Legal Law Case Study

Superior Essays
1. Agreement
Offer
An offer must include an intention to be bound combined with final and certain language that requires no further communication other than acceptance. This is distinguishable from an invitation to treat, which is an invitation to others to make an offer. This distinction is based on the facts of the case. Kelvin’s quotation is the offer, because it included all the necessary details such as price and delivery date, which makes it necessary only for Brie to communicate her acceptance of the quote. While Kelvin could argue that a quotation does not signify an intention to be bound, the law states that the intention is discerned from whether a reasonable person would believe it was an offer. A reasonable person would have found
…show more content…
As Kelvin accepted Brie’s offer he performed both acceptance and consideration. Although Kelvin’s performance gains Usain little other than Brie’s happiness, and pride for his good deed, the courts look only at the sufficiency not adequacy of consideration such that even nominal consideration is accepted. As the acceptance of the offer was the consideration Usain asked for, Kelvin’s performance was sufficient consideration.
Existing Legal Duty
Kelvin can enforce consideration despite the fact that he has an existing legal duty under his contract with Brie. This is because a third party may contract a person otherwise under an existing legal duty to do the act so required. Usain is not an agent of Brie as he was given no authority to act on her behalf and was not purporting to, and is therefore a third party.

3. Certainty
The contract is sufficiently certain as the essential terms including price are given. No party has discretion as to performance, and it is sufficiently clear for the courts to enforce.

4. Intention to Create Legal Relations
There is a presumption for enforceability in commercial contexts, depending on whether a reasonable person would agree that the agreement is binding. As Kelvin asked for Usain’s firm promise to give the $1000 upon acceptance of Brie’s contract, a reasonable person would find an intention to create a legal
…show more content…
Certainty
The contract is not sufficiently complete because the amount of the bonus is indeterminate and ‘price’ is generally an essential element which would be necessary for an employment contract. The courts would be unable to award this amount at their own determination as there is no external standard for evaluation of ‘the amount they value’ her work, making it uncertain as the courts can’t attribute meaning to it. Additionally, Mistral has made an illusory promise by saying ‘if your work is good” as performance of the bonus is fulfilled at the discretion of the company.
Severance
As courts wish to maintain contracts, the uncertain clause of a contract should be severed if it isn’t essential, based on the intention of the parties and the document as a whole as to the validity without the clause. The bonus clause is severable from the contract because it was additional to the payment of the $3000 agreed upon for her work. Therefore only the bonus clause should be void as it is not essential.

4. Intention to Create Legal Relations
Following the rule set out above, a reasonable person would have found an intention to create legal relations in this commercial

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Parol Evidence Rule

    • 1413 Words
    • 6 Pages

    425, 433 (1999). Stated differently, parol evidence cannot be used to add or alter the terms of a completely integrated contract, but it can be used to define ambiguous terms. Likewise, “[i]t is well settled that the parol evidence rule does not prevent the introduction of parol evidence indicating that the written instrument was not to become effective as an instrument, until a prior condition or event had occurred.” Foreman, supra, 257 Md. at 442. “Parol evidence is admissible, therefore, to show that a writing never became effective as a contract or that it was void or voidable.” Tricat Indus., Inc. v. Harper, 131 Md.…

    • 1413 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Offer may defined as a final statement or proposal by the offeror to the offeree. Statement or proposal is generally based on certain terms and follows a process of negotiation between the parties; an offer only could stand when the terms are finalized between offeror and offeree and the offer could only be legally bound when both parties accepted (Monahan 2001, 5). Consideration is one of the essential element of contract formation. It based of barter system with the same principle of “something for something”. For the promise will be legally enforceable, it requires a price be paid for a promise (Khoury and Yamouni…

    • 1124 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Hyder V Wrench Case Study

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Consideration need to require the contract whether binding. Both of these parties need to reach an agreement under the law binding. If the parties are not accept the offer in the agreement, however the offeror can quit the contract with no any problem. (Williams v Raffrey Brothers). (iv)Intentions: Intention to create legal relations (I.T.C.L.R) is defined as a purpose to enter a lawfully authoritative understanding or contract.…

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Because terms are the obligation one party made with the lawful effects. The Carbolic smoke ball company had refuted that it did not make any specific promises in that advertisement as the wordings are just “mere puff”, which means nothing. However, that plea is a fallacy. The advertisement said that 1000 pounds deposit is lodged at a certain bank for the purpose which he has specified. The wordings showed the intention to promise clearly and were sufficient to make an offer (Paul,…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lastly, it lacks guidelines as there is no criteria that judges need to follow apart from the fact it avoids an absurd result. What the law commission report had to say about the golden rule is that it sets a ‘purely negative standard, by reference to absurdity, inconsistency, or inconvenience, but provides no clear means to test the existence of these characteristics or to measure their quality or extent’. This means we are looking at the failing of parliament where they would have got the wording…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The intention to create legal relations is the last factor be determined. This is present in this case as they both entered a contract which does not state that there any legal bounds to it or it being a domestic agreement. Nature of advertisement The advertisement was not an agreement offer to world at large but restricted to those who acted upon the terms contained in the advertisement. Julie accepted and acted according to Leila’s advertisement. In Calill v Carbolic Smoke Ball(1893) constituted good consideration, because it was a distinct detriment incurred at the behest of the company and, furthermore, more people buying smoke balls by relying on the advertisement was a clear benefit to Carbolic.…

    • 1518 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Force Majeure Clause a. This clause excuses the party from performing any contractual obligations as an unforeseeable event has happened. 2. Discharge by Frustration a. Neither party was responsible for the destruction of place and…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Intention to create legal relations To form a contract two parties must give mutual consent that the agreement is legally enforceable. There is a strong presumption that commercial agreement are intended to have legal consequences. The presumption cannot be rebutted as there is no express or implied repudiation of the…

    • 1500 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Similarly, the facts and evidence surrounding this case, when viewed in the best possible light to Ms. Cohen’s, do not give rise to an implied contract for continued employment. STATEMENT MADE TO MS. COHEN BY JEFREY HOLMGREN WERE MERELY A GENERAL EXPRESSION OF ANTICIPATED LONG-TERM EMPLOYMENT RATHER THAN LANGUAGE THAT GAVE RISE TO MODIFICATION OF THE AT-WILL EMPLOYMENT RELATIONSHIP Nevada law is clear…

    • 1500 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In some cases, the exclusion clause will not be treated valud, if the seller is misrepresenting the scope of the clause. Words of contract must be clear and unambigious, it must not create any doubt in customer/buyer mind. An example of an unsigned exclusion clause would be the clearly written sign right behind the phone chargers point that “If any mobile phone are lost or damaged University will not be responsible for any damage or loss caused.” “It is settled that no clause is effective unless adequately brought to other party attention before the time the contract is made (R.Lawson, 2011).” Talking about James chung, who is 18 now which means is at the age of majority parks his car to Sydney CBD at private parking. When he returns the stereo sound system is missing from his car and the management of the Car Parking denies repsonsbility as they have already show sign warning about ‘parking at owners risk’ at the entrance…

    • 1329 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics