United States Immigration Policy Analysis

Superior Essays
The legacy of immigration and naturalization administration spans more than 100 years (Our history, 2011). Laws passed in the 1880’s implemented three elements to our immigration policies: “(a) restrictions based on personal characteristics, (b) restrictions based on national origin, (c) protection of American labor” (Laque, 2010, p. 5). When the federal government took over immigration in 1891 the Office of Superintendent of Immigration was part of the Treasury Department (Our history, 2011). Through the years the Office of Superintendent became the Bureau of Immigration under Department of Commerce and Labor in 1903, then Naturalization Service in 1906 (Our history, 2011). In subsequent years it bounced from agency to agency, ultimately being …show more content…
Four years before the Geary Act extended the Chinese Exclusion ACT; Congress passed the Scott Act banning Chinese immigrants from returning to the U.S. after they left (Rowen, 2000-2016). In 1943, fifty-one years later, the Chinese Exclusion Act was repealed allowing Chinese workers to immigrate to the U.S. but an annual quota of 105 was implemented (Rowen, 2000-2016). By 1892 the number of immigrants was so high that the government needed a way to handle the influx, thus designating Ellis Island as a federal immigration station in 1892 (U.S. immigration before 1965, 2009). Ellis Island served as the primary immigration station from 1892 to 1954, processing more than 12 million immigrants (Rowen, 2000-2016). Early explanations of immigration stressed the ideology that America in part provides “an asylum, wherein the blessings of liberty would await all men” (Totten, 2008, p. …show more content…
149). Dramatic changes in policy would be the national origins quota from 1882 to 1924 with the exclusion of all Asians and African immigrants and severe limitations on eastern Europeans. Immigrant communities themselves held mass meetings, distributed petitions, and sent delegates to Congressional hearings on immigration policy. The influx of immigrants provided a cheap supply of unskilled labor pitting immigrants against native-born or against like ethnic groups (Seller, 1982, p. 149). To curtail immigration from southern and eastern Europe, the U.S. implemented the literacy test that was to be rational and free of ethnic bias (Seller, 1982, p. 154). The failure of the literacy test to not reduce the number of undesirables, Congress imposed a quota system in 1921 limiting annual immigration from European nations to “3% of the number from that nation residing in the United States as of 1910” (Seller, 1982, p.

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The United States has always been a mixing pot, immigrants from all over the world have been coming with a common goal to better themselves and their families. Nonetheless, immigrants had never had it easy to succeed in a foreign society, the time period 1865 to 1898 was no the exemption. Irish, Russians, Greeks, Poles, Hungarians, Romanians, Chinese and Bohemians among many other were coming to the union to face prejudices from “true Americans”. Immigration caused a strain in society since the government would not help immigrant at any point under any circumstance, the gap between the rich and the poor grew as immigrants…

    • 1124 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigration in The United States during the progressive era resulted in an essential transformative period during American history. The United States was a beacon of hope for immigrants looking for prosperity and a fresh start. However, during the years 1880 through 1925, important transformations within the American economy occurred there were important such as the successful and lucrative industrialization and tensions arose regarding the government’s negative feelings and toward the large flow of immigrants and new cultures.…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Illegal Immigration Dbq

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The annual allowance of immigrants in the country was getting lower to 150,000 it was 2 percent of each nationality. Making it harder for immigrants to come and making people expand their cultural life to other places. This law was still something was done until 1965, making it hard for the immigrant to be allowed in the country and having a better life away from their country. After two years in 1929, the annual quotas of the 1924 act are made permanent. The cultural mixture was not huge because there were 70% that came from northern and Western Europe, while 30% came from Southern and Eastern Europe. This made mostly white people, the ones that migrated to the U.S. making the other races minimum. Most of the immigrants that were coming to the U.S. were from Europe. During this time America was going through the great depression and since the Immigration Act of 1924 excluded Asian Immigrants, they decide to use Mexicans and a form of cheap labor during the late 1920s. Mexicans had thousand of legal and illegal workers that did labor on farms, ranches, and mining. There were a great number of Mexicans working in the U.S. during the Great Depression. Consequently, the loss of jobs was high as a result of this anti-Mexican sentiment started to grow. Making Mexicans get hated by the rest of the society, which had grown following WWI. The government decided to send back the Mexicans because it would be less to…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The discrimination would include laws passed, like the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 and Immigration Act of 1921 and 1924. Over this period the American people showed just how much of the country was nativism during this time.…

    • 1059 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A total of 153,200 immigrants came from Asia, Vietnam having the smallest amount with only 300 people. From African countries, there was a total of 14,100 people (immigration p872). These numbers were based off the quota system and clearly shows a preference for Europeans and also an indication of which people were most restricted at the time. In the time period with two major conflicts, the Cold War and the Vietnam War, it was the people of those two nations that faced more hardships to enter the U.S. In the decade the act was passed, 1961-1970, there were 1,123,500 immigrants from Europe. Once again, the least number of people came from the Soviet Union with 2,500 immigrants. The amount of immigrants from Asian countries nearly tripled as 427,600 people arrived in America. Vietnamese immigrants, still yielding the smallest amount of immigrants, grew exponentially with a total of 4,300 immigrants. There was a total of 29,000 people from the African countries (immigration p872). The decade after this time period, 1971-1980, proves to be the most telling with the shift in immigration trends. During this decade, only 800,400 immigrants are from European countries and instead of the Soviet Union producing the least amount of immigrants, it is Norway with…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Remember, remember always, that all of us, and you and I especially, are descended from immigrants and revolutionists”,(Franklin D. Roosevelt). The United States was a country founded by immigrants and has since then grow as a beacon to those across the world seeking greater opportunities. The earliest immigration policies established what would constitute an American citizen, forming a national identity. The Alien Act was the first major law passed giving the executive power in dealing with potentially beligerant foreigners. The Immigration acts of 1864 created a Commissioner of Immigration under the Secretary of State. Several years later, the immigration act of 1882 was passed further expanding the federal government’s power in overseeing immigration. Following its implementation the federal government attempted to maintain a European-descent heritage with a series of laws excluding immigration from Asiatic countries. In 1921, gave a more definite regulation of immigrants based on quotas. Then, following World War Two, the United States began to stray out of an isolationist stance expanding policies admitting more migrant workers and more accepting of refugees. At that time, immigration policies were…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1920s America Immigration

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Before World War I, most any white persons who passed through the “golden door” and wanted to become citizens of our nation, could. Yet, in 1921, immigration from Europe was cut back to one-third of what it was before and cut even more so three years later with new national quotas to follow. In spite of that, California relied heavily on seasonal Mexican Labor so to satisfy this need, in 1924 the law established no limits on immigration from the Western Hemisphere (Foner, pg. 624). It also established the term “illegal alien” which in turn created the border patrol – policing the land boundaries of the United States and arresting deported persons who were in violation of the new quotas and restrictions. These immigration restrictions were placed due to the government wanting a “higher” quality of people, meaning white-natives essentially. This initially enhanced the emphasis on race as a determinant of of public…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Between 1800 and 1875, immigration laws were regulated and enforced at the state level. However, in 1875, Congress began to regulate some aspects of national immigration law. Despite the country’s origin as a nation allegedly built by immigrants for immigrants in order to foster economic opportunities for all people, the elected politicians were very selective about the nationalities of the immigrants who were accepted, and about their social standing. The earlier laws made it possible for immigration officials to refuse entry to the country to people of social classes that were deemed unfit, including lunatics, idiots, the insane, prostitutes, and paupers. Additionally, following the assassination of President McKinley in 1882, Congress made legal the discrimination against any non-citizens based on their race or their ideology. These early immigration laws were highly biased against huge numbers of people with physical and mental disabilities, people of diverse religions, social…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the 1920’s the pressure for extensive immigration restriction became tempting. Everyone feared immigrant radicalism, which outweighed the want for cheap labor. In 1921 a temporary law restricted immigrant from Europe to 357,000 per year. Congress officially limited Europeans immigrants to 150,000 per year three years after the first law was put into place. This law was put into place so the old immigrants would always outnumber the children of the new immigrants. In 1924 a law allowed an unlimited amount of immigration in the western hemisphere because California relied heavily on Mexican labor during certain seasons. The 1924 law implemented the entry of all those who were ineligible to claim citizenship. This law included the entire population of Asia even though we fought on the same side in World War…

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Between 1877-1900, the country’s population increased by about 27 million people. Before 1880, most of the immigrant population came from Western Europe and China. At the end of the century, most immigrants were emigrating from Southern and Eastern Europe - giving this era its name “New Immigration.” The sudden increase in immigration caused a lot of controversy in America. Immigrants were taking American jobs which resulted in wages cuts and reforms.Immigrants were willing to work for less pay than Americans wages. Americans believed taking away the immigrants right to vote kept them powerless as well as stuck in the lower class…

    • 1431 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Late nineteenth century marked a new era for America. Because of the country’s rapid economic growth and industrial revolution, millions of immigrants from all around the world made the long journey to the United States. The “land of opportunity” as they called it, offered them a greater chance to have a better life. However, the vast majority of the “new” Americans faced an uphill battle for survival. Low wages, awful living conditions and racial discrimination took a toll on many of the immigrants.…

    • 392 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    From the 1880s to the 1920s, there is an estimated 20 million immigrants that came into the United States. Due to the larger amounts of legal and illegal immigrants, the U.S. government created the Quota System in 1921 to help manage the inflow of immigrants coming into the country. After the Roaring Twenties, the great Depression era saw a massive decline in immigrant populations due to the massive decline in economic opportunity. This period defines the results of a weakened U.S. economy, which caused a steady decline in the post-Depression years up until the beginning of World War II in 1941. However, many anti-immigration laws remained intact due to the continued legacy of racism and “nativist” sentiment that sought to curtail the presence of illegal immigrant workers. More importantly, the U.S. border Control was set up to control the inflow of Mexican workers coming into American on the Mexican-American…

    • 1408 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By July 1919 and June 1920, “more than 430,00 people had arrived and almost double that number would arrive in the next twelve months” (Cannato pg. 331). The new law in 1921 made a suggestion to impose a quota on immigration. This then resulted in the Quota Act that set an annual “limit on immigration to 350,000 immigrants per year” (Cannato pg. 333). The law was mainly created to lower and prevent the numbers of immigrants coming from eastern and southern Europe. Then the quota set in 1921 was revised. In the National Origins Act, for immigration in 1924 went from 350,000 to 287,000 people. This quota was determined by “2% of each country’s foreign-born population based on the 1890 Census living in the United States” (Cannato pg. 341). Even though there was an existing quota, this did not apply to those individuals that were highly skilled immigrants, domestic servants, or specialized workers. Also in 1924, Congress created the U.S. Border Patrol within the Immigration Service. Immigration Service continued evolving as the United States experienced rising…

    • 1200 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    As one of the world 's leading countries, the United States is an attractive destination for immigrants from all over the world to settle. However, these immigrants who are seeking a better life in America, oftentimes have trouble assimilating within the culture. They face things like discrimination and fear of deportation, if they arrive in the United States illegally. The struggle between immigrants and Americans has gone back for centuries, as the two have tried for years to find compromises in living together in one country. The government made efforts after the Civil War and during World War I against immigrants. For example, Congress became stricter on state laws in regards to regulating immigration. This included things such as passing…

    • 2254 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    New Immigrants

    • 190 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Over decades, since the beginning of American history, there have always been immigrants coming to American shores. Recently, in New York City, a new immigration processing center has been opened in New York harbor, on Ellis Island. It is designed to accommodate the rush of immigrants since the 1890’s, mostly western immigrants from Europe, including Italian, Russian, German, and other European groups. Some nationalities, particularly…

    • 190 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays