Katrina Clark My Father Was An Anonymous Donor Analysis

Improved Essays
Some say blood is thicker than water. However, is blood thicker than sperm? The argument about nature versus nurture has been going on for years. Do people really need to know where they come from to feel whole or even feel happy? In Katrina Clark’s article, “My Father was an Anonymous Sperm Donor,” Clark argues that children conceived from sperm donors deserve the right to know their fathers. Clark uses some history about sperm banks beginning to flourish in the 1980’s and 90’s. Also, Clark talks about how some maladies within that time period had happened. (1-2) While Clark’s history is somewhat credible, she uses mostly people’s pity to show her argument. Furthermore, Clark uses careless generalization and jabbers about other’s families …show more content…
In Clark’s experience, not knowing her father made her feel lost and disorientated. She states that children born into that situation did not get a choice to live without limitations and confusion. Clark states, “It’s hypocritical of parents and medical professionals to assume that biological roots won’t matter to the ‘products’ of cryobanks’ service, when longing for a biological relationship is what brings customers to the banks in the first place.” (1) What the author means by this is, everyone wants some sort of biological relationship. However, her mother will always be her biological mother. She mentions at a young age she was always jealous because one friend’s mother went through two divorces but her friend still knew a little about her dad. Clark was jealous of another friend because after her parents got divorced, she got all the attention and no one had offered Clark any sympathy or support like that. Once Clark’s mother got married, her new stepfather always got in the middle of their arguments. She told her stepfather that he had no authority over her because she had no father. (2) Therefore, Clark tries to grasp the reader’s attention by making them feel bad for her but has no evidence to further her …show more content…
By using the statement, “We offspring are recognizing the right that was stripped from us at birth – the right to know both of our parents,” she is implying that all children born in the same or similar situation feel the same that she does. (1) However, this may not be the case. She never mentions other situations or even evidence of children in the same situation feeling the same way. People go to sperm banks for many reasons. She fails to mention the good that sperm banks do. These cryrobanks help women with biological clocks ticking who want to give a child a life. It even helps couples who can’t have kids due to low sperm count, poor motility, and abnormal morphology of sperm. (Womens-health.co.uk) Clark also fails to mention that sperm donor children don’t suffer from any greater social, psychological, or emotional problems than traditional families. (Telegraph.co.uk)In an article called, “Sperm Donor Children Are Fine without Fathers,” Cambridge University proves the statement through research between traditional and sperm donor families. Clark doesn’t use any other information other than her own experience within the article. By assuming that all sperm donor children feel just as she does on the topic, she fails to prove her

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In court, this part of the process was brought up. Karla Dunston said that Szfranski’s sperm was a donation so she should be able to use it. Jacob Szfranski’s lawyer argues that his client was providing his sperm and not donating it (Schwartz). Using the doctor’s visit as evidence, they both agreed that they would use his sperm so it was not a donation it was Jacob Szfranski providing his sperm in order for Karla to have a child (Schwartz). The issue with this case is that the courts cannot treat it as a custody case because scientifically a frozen embryo is not the same as a living child (Schwartz).…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mother’s do not take their children out of this world and not have sympathy afterwards or regret. This Mother aborted her unborn child after many other abortions, but began remembering the child and what could have been life, and realizes even though it was unborn, it was a body. Every day some women gets pregnant, and it is their decision whether or not they think it is best if their child came into this world or not. It may be a tough decision, but it is between the mother and child not the rest of the…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Katherine Santana Mrs. Tapia English 3 Honors 11 November, 2015 In Vitro Fertilization Patrick Steptoe, a pioneer of fertility treatment, once said, “I'm not a wizard or a Frankenstein tampering with Nature. We are not creating life. We have merely done what many people try to do in all kinds of medicine—to help nature. We found nature could not put an egg and sperm together, so we did it. We do not see anything immoral in doing that in the interests of the mother.…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Still, a lot of lay people have misconception that mothers are always awarded custody of the children. There is no preference given to parent based solely on gender; therefore, Michael has a good chance to custody of his two children, based on the best interest of the children, which is Michael has provided all the day-to-day needs of the children during the weekday. In Hassenstab, the father petitioned for the custody of his daughter, alleging that his ex-wife is a lesbian and openly dating other woman. Further, the father argued that the mother committed suicide before marriage suffered psychological difficulties and consuming alcohol, failure to provide a stable home environment for the child; therefore, she was morally and mentally an unfit mother. The court those allegations were not warranted, but the child’s desire where to live, it’s the child’s best interest.…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A woman who has become pregnant naturally, which is impregnation through sexual intercourse, and wishes to keep the child possesses the decision-making rights to the child. Her gestating the fetus should not give her the right to the fetus, but rather her intention to keep the fetus (Liezl 2002). Until her name is written on the birth certificate, she is not technically the legal mother (Resolve 2016). Furthermore, a father is not considered the legal father on the same grounds. A man definitely does not gestate the fetus, but becomes a father legally by placing his name on the child’s birth certificate (Nolo 2016).…

    • 1422 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The couple had been to multiple doctors and they had all given the same diagnosis that Ruth was infertile and Ruth was taking the news very badly. She saw herself as a failure as a woman since she couldn’t do “the most natural thing in the world,” while her mother and sister had been able to do it multiple times easily. When Alex tried to comfort her by saying that they didn’t need children Ruth snapped at him that, “No one needs children, Alex. People want them,” and then said that she was a disappointment to him. She refused to believe Alex’s denials about her disappointing him by being infertile, he countered that as a teacher she had classrooms full of children, and that she had him, her “big baby.” For many couples they expect to have children after marriage, and in the “Family Development Perspective” children are a huge indicator in the different stages of a family’s life, which depends mainly on how the couple reacts to the presence or absence of children (Mitchell, 2009).…

    • 2067 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Polio Synthesis Essay

    • 1323 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Although Henrietta Lacks herself was not able to reap the benefits of her contribution to science, her family got to understand her a little more. The family bonded over the immortal cells of their mother through the spiritual sense of her always being there with him. Without the findings of HeLa, the world would not have had as many lives saved. Zakariyya never met his mother, but has had grudges toward the doctors that protected his mother for as long as he could remember and fathom what happened. He felt as though the doctors took advantage of his mom.…

    • 1323 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Benefits Of Bottle Feeding

    • 1032 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Thinking that baby formula is as good as breast milk is believing that thirty years of technology is superior to three million years of nature 's evolution…” Some children are brought into families through surrogacy or adoption and this kind of thinking is baseless and in fact harmful to parents who cannot provide breast milk for their child. Perhaps the biggest non-scientific reason that people refuse to use formula, is assumption. People assume that formula is inferior because it is not natural, and yet gay parents, adoptive parents, and single parents are still able to raise healthy children. The formula vs. breast milk debate may not be as controversial as vaccination, but the feud has got to end. Being a parent is already a difficult job and stigmatized one another…

    • 1032 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mothers and parents should cherish the time they have with the special gift sent from God, and some might ask: if a baby is going to be brain dead or not be able to walk or talk, death is better than them suffering each and every day and being made fun of, is it not? Absolutely not; any women who know ahead of time if something is going to be wrong with their baby, should not have the final say so over whether they can abort their baby or not, and no one should say that decision would be okay. Doctors and physicians should offer advice about clinics and therapies that could help once the baby arrived. Nothing is more selfish than a woman who will not give up for her own baby; those who believe in abortion obviously have no morals and concepts on how important a potential life can and will be. Babies are beautiful, and all deserve a chance at life.…

    • 1531 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I never knew that Californians had limited the legal marriage pertaining to man and woman. A few other new things I had learned was that the Supreme Court ousted the conservative election in 2010 and that the first pregnant man on Opera. Female to male transgender had given birth to a baby. And also a sperm female embryo cells. Biological and social mother has to do with co-mothering type.…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays