Legalization Of The Death Penalty Analysis

Improved Essays
Legalization of the Death Penalty
The death penalty is only legal in some states, and there is much debate over whether or not sentencing criminals to death makes our communities safer. For those against the death penalty, it is understood that executing murderers does not stop other murderers, or make killings more likely. However, on the other side of the argument, those for the death penalty believe that the more severe the penalty, the more criminals will be deterred from committing the crime. In the article, ‘When Murder is Punished with Death, Fewer Criminals Will Murder,’author Jeff Jacoby argues that the death penalty is a good idea because the harsh punishment will make criminals stop and think before committing murder. Jacoby formulates
…show more content…
He begins with the premise stating, “All penalties have some deterrent effect, and the more severe the penalty, the more it deters,” (Boston Globe, 2016). The author uses examples to back up his strong premises. He relates his claim that if the penalty is more severe, the more the penalty deters crime, by giving a common example of a small crime. He makes the audience think by asking which violation they are less likely to commit, “Let a parking meter expire, and you risk a $20 ticket; park in a handicapped spot and risk a $200 ticket,” (Boston Globe, 2016). He uses this example to get his audience on the same page that if the fine is a higher price, you are less likely to take the risk of breaking that law. Once his audience agrees, he can go on to argue a much more serious matter of life and death. He makes a second premise that “a penalty cannot deter if it is never imposed,” (Boston Globe, 2016). Jacoby validates this argument by explaining how even though California legalized capital punishment, the law is rarely enforced and therefore not useful. He explains that “Only 13 killers have been put to death since 1972,” (Boston Globe, 2016), to show how rarely the law is used. This argument ties in with his previous argument that more severe penalties have more deterrent effects. All of his premises are backed up with factual evidence and examples to which the audience can easily …show more content…
He leads up to this premise that the more severe the penalty, the more deterrent the effects by first stating the claims of the opposition. He begins by noting how in support of Proposition 62, the California ballot initiative to repeal the death penalty, former El Dorado county supervisor Ron Briggs made the “tiresomely familiar claim” (Boston Globe, 2016), stating his position that the death penalty is not safer for the communities and does not deter crime in any way. He also states how the death penalty opponents believe that using death as a punishment does not make killings more likely, then quickly refutes their claim by adding “never mind a thick sheaf of peer reviewed academic studies refutes the abolitionists’ beliefs, as, of course, does common sense,” (Boston Globe, 2016). He recognizes his opponent’s side, however he follows their claim with logic that proves the argument of the other side to be invalid. After noting the other sides’ claim that the death penalty doesn’t deter killings, he refutes this argument once again by getting the audience into the same mindset. He claims that it is invalid to say that the death penalty does not make California communities safer if the death penalty has rarely been in use in California and “endless legal appeals and procedures have made executions, for all intents and purposes, impossible,” (Boston

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    This article, written for Time Magazine, gave people a better idea of what was going on with the death penalty and understand why the era of capital punishment is coming to an end. The organization of “The Death of the Death Penalty” was confusing and sometimes I didn’t quite understand what was being talked about. The essay’s argument, however, is constructed logically by giving the reader facts and statistics. Von Drehle argues that the capital punishment system has failed and causes our government to spend millions of dollars on…

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Specifically, a family whose eight-year-old son was killed in the Boston Marathon bombing feels it “prolongs their suffering”. A third reason that aims to persuade people on is death penalties cannot be reversed if a person is eventually proven innocent. Over an almost 40 year period, “more than 140 people sentenced to death have been acquitted of their crimes (sometimes by DNA evidence), had the charges against them dismissed by prosecutors or have been pardoned based on evidence of innocence”. The ability to be one hundred percent certain of someone else’s actions is nearly impossible; therefore the death penalty should not be used. Another reason Mr. Will mentions in the article is the ideological conflict between conservatives and the death penalty.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Death Penalty Texas

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Not all the cases with death sentences is right, “I don't want to put one innocent person to death to put 99 that are guilty to death,” said Gary Johnson (Johnson 1). In addition, the cost of it is also excessively expensive; therefore, this solution is not as good as its definition. The death penalty has its impacts to the criminal behavior of people as the result of reducing crime rates since it was re-instituted. One can say keep it but only for a symbol. Life is precious, and no one has the right to end other’s…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    America is in the midst of a massive debate in regards to the constitutionality of the application of the death penalty, and while the importance of the Constitution cannot be understated in regards to this discussion, other factors, such as social science evidence and the many different ways in which the Constitution can be interpreted, are equally important. One of the principal arguments in favor of the use of the death penalty is that it acts as a powerful deterrent against capital crimes such as murder. However, empirically speaking, any causal relationship is highly dubious at best. The consensus in the social science community seems to be that there are far to many confounding variables to make any sort of meaningful determination in regards to the efficacy of the death penalty as a deterrent.…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book Capital Punishment by Michael Kronenwetter . He talks about how capital punishment was favorable for our country. He explained the power of the death sentence and how it helped the government and the people of the United States. He explained how the capital punishment was a deterrent for people. That anyone who would think about committing a murder would think before because they would be afraid of the consequence.…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Adrianne Haslet-Davis writes such a vivid recognition of enforcing the death penalty by the use of deterrence. She focuses on an individual story, hers being coming close to death. She goes on and on about if any individuals was murdered the life of the murderer should be also. The community tends to always use punishments to put down criminals from their cruel and heinous actions. However, with our crime rates so high, it's plain up simple that the smartest punishment for any murderer should be execution.…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Capital Punishment The History of Capital Punishment in Canada British law was predominant in Canada until 1859, in which around 230 infractions, including the stealing of turnips, were punishable by death. Later in 1865, the law changed and only murder, treason and rape were considered capital offences. The first attempt to abolish this unusual punishment was taken in 1914 by parliamentarian Robert Bickerdike, stating strongly in the house "There is nothing, more degrading to society at large . . . than the death penalty. " Sadly his attempts were not enough to abolish capital punishment.…

    • 1370 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “A Strong Argument Against Capital Punishment”, Lincoln Caplan expands upon Connecticut's recent choices about capital punishment. Connecticut is one of several states in the United States that brought the issue of capital punishment to the Supreme Court for debate and discussion. The Supreme Court ultimately ruled that the death penalty is unconstitutional in the state of Connecticut. In this debate, the Democratic legislative side leaned against capital punishment; while the Republican legislative side leaned towards capital punishment. The Democratic side reasons that the death penalty violates the state constitution against excessive punishments.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Detrimental Effects of the Death Penalty in America After several decades of debate, the death penalty continues to rise as a contentious issue in the United States of America. The morality and inefficient process of execution has come into question, with many opposing a punishment that half the world no longer uses. A slow and tedious process that welcomes botched executions, the legality of the death penalty has raised reasonable concern. Although the Supreme Court ruled the death penalty as constitutional, capital punishment still has various disadvantages that many Americans are unaware of.…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In other words, the severity of the death penalty will make criminals want to avoid it. However, the statistics tell a different story. According to the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the rates of murder, one of the most common violent crimes in the U.S., are higher in states using capital punishment than the ones that aren’t (Deterrence). While the general trend of murder rates has been a downwards one, there’s still a significant percentage difference in the statistics (peak difference was 46% in 2005). This evidence shows that the idea that capital punishment is a deterrent is false.…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Article Summary #1: Author William Tucker uses his 2000 American Spectator article to explain why the death penalty is actually a deterrent to criminals. Tucker analyzes the statistics of crime over the years and concludes that when death penalty rates are up, murder rates are down, and when execution rates decrease, the rate of homicides rises (par. 13). While many criminologists believe that the death penalty doesn’t affect the amount of murders that take place in America, Tucker counters by saying, “The results are plain to see. Beginning at almost the exact point when executions ended, murder soared to unprecedented heights.…

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Death Penalty: Inhumane or Necessary Deterrent?” written by Euan McKirdy, several concepts surrounding the death penalty are discussed. McKirdy is a Digital News Producer who joined CNN in early 2014 and covers everything from politics, tech and the environment to sport and the arts. Before McKirdy started writing for CNN he wrote for a different publications and websites including Time, the BBC, the Wall Street Journal and Monocle. Throughout the article, McKirdy displays information for both sides of the controversial argument. He writes: Advocates say it is a powerful deterrent against serious crime, while others point to the problems -- and cost -- of keeping violent offenders in general prison populations.…

    • 889 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Payal Patel Mrs. Burt English H - Per. 8 25 November 2014 Persuasion Techniques Come into Play A writer often incorporates persuasion techniques into his writing in order to convince the reader to agree with the argument, share commonly accepted values, or adapt a new way of thinking. Afterwards, the writer is able to persuade the reader into anything because the reader is under the writer’s control. Persuasion techniques come in handy when a writer wants to spread his opinions and values to other people through personal experiences or factual evidence.…

    • 1053 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The first argument is “The Deterrence Effect,” which is based on the idea that the use of capital punishment is an operational method to reduce the rate of serious crimes. There are four justifications for the depravation of liberty; incapacitation, rehabilitation, retribution and last but not least, deterrence. There can be two forms of deterrence,…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Justified Murder Essay

    • 1941 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Justifiable Murder n after by sentencing over 72,000 to death in his reign. ()By the 1700’s English established that over 200 different crimes that would seem nearly insignificant today were punishable by death. For example, execution was a reasonable punishment for cutting down a neighbor 's tree. ( ) In the days of monarchy few doubted the morality of executions. Most believed that king had the divine right to do so from God himself.…

    • 1941 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays