Pros And Cons Of Legalizing Organ Sales

Great Essays
In the United States, there has been an increase in the number of organ transplants

needed over the years, even though there are not enough donated organs to fill that need. This

issue has sparked many ideas in the creation of a remedy to the current organ donation shortage.

One of the proposed solutions would be to legalize the sale of human organs, which has many

issues woven within it. Through history of organ donations, many people have been saved.

However, the proposition brings with it problems and concerns. Modern science has produced

other means of reducing the shortage without endangering the health and welfare of it’s citizens.

The legalization of organ sales in the United States would pose threats to the country’s
…show more content…
If the United States was to adopt the presumed consent law,

it could drastically reduce the need for organs, without subjecting it’s citizens to the difficulties

associated with the legalization of organ sales.

There are many risks that come along with the legalization of human organ sales in the

United States. Legalization of organ sales can lead to unethical people taking advantage of the

poor. It can be questioned whether selling an organ is a truly self-aware and informed choice.

Immoral uses for the organ market would include people using it as a form of collateral for debt,

selling an organ just to buy an expensive item that they had been wanting, or to make easy

money. The poor could be thought of as “extra body parts”, which is morally and ethically

abhorrent. In the always ongoing battle between morality and immorality in the world, it

becomes more and more evident that this battle affects the people in very intimate ways. This

battle is raging in the U.S. in many ways, such as the thought of legalizing of organ sales. The

lust for money has come to outweigh the well being of humans and their
…show more content…
Just because someone is on the waiting list, does not mean that they

would have the money to buy an organ. The legalization of human organ sales would create an

upper-class dominated organ trade, which would not benefit the poor at all. Legalization of

organ sales in the United States would pose threats to the country’s morality in a sense that the

poor could be mislead to use the organ market as a short term solution to long term monetary

problems.

Just as it is impossible to totally rule out immorality in an entire country, it would be

impossible for the government to have entire control over a domestic market for organs. There is

a trade market that operates all around the world, called the black market, which sells, trades, and

deals in illegal means. They will sell anything. The black market has been known to sell

everything from endangered wildlife to cigarettes, faux designer items to sex slaves, and stolen

historic artifacts to human organs. There is a neverending flow of illegal trade in that industry. If

the legalization does anything to impact the black market sale it may be for their benefit. It

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    If there was a statistic that backed up organ legalization as far as how many lives would be saved per year, would it be immoral for a person to be in approval of legalization? Miriam Schulman, the director of Markkula for Applied Ethics at Santa Clara University, who wrote Kidneys for Sale: A Reconsideration, believes it goes far beyond saving lives. Anthony Gregory, a research fellow and student programs director at the Independent Institute, and the author of Why Legalizing Organ Sales Would Help Save Lives, End Violence, has similar beliefs as Schulman. Both authors explain how legalizing does not only benefit the rich, but can also benefit the poor as well in other ways; what the need is to what is actually available, such as how many kidneys are available to how many are actually donated; and explains what the people who…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Organ Sales Will Save Lives”, Joanna MacKay argues that the sale of humans organs, such as kidneys, should be legalized. She claims, “There are thousands of people dying to buy a kidney and thousands of people dying to sell a kidney.” She provides critical background information on the problem before delving into her main ideas. MacKay claims that donors need and deserve the money, and that buyers are unable to access the necessary organs any other way. Unfortunately, people living in poverty in third world countries would thrive if given the money buyers are willing to provide in exchange for a vital organ.…

    • 268 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author of freakonomics, Steven Levitt, wrote the article Flesh Trade in an effort to bring awareness to the idea in monetizing our organs. He is able to effectively communicate his controversial viewpoint with credible evidence and easy to read language. Therefore, common people are able to understand his argument and form their own opinion on the matter. The purpose of discussing such a repugnant topic is made clear by the author’s mention of the people who die waiting for an organ transplant.…

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Those studies may not apply to those desperate people in the third world countries that live in the unsanitary environments, but most still take the risk. This is the best hope for these families to get money. Some people think that selling an organ is morally wrong. The desperate people in the third world countries would disagree.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    You would think that compensating people for their organs would help the shortage and encourage capitalism. After all, United States is built on the free enterprise idea. Create and regulate a free market “in all aspects of organ and tissue procurement.” The free market will be able to match goods and services with those who need them. The free market would also be able to compensate the donors at fair market value and also keep their liberties intact.…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Molly O’Brien Expository Writing Assignment #2 The Debate of Organ sales In MIT student Joanna Mackay’s article “Organ Sales Will Save Lives” she focuses on why organ sales should be made legal. She researches information about how people are dying due to minimum organs, third world donors, moral issues and the advantage to government regulation to argue her point that organ sales should be available if one desires. Joanna's presents how people are dying and suffering from the lack of organ sales.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Every 14 minutes someone is added to the kidney transplant list”, the National Kidney Foundation is not playing around. Statistically speaking that is a lot of people in need of a vital organ. The author Joanna Macay talks about the need for organ donations in her Article “Organ Sales will Save Lives”. Macay disputes her case briefly when stating her thesis in the first paragraph. She goes on to give her opinion that the selling of organs should be built to become legal.…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While internationally the number sat right around 50,000 people. With the sale of organs being illegal internationally, that is what makes the demand so high. In the essay, an example was given about the demand. “When ‘desperately wanted goods’ are made illegal, history has shown that there is more opportunity for corruption…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Paper 4 "Organ Sales Will Save Lives" by Joanna MacKay explains the problem that thousands of people are complaining about. This problem is that thousands of people are begging to buy a kidney, but the government doesn't allow people to sell human organs. This outcome causes thousands of people to die each year, creating chaos around the world. Mackay and the other author’s want to convey their message to the government on why this catastrophic problem should be fixed. Since this essay is written on the subject of organ sales and Mackay’s essay was written back in 2004 some information may be dated, however not much has changed to fix this issue.…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The black market has valued human organs at five thousand dollars each, so they report. They suggest sales of organ may be for itself. Some people who disobey the laws are increasing to a large scale number. On the other hand, there are those who believe that it might be better to legalize the sale of…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “There are thousands of people dying to buy a kidney and thousands of people dying to sell a kidney.” [Mackay] Mackay instantly grabs on to the readers heart strings with the beginning of her essay. MacKay’s introduction is full of emotionally- charged words and pain. “In third world countries, there are people willing to do anything for money.” [Mackay] “Eager to pay off debts, they line up at hospitals, willing to sell a kidney for about $1,000.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Organ Sales Will Save Lives In the essay “Organ Sales Will Save Lives” by Joanna Mackay, kidney failure is the main topic. In the thesis Mackay says “Government should not ban the sale of the human organs, they should regulate it.” It is supported by the evidence it will save lives. 350,000 people in America struggle with this situation each year.…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If every eligible deceased patient was a registered organ donor, they would have the possibility of saving the lives of every person on the organ transplant wait list: giving over one hundred and twenty-two thousand people a second chance at life. The American government should take extra measures to educate its citizens about the monumentally life saving possibilities of organ…

    • 1093 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sam Vaknin portrays a grim picture of the current black market trade in human body parts. Those who sell their organs are usually individuals in developing nations in extreme poverty who make very little from the sale, while those who transport the organs usually make a fortune reselling the organs to recipients in rich, developed countries. Part of the organ trade involves the abduction of individuals, including children, and the theft of their organs. Vaknin applauds the willingness of the American Medical Association to investigate "the effects [that] paying for cadaveric organs would have on the current shortage" of organs. He concludes that the current international ban on organ sales has produced the black market trade, and it would be "better to legalize and regulate the trade than transform it into a form of organized crime.…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Selling Organs Essay

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages

    At already existed black market, you can purchase just about anything that a man have: kidneys, lungs, liver, eyeballs, bones, tendons, heart valves, skin and many more. However, it would encourage more violent crimes, criminals would hunt for organs and get rid of the rest of the body. [The damning evidence they uncovered suggests that tens of thousands of innocent people have been killed on demand to supply an ongoing illegal organ transplant industry.(5)] ,the most recent exposed China’s human trafficing. Often accomplices mafia group transplant draw up documents for the adoption of children abducted entire families, arrange travel or credit fraud, threatened by the court and paid, if the random victim does not give a "duty", and then offer to help in conflict resolution: a kidney as an exchange fee, newborn twins in exchange for life. For example, in Moldova entire villages mysteriously disappeared, supposedly “gone on…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics