Lars And Pollution Case Study Solution

Improved Essays
Case 12: Lars and Pollution

Who has moral responsibility for deciding what to do?

In this case we are introduced to Lars Olsen, the current CEO of Electronic Manufacturing Incorporated (EMI). Lars is faced with the ethical dilemma of deciding what to recommend to the board with regards to reducing the cost of recycling their electronic products. EMI is a large manufacturer of wireless mobile devices located in Berengaria, along with all of their consumers. The Berengarian government has recently put into place new environmental legislation, which holds electronic manufacturers responsible for the recycling of any toxic waste found in their products. This legislation outlines that the manufacturers are still legally responsible for the proper
…show more content…
The second option would be to send the disposable electronics Kangan, a West-African country where labour is much cheaper and there are no electronic disposal laws. Considering that Lars’ recommendation of how to minimize recycling costs will ultimately be voted and decided on by the board, it can be said that both Lars’ and the rest of the board member’s hold equal moral responsibility in deciding what to do. Lars could potentially suggest an alternative option and convince the board to vote on the alternative, however, when it comes down to it he holds no more or less influence on what the board decides. It is with this in mind that I can say with confidence that the board and Lars hold the moral responsibility of this case’s …show more content…
If EMI were to locate the factory in Berengaria, they would have to consider the shareholders of EMI due the higher cost of labour and strict regulations. We must also consider the considerable long term health issues on the citizens of Berengaria that would be caused by the emissions from the recycling plant. From a non-anthropocentric view, the surrounding wildlife, natural resources and overall ecosystem in Berengaria are also owed moral consideration due to the pollution and environmental damages they would all suffer from. On top of the citizens having their health effected by the emissions, the Berengarian economy would also see implications due to the location of the plant. If businesses workers are forced to take time off due to environmental sickness, then it can be assumed that the businesses themselves will suffer, and in turn the entire economy if health becomes a big enough problem.
To summarize, if the recycling plant is to be located in Berengaria, the EMI shareholders, the Berengarian citizens, wildlife, ecosystem, and economy would all be negatively affected in some way, and thus, are all owed moral

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    To improve and to stop the world decline of the important resources they need to put laws into place and create organizations to fight back this problem. If they don’t the world will come to an end. However there are some people who disagree with this claim. In fact according to Motoko Rich and John Broder in their article, “A Debt Arises on Job creation and environment,” they state that many economists agree that regulation comes with undeniable costs that can affect workers. Factories may close because of the high cost of cleanup, or owners may relocate to countries with weaker regulations.…

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Almost all of our gains in the fields of industrial progress, science and technology have been realizing at the cost of our health. Human causes the most serious consequences is: environment because environmetal changing can cause global warming,climate change,…The world is becoing wamer and wamer. There is also prediction of regional climate changes along the ecosystem. Also, it affects human’s life as: water we drink, air we breathe. For instance, the water we drink and the vegetables are all contaminated today.…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The environment and climate have been controversial topics for many people. Environmental and climate damage have caused many societies in the past to collapse. Both videos lecture this week point out the need to keep the environment and climate safe and free from damage. If nothing is done, it can cause major damage on our isolated planet Earth and most importantly negatively human beings. Humans need to understand the importance the environment has on our survival.…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Water contamination is a major issue, both to humans and the environment. There are many ethical issues surrounding companies who may contribute to water contamination and those who govern water safety. Water contamination events can cause nationwide concern, such as the drinking water in the city of Flint, Michigan and the BP Deepwater Horizon oil spill into the Gulf of Mexico. Water contamination can have disastrous consequences for the human population with effects such as birth defects and non-communicable diseases. According to the textbook, there is a good chance that future wars will be fought over access to water and other resources.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This adverse condition also reminded us of how the factory activity can affect not only us but also our environment; it’s because of it would also damage the plants around us. Another effect that will appear is that our nature can be harmed because of the plant waste or the chemical waste. Factory used to throw their waste into the river, the plant waste that is being thrown, will contaminate our river and create diseases. If we recall, this issues had become a reality that is now affecting the people who lives in Flint Michigan United States. Apparently their governor has changed their water resources in order to saves up money.…

    • 1708 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Net neutrality should be the status quo on internet usage to keep is loyal users. Large corporations such as phone companies, cable providers and internet service providers (ISPs) are against net neutrality solely because of their interest in greater financial prosperity. These conglomerates that are against net neutrality…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    So you can see that Chiang Mai’s smoky season can cause damage to the environment, quality of life, health problem, tourism and traffic. According to Acharee Tiptanatoranin of the Journal of the political administration, haze and forest fires have an impact on both tourism and business services, where relevant. Due to the smog problem, some airlines have canceled some flights for passenger safety. It also affects the traffic on the highway between provinces. Consequently, everyone should ponder these issues again and find ways to deal with the…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fireman said something very true that we should do, “It is an inheritance that we must use, but that we must find a way to use without endangering ourselves by filling the air with the pollution that fossil fuels create” (Fineman223). Instead of poisoning ourselves we should come up with a solution that would help both our pockets and mother Earth. I recently read in the International Energy Agency that, “In the 40 years that in which the…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The increased harmful effects to the climate as a result of the adopted lifestyle of polluting the earth, it means that people now to live with extra cost to modify the environment to tolerable levels. Otherwise, it would also mean human destruction. People would get appliances such as air conditioners and expensive fire extinguishers to help in cases of fire resulting from overheating. Likeliness of increased levels of skin disease occurrence would be unimaginable, and many people would live an expensive life of catering for such problems. The government would also invest heavily in measures of preventing excessive damages, and thus experience would be costly resulting in poverty.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Work hazards are present in most work environments. Hence, the interest of health and safety is of concern to the employee, employer, government and health related sectors. Employees are concerned because safety risks could render them victimized and endanger their health. Employers also heed the importance of prevention at work if not out of a moral duty, it would be because work accidents pose an economic burden and forces them to lose workforce. Government and health related sectors have an interest in accidents arising at work because it would eventually affect the general productivity.…

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays