Kilgour Family Streetcar Case Study

Improved Essays
The Kilgour Family Streetcar thrived in Oakley until 1951, when it no longer served the public’s needs. Accompanied by high fares and inefficient routes, Oakley’s residents did not contest the termination of streetcar operations. Although the Kilgour Family Streetcar was key in the characterization and urbanization of Oakley, it was not the only failed transit-stop on the journey to finding the light at the end of the tunnel for Oakley; the light signifying an efficient, reliable transportation system to serve its residents.
Cincinnati encounters hundreds of commuters, residents, shoppers everyday, and unbeknownst to most, right below all the energy and excitement rests seven miles of ruined tunnel and six subway stops. Here lies America’s
…show more content…
By early 1921, the hypothetical inflation that some feared, became a reality as the city was only able to fund the construction of seven of the original sixteen miles the city proposed. It was clear that the original rapid transit loop plan could not be built, in full, for the initial $6 Million price tag. This was large in part to the doubling construction cost throughout wartime. Therefore, to build the entire subway loop it would match the initial appraisal costs of $12 Million. To stay on budget, the city concluded that the Cincinnati Subway would produce the most revenue if it served the western half and the section of the loop from Saint Bernard to Oakley. Thus, with insufficient funds, it was time to cut the eastern half of the loop plan that stretched from Oakley back into downtown. If the city were to extend the track to Oakley, this would require the completion of all the proposed stations, the creation of five more stations, and an added $1.3 Million. For $6 Million, the line would need to exclude the eastern half, but could still follow its original plan, only extending from downtown to Oakley, not looping back from Oakley into downtown. It is important to note that this quoted $6 Million did not include the construction costs of installment of the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Kenneth Jackson contends in Crabgrass Frontier, that the development of the skyscraper with the telephone and elevator emphasized the vigor of the American city in the 19th century, “but the extraordinary prosperity and vitality of most urban cores between 1890 and 1950 cannot be understood without reference to the streetcar systems.” Unlike cable cars or the railroad, streetcars highlighted the business district and connected the people to the heart of the city. The streetcar enabled mobilization so people had more choices about where to live which triggered growth outside of the city. Jackson further illustrates this point stating, “the tracks radiated out from the center like spokes on a wheel, tying residential areas far distant to the…

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Etowah Case Study

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Etowah’s revitalization and development initiative began as a result of various occurrences. First, Louisville & Nashville Railroad Co. (L&N), the reason Etowah was created, decided to pull up its stakes in 1974 and leave Etowah (Lambe, 2008, p. 55). This move by L&N resulted in the closure of many railroad jobs, leaving many men to find work elsewhere. This is when Etowah made the decision to bring the manufacturing industries into town, which would ultimately create more jobs for residents. Apparel and textile industries in Etowah would be successful for a while until Etowah’s largest manufacturing employer, Beaunit Fibers, left town leaving 1,000 local residents without jobs (Lambe, 2008, p. 55).…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Baltimore and Ohio Rail Road Company (B&O) was America’s first common carrier railroad. The line was built by Baltimore merchants and bankers to connect the Port of Baltimore with the western states. The recently completed (1820) Erie Canal was drawing away business by connecting the Port of New York to western states. The B&O was a success from the beginning carrying freight and passengers over a quickly expanding network of intercity rail lines. This pioneering effort spurred other railroad development among the eastern states.…

    • 238 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Franklinton is a small neighborhood, just west of the the city, and right beside the Scioto River. For years it has been referred to as “The bottom” because of its low socio-economic yield, as well as being below the water level of the Scioto River. According to an article written in The Atlantic, Franklinton was the first settlement in Columbus in 1797. This along with the fact that it is just a quarter mile away from the city makes it hard to believe that Franklinton is one of the most impoverished communities in Columbus. This community has faced a lot of hardships since its establishment in Columbus.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Poverty is a causal nexus for many problems in American neighborhoods. Baltimore, a city once known for its thriving economy during the manufacturing era saw its socio-economic downfall when the manufacturing era ended and poverty became a looming reality for many of its residents. Although Federal and state governments have tried relentlessly to revive Baltimore, substance abuse, racial segregation, and violence caused by the then rapidly declining economy diffused in the fabric of the city. Many people who lived in Baltimore during its prosperous times recall the potential many Marylanders saw in the future of the city. Still, despite the seemingly unfavorable future that Baltimore portrays, many see the positive side of the city as a beacon of hope for what is to come.…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Transcontinental Railroad was not only the first massive mode of transportation to connect coast to coast for the United States but it was a race, a major source of immigration, culture, and the livelihood for many who worked on it. Building the railroad wasn’t an easy feat, it had grueling trials on both the manual and non-manual side of the process. The financing for the railroad constituted finding loopholes to get the most government funding possible and finding investors. While the manual workers had to face, tough terrain, angry natives, dangerous explosives, long hours, low pay, hazardous weather conditions and many more. The Transcontinental Railroad was also one of the most committed engineering projects during the 19th century.…

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gentrification 's Insidious Violence; The Truth about American Cities Ever wonder what will happen if people band together to try to fix whole communities? What would happen if these cities now seen as blackened areas disappeared completely? What would happen to the infrastructure, and most importantly what would happen to those already living there? These very important and current issues are answered in "Gentrification 's Insidious Violence; The Truth about American Cities" written by Daniel Jose Older in order to change the view of the everyday and almost seen as a common American, the "middle-class white republican. " The definition of gentrification is the buying and renovating of houses and stores in broken down neighborhoods by wealthier people, often displacing low income families and small businesses.…

    • 1422 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    During the 1840’s a man named Asa Whitney had a vision to connect the East and West Coast together with a railroad (Carvantes 4). He saw the great potential of a railroad stretching across America seeing how it could allow people and resources to travel across the country in a safe and reliable form of transportation. His vision would come to be realized with the creation of the Transcontinental Railroad. Construction of the railroad first began in 1863 and was a very long and expensive process costing up to $96 million (Carvantes 4). However, it proved to be well worth the time, effort, resources, and money.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Corruption Of Detroit

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages

    It isn’t simply a perceived corrupt system, or tainted images of success that tear down the citizenships hope in the American Dream, but also the state of the country’s economy that has left so many without hope, unable to sustain the ideals of the people. With each passing year, more and more job positions are sent overseas at the behest of companies wishing to save cost. The city of Detroit is hit hardest by this trend, as recorded in the book “The Fall of an American Rome”, which details the huge loss of manufacturing jobs within the city, a drop from 290,000 positions in the 1960s, to merely 27,000 in recent years (Skrabec). The loss of work doesn’t simply affect income, but the city’s prosperity as whole, even the city’s literacy, which…

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Essay On New Haven

    • 1723 Words
    • 7 Pages

    New Haven, a city in Connecticut, is notable for undergoing major changes during the city’s existence. It doesn’t offer images glamorous and lavish lifestyle like major US cities, or the dream of someone coming into this city and having it change their entire life. Nonetheless, it offers the idea of the American Dream, New Haven is a city where one can own a house a among the most modern and sophisticated infrastructures. Its history of development and redevelopment is an uncommon story, consequently New Haven has been examined multiple times because it has a unique urban renewal experience. However, the implications of New Haven’s urban renewal projects have gone unheard and unforeseen by the common citizen.…

    • 1723 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Where someone not great is put into a situation where they are forced to try and cope when a situation puts them are under pressure. The audience finds this type of tragedy entertaining because of the way the hero/heroine reacts under pressure. For example in Arthur Miller's tragedy 'A View from the Bridge' - Eddie is under pressure when two immigrants come and live with him, and his main flaw is jealousy. To begin with, A Streetcar Named Desire is considered as a tragedy because it has a tragic heroine. Each tragic hero or heroine has the potential to do, they are characterised as being the perfect hero except for his/her flaws, they are in conflict with at least one person around them, they are trapped in situations that they cannot get out of, they seem to be doomed from the start and they bring about their own downfall.…

    • 1478 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ten year old, Lafayette Rivers exclaims enthusiastically in Alex Kotlowitz’ 1992 biography There Are No Children Here, “If I grow up, I’d like to be a bus driver”. Sophomore year, in Honors English, we were reading out loud in class when this aspiration of a lower-income, innocent child, was lethargically muttered by a classmate, and to my dismay, I began to cry. I was saddened by the fact Naperville was less than 60 miles away from Chicago, yet my peers knew so little of what too many city children, like Lafayette who lived in Cabrini Green, had to endure. What broke my spirit, was that my peers were only sympathizing for that class period and would go on with their daily lives, giving no second thought to children who are less fortunate, who have to give so much just to help their families survive, and who are not even sure they will have the opportunity to grow up.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Ian Frazier’s “Take the F,” Frazier gives an observation of his views on Brooklyn, the F train and New York City as a whole. Within these observations, Frazier writes beyond a given place and considers the interaction of people. For example, he describes his long train ride from Brooklyn to Manhattan: “every ride can produce its own mini-society of riders, its own forty-minute Ship of Fools.” By using “mini-societies” Frazier gives readers the sense that these riders aren’t strangers anymore, they are a body of “people living together in a more or less ordered community.” Through his scrutiny, Frazier connects strangers through common sensory experience showing that people form connections beyond verbal language and are instantly linked through the power of senses.…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Peter Calthorpe Urbanism

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Notable Planner: Peter Calthorpe Chanel D. Ellison The Ohio State University New Urbanist Peter Calthorpe has not only been a visionary for urban planning, but has brought his visions to life. With ideals similar to John Nolen and his bringing of Garden Cities to America, urban sprawl smart growth have been the plight of Peter Calthorpe’s urban planning focus. Under the umbrella of new urbanism, Calthorpe incorporates the ideas of transit oriented communities and environmentally sustainable communities. His publications and city plans do not fail to emulate his four key principles in regards to planning; diversity, human scale, conservation, and regionalism.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    New York City From a New Yorker’s Point of View: A City Filled with Flaws New York City. The Big Apple. The City that Never Sleeps. These phrases always seem to catch the attention of many people. When New York comes up in a conversation, most people think about well-known locations like Grand Central Station where you can travel to upstate New York or other states near New York, or Times Square where the lights shine the brightest and there are so many different things to do like shopping, eating, sightseeing, or just hanging out.…

    • 1271 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays