Kripke Causal Theory Of Name Essay

Great Essays
Essay #2 Assignment
When it comes to names in philosophy, there are many different arguments and views for how names should be dealt with and in what situation. Linguistic tokens, such as names and referential terms, have been the center of philosophical questions into the nature of reference. In his book, Naming and Necessity, Saul Kripke outlines his causal theory of reference for names. Gareth Evans, who, along with many others, was not satisfied with Kripke’s causal theory, wrote, The Causal Theory of Names, where he poses problems for Kripke’s view. The main attack was that the theory is not successfully in dealing with issues where the references of names change. Evans argument shows the most presence in his recognized Madagascar example. Though Evan’s communicates problems that are worthy of acknowledging, I believe that by examining the main ideas in Kripke’s causal theory of reference, the problems of reference change are not shattering to the theory. It is just that Kripke’s terms in the theory do not have enough description, not so much the fact that the theory can’t prove explanations for situations of reference change.
Kripke was not fully satisfied with the descriptive theory or the cluster theory, so as a result he proposed the causal theory. The theory begins with a causal chain where an initial baptism takes place. Having the idea of a baptism works in favor of avoiding various counterintuitive outcomes of the description theory and is evident in Kripke’s example of a man named Gödel. Referring to Gödel as “the man who proved the incompleteness theorem” and then learning in the future that Gödel plagiarized proof from Schmidt, means that using the name Gödel would be referring to Schmidt according to the descriptive theory. However, our instincts tell us that we are referring to Gödel. Kripke says, “it does not seem that if most of the ϕ’s are satisfied by a unique object γ, then γ is the referent of the name. This seems simply to be false.” (Kripke, Naming and Necessity). The causal theory proves to have clear advantages. In his Causal Theory of Names, Evans recognizes that Kripke’s theory has its benefits, but still feels that unamended it is not accurate. A crucial problem he has with the theory deals with Kripke’s initial baptism and that it’s unapparent which devices are being used when something is initially being denoted. The most description that Kripke gives about initial baptism’s is that, “When the name is 'passed from link to link,' the receiver of the name must, I think, intend when he learns to use it with the same reference as the man from whom he heard it." The issue Evans sees with this is that despite how vague or far-flung the causal relationship between a person’s use of a proper name and the object it originally referred to, when the person uses the name they are still going to be referring to that object. Evidently it appears that the theory has no regards for context and so Evans likes to suggest it as a magic trick. “The capacity to denote something” has been passed on somehow and since its been passed on, there’s no way for it to ever be lost. Another concern of Evans about the causal theory, in the category of surrounding context, is that it does not fully justify the difference believing and denoting. There can be situations where a person may use a name and say something about the name that is true, and no causal chain from the person’s use of the term to the terms initial baptism will exist. An example would be a person who knows the method behind naming U.S. city streets, in that they are named numerically and chronologically.
…show more content…
So it appears the main problem for the causal theory begins at a names initial baptism because once it’s given a reference, in the future, causally disseminated uses of the name will unavoidably be referring back to the reference given at the initial baptism. Regardless if the name in the future is widely accepted as referring to something else. That being said, I think that Evan’s criticism is successful if the causal theory is unamended, because instances of reference change are critical to

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Two young men from the inner city part of Baltimore, Maryland located right on the boarder that separated Maryland from Washington, DC found each other as one of the young men developed a weird connection with another young man that he had never met before. Sharing the same exact name as him with the feeling that this connection was destiny being from the same exact area, only visiting the prison a couple times Wes Moore (Wes 1) was able to see that they lived somewhat of a similar but different life style. Sharing many of the same experiences, but one handling situations different from the other which was the main reason they sat on opposite sides of the table one being the visitor and one being the visited. The other Wes Moore (Wes 2) would have no opportunity to life on the outside as he served a life sentence with his brother Tony for killing a police officer named Bruce Prothero as they tried to rob a jewelry store, both having multiple offense before this. Meanwhile…

    • 2157 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In History “In History”, by Jamaica Kincaid, weaves together the stories of Christopher Columbus, George Clifford, and Carl Linnaeus so that the reader may understand why the author is questioning her own history and those who are like her. Kincaid questions us, “What is History? Is it a Theory? Is it an Ideal” She answers these questions through the stories of these three men as they come across and label foreign people, lands, or plants. Kincaid implies that the act of identifying and labeling unfamiliar with familiar terms are taken from these men 's subjective lives.…

    • 1226 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the book Freakonomics the authors, Stephen Levitt and Stephen Dubner, takes a novel approach to studying economics, sharing its most interesting research. First they begin with the topic of correlation and causation. According to them correlation means, “A relationship exists between two factors—let’s call them X and Y—but it tells you nothing about the direction of that relationship. It’s possible that X causes Y; it’s also possible that Y causes X; and it may be that X and Y are both being caused by some other factor, Z. ” (8). One the other hand, causation is when one object affects the other object.…

    • 1817 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At the beginning of his novel, “Candide,” Voltaire introduces the character Pangloss and his greatest philosophical and spiritual ideas he passes to Candide and Cunégonde: “Pangloss gave instruction in metaphysico-theologico-cosmoloonigology. He proved admirably that there cannot possibly be an effect without a cause and that in this best of all possible worlds the Baron’s castle was the best of all castles and his wife the best of all possible Baronesses. It is clear, said he, that things cannot be otherwise than they are, for since everything is made to serve an end, everything necessarily serves the best end. Observe: noses were made to support spectacle, hence we have spectacles.…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The short story “Naming of Names” by Ray Bradbury is about the protagonist, Harry, who moved to Mars with his family and immediately doesn’t like the change. Resisting change causes more harm than good. When his friends tell him, ”You’re getting thinner Harry”, he responds I’m not. They tell him, “and taller”, he yells, “liar!”. Harry loses some of his social friends due to his bad behavior.…

    • 263 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is the author’s attempt to make the reader associate his name with…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Seeing how kids and teenagers develop and deciding the stage procedures is a complex selection of theories. Numerous thinkers and specialists have their own theory of how the body and mind grow. There is no good and bad in their methods of insight, there are appraisals of human development. While a few speculations can be straightforwardly connected to a man, so can another. To demonstrate reality in these theories, I will give examples of how all the kids in the movie ‘Babies’ by Thomas Balmes demonstrate characteristics discussed in each given theory.…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My Name Is Mine Analysis

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages

    1."The Name Is Mine," by Anna Quindlen,” according Quindlen, she propose that her name plays a significant part in her life, the surname she inherits at birth, she refuse to give it up at marriage to settle under the identity of or husband last name. "My Name," by Sandra Cisneros, she states the reasons why the name Esperanza do not repents who she is as a person and why she wants to change her name to one that identifies who she really is and represent her identity. One’s name does not have the power to shapes his/her identity and mold one’s destiny in life. A name uses to identify his/her at birth, which our parents given to us are a sense of ownership throughout his/her lifetime. Many stand behind the name because of their self-accomplishment…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Cruelty is at the heart of genocide. The killers just don’t eradicate the targeted people, but brutalize them in ways that far exceed what is needed to kill them.” – Jonah Goldhagen A quote from the narrator of Genocide: Worst the War, that I find critical for the discussion regarding the politicizations of genocide.…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. Identify which author and theory you are using: I am going to use a middle-range theory of acute pain by Marion Good Ph.D, RN. After reading your chosen articles on nursing theory, write a paper that answers the following points/questions: 2. Describe the theory and its components?…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This segment revolves around the importance of a name and everything that makes up a name.…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In an effort to argue for the existence of God, Saint Thomas Aquinas provides five cosmological arguments in his piece “The Existence of God”. The second argument he states examines causes and effects and looks to explain these series in regard to their beginning, or first cause (43:1-2). Aquinas says that the chain of causes and effects cannot go back to “infinity” (43:60) because when the first cause is taken out, so is its effect and every following effect (43:61). I find this claim plausible because this would mean that there would be no “caused” things in existence. Aquinas follows to say that “there obviously are such causes” (43:62) in existence, so the first cause must not have been taken away.…

    • 1238 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “When we know the name of something, it brings us closer to the ground” (Goldberg, 57). Here, I believe Goldberg is trying to apply reasoning and credibility for readers to understand that, when one knows the name of someone or something you will feel closer. Even though Goldberg argues that it’s important to call things by their real names, she only provides us with a few examples and by adding more personal examples and the names of the people around her…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Theoretical Framework For Nursing Practice Unit 1 – Introduction to Theory Learning Activities 1. According to Chinn & Jacobs, there are several meanings of nursing theories as shown below (Meleis, 2007): 1.1 Theory base on structuration – according to Anthony Giddens, the social structure and its relationship with one another forms a theory when a certain action or ideas are reproduced or repeated such as culture, traditions, religion, morality, learning forms a theory or a social structure (Craib, 2011). This structure theory can be replaced or ignored if another theory is proven worthy of adoption such as conversion of religion, changes in learning tools from books to computer or changes in nursing leadership etc,. 1.2 Theory base on goals-setting…

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The time period leading up to, and immediately after the civil rights movement was a very difficult time to be an African American due to discrimination and segregation. The two short stories, “What’s in a Name?” and “Finishing School”, both focus on these things, however, the characters, themes and settings in which they take place are very different. Ironically, the paths these characters ultimately take in their adult lives end up very similar.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays