Leadership Essays

2034 Words May 20th, 2012 9 Pages
CRAM Exclusive
Essay Sample
For every theory there is a counter argument. What are the criticisms and arguments against Transformational Leadership? Identify the sources and clearly articulate the reasoning behind the criticisms. Adopt a position for or against Transformational Leadership and defend your position with argument Introduction This essay is based on the Transformational leadership theory and will be referred to as TL throughout this essay. This essay will look into criticisms and arguments against the

middle of document…

Inspirational Motivation – Transformational leaders have a clear vision that they are able to articulate to followers. These leaders are also able to help followers experience the same passion and motivation to fulfil these goals.
Idealized Influence – The transformational leaders serves as a role model for followers. Because followers trust and respect the leader, they emulate the leader and internalize his or her ideals.
The four components deal with a close relationship between leaders and follower. The criticisms of the 4 components were that they were personalised, and demanded the capabilities of experienced senior managers. TL seemed to be out of reach for new or inexperienced leaders and thus was criticised as an elitist theory, relevant only to the selected few that may possibly be able to implement its strategy. Bass and Riggio (2006) “Critics perceive transformational leadership as elitist and anti democratic” (Pg11). This also brings into question on the limits of the application of TL as these so called elite will not be in the majority.
The biggest criticisms of all regarding TL comes from the “dark side” or the pseudotransformational aspect that is concerned with this theory. Bass and Riggio (2006) “pseudotransformational leaders believe in distorted utilitarian and warped moral principles” (pg14). TL does not discriminate and is applicable by both authentic and inauthentic leaders. This means an authentic leader such as Steve Jobs of Apple can
CRAM Exclusive
Grape85273Wizard

Related Documents

  • Leadership Essay

    The old leadership style mostly benefits the leader, the follower just being means to an end, whereas the new leadership empowers, includes and benefits everyone, recognizing each individual not as means to an end, but an end themselves, focusing more on the complex processes and development of the team and not just the product goal itself. The inner workings of the team also differ significantly when comparing the old and the new leadership style. There is interdependence among the team members

    Words: 1055 - Pages: 5
  • Leadership Essay

    As situations change, leadership relations change. Leadership cannot be transactional. It can only work if both parties keep their agreements. A class survey was held to compare leaders to managers. The overall opinion was that they are similar in many ways. A leader and a manager can be one in the same. The difference between a leader and a manager is that a manager directs and a leader motivates. Leaders make the rules. Managers enforce the rules. Leaders make the policies. Managers enforce the

    Words: 1207 - Pages: 5
  • Leadership Essay

    direction, or being macromanagers. Sometimes participative leadership is carried to extremes. Team members are consulted about trivial things that management could easily handle independently. Another problem is that many managers still believe that sharing decision making with members reduces their power. If democrat leadership goes one step further, the result is extreme macromanagement, which is referred to as the laissez-faire leadership style. A study conducted with 4,500 Norwegian employees found

    Words: 1214 - Pages: 5
  • Leadership Essay

    definition — Leadership is a process whereby an individual influences a group of individuals to achieve a common goal. Leaders carry out this process by applying their leadership knowledge and skills. This is called Process Leadership However, we know that we have traits that can influence our actions. This is called Trait Leadership in that it was once common to believe that leaders were born rather than made. These two leadership types are shown in the chart below While leadership is learned

    Words: 3434 - Pages: 14
  • Leadership Essay

    (Maxwell, 2003) Leadership and management are crucial for success. Leadership is a quality hidden in the personality of a human being. Human personality is very complex and it is very difficult to grade individuals according to one’s personality. Leadership, on the other hand, depends on the organic structure of the personality which includes experience, skill, responsibility, intelligence, power of organizing people and social interaction. Leadership is an indispensable activity, which every

    Words: 2621 - Pages: 11
  • Leadership Essay

    Leadership Quarterly, 3(4), 271-305. Copyright @ 1992 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 1048-9843 Faculty of Management, University Campus, 272 LEADERSHIP QUARTERLY Vol. 3 No. 4 1992 & Rotter, 1985). There is a consensus among scholars that expectations and motivation are positively associated. However, none of these theoreticians has proposed that we apply knowledge of this relationship by purposely raising worker expectations

    Words: 17761 - Pages: 72
  • Leadership Essay

    bend some rules, because ‘life’ does not always fit into a system. A characteristic of leadership I find very important is accountability. If you lead, you must be held accountable. I enjoy the responsibility of accountability. I want to know that my followers are pleased with my leadership. I enjoy feedback. No one wants to be lead astray. Lastly, I believe one of the most underrated characteristics of leadership that I posses is enthusiasm. How can you inspire others to share your vision if you seem

    Words: 1634 - Pages: 7
  • democratic leadership style Essay

    In fact the leadership style plays a crucial role in a business which refers to the art of making the subordinates work efficiently in aim of pursuing a mutual goal which is favorable for both the firm and the employees. The leadership style varies in business, however in contemporary democracy societie, it is commonly believed that a democratic leadership style is the most effective for management. This essay will discuss the pros and cons of democracy leadership style and explain why it is the

    Words: 1623 - Pages: 7
  • Essay on Leadership

    This experienced made Jobs realized that he needed to take an unmarked path to get to where his intuition was leading him. Steve Jobs was successful at creating the new Macintosh home computer, however, he quickly failed at his leadership position. According to the Buisness News Daily, “After a falling out with Apple's CEO, John Sculley, Jobs resigned in 1985 to follow his own interests. He started a new software and hardware company, NeXT, Inc., and he invested in a small animation company, Pixar

    Words: 2493 - Pages: 10
  • Leadership Essay

    love the culture in which you are in. And try to learn about its strengths, don’t focus on the weaknesses, and make sure that all the people you are transferring with you are of the same opinion.” “I think one of the basics of transcultural leadership is empathy.” He stresses the importance of cultivating a certain mindset or character that truly enjoys the challenge of living in new environments: “If you have to work and particularly do something significant in a country it is much easier

    Words: 5419 - Pages: 22