Can Knowledge Be Justified

Improved Essays
The word “philosophy” is normally associated with questioning and discovering the truth behind topics such as reasoning, existence, and knowledge. Philosophers ask questions left and right in order to gain more knowledge about the world, leading them to become known as “lovers of wisdom.” This ultimately leads to the question of “What is knowledge or wisdom?” Philosophers ponder over what it is to truly “know” something, and how trustworthy are the facts that humans thought they knew. Over the years, countless theories about knowledge arose until one definition of knowledge became widely recognized: Justified, True, Belief. The concept of justified, true, belief is centered around conditions that must be fulfilled in order for someone to know …show more content…
In order for X to be justified in believing P, X has to rule out other alternatives that might make P false. For instance, assume that X took an exam in college with twenty nine other classmates. The teacher announces that only one student was able to get an A on the exam. The chances of X being the student who got an A would be one out of thirty, or about three percent. At this point, X does not know whether he was able to get the A. Assuming that there was an even separation of girls and boys in the class, the teacher announces that the student was a boy. Now X’s chance increased to one out of fifteen, or approximately six percent. but X still doesn’t know if he got an A. Finally, the teacher reveals that the student who got an A was either X or Y. X’s chances of being the A student has increased to fifty percent, yet X still does not know if he is the student because he hasn’t rule out the possibility of Y being the A student. As seen from the example, justification comes in degrees, which means that X can be less justified at some points and more justified at other points in time. But for X to know that he was the student who got an A, X needs to rule out all other possibilities and have absolute justification that the A student was really him. This idea of absolute justification can be associated with infallibilism, which states that X cannot make an error in his justification for him to know P. …show more content…
The justified, true, belief theory states that in order for X to know P, P must be true, X must believe in P, and X must be very justified in their belief of P. However, the Gettier example shows that X can be justified in their belief for P, and P happens to be true, yet X still does not know P. The point of the Gettier example was not to show that humans do not know anything. It was suppose to demonstrate that no matter how many different conditions are added to the definition of knowledge, there will always be a counterexample. The definition of knowledge is always a work in

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Standardized Test Benefits

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Therefore, students should receive different test based on their skill level so schools can see more accurately how much students are growing year to year. Also, about eighty percent of college students change their major at least once because for one, they might not even know their strengths, and/or not have an idea as to what career they want to go in to when they start college (Ramos). This is because the current system does not really give students the opportunity to figure out what they want to do. Changing majors can cost students thousands of dollars because they still must pay for the major specific classes even though they changed majors. Another thing current standardized testing does not show is creativity, current standardize test is all book work type of things like doing math problems, and reading a passage and then answering questions about that passage.…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Russell Gough states in his article, "College Entrance Requirements for Athletes Are Unfair,” “Four years of hard work and verifiable accomplishment in high school are negated by a 3.5 hour multiple choice test” (Gough, 66). Schools rely on these test scores to determine whether or not a student is college ready. However, in studies that have been conducted by William Hiss, there is little correlation that suggests that the score a student receives on the test will predict their success in college. The Hiss study included thirty-three universities, public and private, and included data from 123,000 students. Hiss found that the difference in college grade point average among students who submitted their SAT versus the students who did not is five one-hundredths of a point (Jaschik).…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Otherwise, we are all just blabbering idiots, going on and on about our own experiences and agendas. We should all strive for objective knowledge. It’s the only knowledge that is untainted by prejudice, preconceptions, or bias and asserts to provide what is good to us…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Examples Of Contextualism

    • 1047 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Many famous philosophers have offered that the perseverance of truth is essential to creating value in a human life. Often, there are many unanswered questions that can get in the way of people pursuing truth. For example, what defines a person, what is reality, and what is Reality? Object identification poses an issue when defining human value and capability. There are theories like, originated theory, viewer theory, multiple viewer theory, and object identification theory, and contextualism that help humans address this problem.…

    • 1047 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In high school, students stress themselves by taking advanced placement classes, sports, and clubs. In addition, they have to be ready to maintain their high GPA, but in fact, admissions offices barely check on applicant 's grade point average (Marklein). Colleges do not care how many advanced placement classes the student took. In fact, colleges are interested students involving into the area of music, sports, community services, and other extracurricular activities. All efforts that students spend on maintaining a high GPA will be worthless if they do not do well on their SAT/ACT scores.…

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some may claim that DeShawn didn’t have a choice to better his life because other students from other school have the proper tutoring to be able to get into better schools. Although this may be true, DeShawn was given flashcards by his teacher, and he didn’t even look at them. On page 89 DeShawn said, “I shook my head.…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He wants you to know that this can happen to anybody regardless of how successful you was in high school. He states that it’s common sense they institutions should be preparing these first year students in advance, but gives us data on why things aren’t going as well as they should be. For k-12 education there has been budget cuts which “affects the ability for many high schools to provide college-bound students with the tools needed for a successful transition.” (Harke para 4) Because of budget cuts many counselors lack the support needed to help the students in need guidance, he gives more data showing the counselor-to-students ratio is greater than 1:900 in the California Department of Education. Therefore, “Counselors can’t prepare high school seniors for the academic, social, and personal challenges associated with transitioning to college.” (Harke para 6) This issue has been notice and many colleges are trying to help these first-year students by getting them to “set more realistic expectations,” (Harke Para 7) but since these programs takes place on campus it’s already too…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Humans contain a deep yearning for knowledge. Given that the previous sentence is merely an assertion with no justification, there is no need for one to believe me – it may be true, but until that is justified and found to be true, it is nothing beyond a belief. Prior to a proposition’s justification, one should not be infer that it is knowledge. Justification for objective knowledge can be divided into two categories: a posteriori arguments and a priori arguments. These categories take many names; a posteriori is similar to empirical arguments, which are defined as observational proof.…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sure, if someone doesn’t get into their first college, then they still have a chance at getting into another. While research varies, Affirmative Action in college admission offices is the equivalent of adding 150 to 310 points on an SAT score for a minority (11 Facts). Should that rejection be based on their achievements or skin color? The kid who goes to a college preparatory high school, earns good grades and who is involved should be admitted into college, but with affirmative action, the less knowledgeable kids get accepted in their place even though they aren't educationally ready. Most people often believed that Affirmative Action gives minority groups more of an unearned advantage over others.…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Coherentism In Philosophy

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Coherentism has not gained much recognition throughout the history of philosophy. According to the traditional definition of knowledge, knowledge is Justified True Belief. Hence, one must first justify their belief before they can acquire any knowledge. Since most of the time the beliefs we assume we have justified and are justified based on other belief. Consequently, this promotes the concept of regress argument where the philosophers are on the quest to truly justify a belief thus we can know for sure that we have knowledge.…

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics