites. It wasn’t until 1954 with the ruling of Brown v. Board of Education that segregation in schools was made unconstitutional (Document 2), based on the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment. In order to become integrated, some schools were forced to resort to bussing their students in from other areas (Document 3a) – although the ruling took care of ‘de jure’ integration of society (that which is imposed by the federal court system), it did little to immediately reverse the ‘de facto’ segregation of society, especially in the South (‘de facto’ implies that which has become the unwritten law of social classes and segregated residential areas themselves). Long-term effects of the decision were more dramatic, however.…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Linda Brown and Brown v. Board of Education The Civil Rights Movement was an event in American History that played a huge role in shifting the way America is today. The Civil Rights Movement was the biggest step in breaking racial inequality and eliminating segregation between whites and blacks, and bringing the people of America closer together as a society. Numerous people helped push for racial equality, and several of them had gone down into history due to how significant their actions were. The most well known examples of these people are Martin Luther King Jr., Ruby Bridges, and Rosa Parks.…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    George Washington, one of America’s founding fathers once said, "A free people ought not only be armed and disciplined, but they should have sufficient arms and ammunition to maintain a status of independence from any who might attempt to abuse them, which would include their own government. " What is the definition of free? Free is to be not under the control or in power of another; able to act as one wish. Being free is to not physically be restrained, obstructed, or fixed. The United States to other countries is seen and held to a high standard because of how much “freedom” it seems to have.…

    • 1742 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stereotypes Of Immigrants

    • 227 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Stereotypes are unreliable generalizations about all members of a group and do not take individual differences into account. The willingness of people to assign positive and negative traits to entire groups of people, which are then applied to particular individuals. Over the last 80 years, social scientists have found that people have become less willing to express such views openly, but prejudice persists (Schaefer 2015). When it comes to stereotypes of immigrants, whether they are Africans or Latinos, the entertainment industries have doled out millions of models of how immigrants are expected to act depending on their culture and heritage. The implication of stereotypes relating to Africans or Latinos have a strong impact on immigration…

    • 227 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hispanic Stereotyping Many Hispanics come to America seeking a good life, amazing education, and the “American dream”. Many of these Hispanics are discriminated or assumed they are illegal immigrants that need to be deported. Many Latinos are seen as gang bangers, lazy, criminals, and Drug addicts. But they are so much more than that, and without them the U.S wouldn’t be as successful as it is today. Many people today discriminate Hispanics because of a lot of efforts to remove illegal immigrants.…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Alan Bialostozky Comm 100C Professor McMurria Spring 2015 Take home exam #3 Leo Chavez article “The Latino Treat Narrative” proposes a well-supported narrative to the nation’s anti-immigration discourse displayed by the media mostly in the USA. In this article, Chavez gives a critical overview and discussion about the images, stereotypes and falsified truths reproduced in society using and crafting recycled myths created by media experts, corrupt politicians, and people who openly hate immigrants from a Latino background. Chavez closely examines how “citizenship” has been seen and discussed through the legal organizations as a form of unity in the country through social and political participation. He claims that just critiquing discourse…

    • 3459 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Lemon Grove incident which occurred from 1930-1931 in California started out with a small groups of the school’s local board committee attempting to build a separate school for the Mexican children. In the video, I could see certain board members arguing and some were disagreeing with the policy, but because Claire the secretary of the Lemon Grove’s Parent Teacher Association was trying really hard to get away with the situation and forcing the committee members to agree with her. I think this an important even in history because many of the Mexicans in the Lemon Grove district has been living in the Unites States for more than 20 years and were facing discrimination happening to their children. The Mexican community responded to the discrimination…

    • 406 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays