Compare And Contrast Tracy And Catcher In The Rye

Improved Essays
Tracy and Holden are products of a culture which does not support those with mental illness which creates a divide between them and society. Holden embodies the lack of attention and support for those with mental illness and Tracy shows that society lets them down by not being around for them. Without a support system, Holden and Tracy are left to themselves with questions and trying to figure out their problems alone. Holden and Tracy are great examples of our society’s lack of support to people with Mental Illness. Holden shows the lack of attention and support for people with mental health because he is forced to lead a life without guidance and information about maturing. Holden demonstrates symptoms like depression, anxiety, and stress …show more content…
Both are left in the same situation. Both are left without friends. Holden wants to stay innocent while his friends abandon him for adult life. Tracy is left alone because she is seen as crazy and lost her only friend in Sunny. Although Holden runs away from any connection he has from society, his mental illness is what stops people from dragging him back in. Depression and anxiety is not wanted in today's society which is evident in Holden’s isolation. On the opposite side, Tracy looks for connections in her imaginary boyfriend, Sunny, parents, and other people she meets. She is seen as crazy and left alone. Tracy reaches out while Holden rejects, but both are left in the same spot. Tracy and Holden shows us a society similar to ours in which those who have mental illness are thrown out of society. They are thrown into a world of problems and are alone in finding out how to hurdle problems of growing up like sex, alcohol, and love. Holden and Tracy did not decide the unspoken rules of society but both are curcummend to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the book, Holden feels depressed. This is the result of isolation and alienation affecting Holden by not letting him reach the people he cares for, being disconnected, and giving up. Holden demonstrates isolation and alienation when he is unable to get in touch with the few people he feels a connection with. Holden doesn’t have many people who he feels…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For example, in Long Day’s Journey into Night, Tyrone continuously tells Jamie that he has no ambition in life, that he is a horrible influence on his brother and accuses him of being lazy. Even when Jamie volunteers to help with the hedge, Tyrone unkindly turns him down, saying “You’d get it crooked, as you get everything else” (O’Neill 83). In addition, Mary blames him for his father’s drinking and his older brother’s death, which further damages the relationship between Jamie and his parents. Consequently, Jamie has lost his confidence - he has no job, no apparent plans for his future and for comfort he turns to alcohol and women. It seems as though his family has given up on him and in turn, he has given up on himself.…

    • 1610 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One’s family environment or a trauma significantly affects the way one associates with others. For instance, Holden cannot seem to connect with people because Allie’s death caused a shift in focus in his family. His parents neglected him and left him at the time he needed guidance the most. He’s left to feel like he’s on his own and has convinced himself that “no one cares”. Therefore, he gives up on himself; he gives in to smoking, alcohol, and bad grades.…

    • 1282 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Depression In Society

    • 2275 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Many untreated depressives lack friends because it saps the vitality that friendship requires and immures its victims in an impenetrable sheath, making it hard for them to speak or hear words of comfort. Worldly success does little to assuage that agony, as Robin Williams’ suicide this week makes clear” (Solomon, par.6). Various untreated depressives require mates since it saps the importance that association requires and immures its setbacks in an insusceptible sheath, making it hard for them to talk or hear empowering explanations. Regular accomplishment does little to appease that misery, as Robin Williams ' suicide this week clears that…

    • 2275 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His mother alienates him for the reason that he ruined her reputation and because she has always cared less about him. Conrad’s friends isolate him after his return from the hospital because he is a “flake”. His brothers death and his suicide attempt have caused him to…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The taboo of mental disorders precedes the treatment and acknowledgement of them, leading to many ignoring their symptoms and struggles for the sake of “appearing normal.” In their attempt to be normal, people begin deteriorating as they fight a losing battle against themselves. They are forced to pretend that they do not need help or support as admitting they have an issue would inevitably lead…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For instance at the end of his date with Sally, he leaves her alone and goes about his life as if nothing happened between them (Trowbridge). But in the same way, Sally abandoned him which Holden explains when he says, “She kept telling me to go away and leave her alone. So finally I did it”(Salinger 149). On the contrary, Whissen claims that Holden forcefully alienates himself “... by choice, sometimes because he cannot stand the company of others, sometimes because he becomes disappointed with their company, and sometimes because his actions seem calculated to drive others away”(53). An overall factor of Holden’s choice to isolate himself from others is the genuine reasoning on why he feels alienated.…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both main characters are dominated by men, and not able to stand against patriarchal order in society. Isolation caused by men who controlled the lives of both characters influenced their mental health and social life. The narrator of Gilman’s story was so unhappy in her marriage that she got mad to escape from this relationship, and Emily caused tragedy because as an isolated from the world for the whole life she never learned how to lose things and people, and she wasn’t able to accept any change in her life. The isolation caused the madness of characters in both…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Majed

    • 1527 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Majid is stuck wondering where he fits in, feeling out of place in the environments others want him to be comfortable in. He is not suited for the “working man’s” life, creating a sense of displacement within Majid that leads to carelessness. This carelessness fuels his despair because without caring for anything, there is no attachment or emotion behind Majid’s desires. His desires are frivolous and short-lived, desires that are heavily illegal and socially frowned upon. Majid’s ‘desires’ are far from ‘hopes,’ emphasizing how by caring for nothing he voids himself of hope and possibilities, leaving empty space for despair to come and fill in.…

    • 1527 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Salinger. Holden’s inability to concentrate is one symptom of depression that has him expelled from school for not finishing his studies, which kept him isolated from other students and faculty. This inability to concentrate is a symptom of depression that makes it very difficult to commit oneself to any single chore. More so, Holden is incapable of having a healthy and loving relationship with a male friend or a female love interest. This is the result of a loss of interests in other people, which is another symptom of depression that Holden experiences with a prostitute and his poor relations with Mr. Spencer.…

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays