Kant's Morality Of Lying

Good Essays
For Kant, lying is always wrong. It does not matter the situation someone is, as long as someone does the right thing for the sake of duty. However, there are paternalistic lies, which are lies that human being uses for protecting other people’s lives. Kant thinks if we do so, we are taking away their human rights. He says that lying affects our “intrinsic worth”, would threat people as a mean and not as an end, and would hurt people’s feeling. First, each person is born with “intrinsic worth”. A person is capable to make his or her own choices. In any case, if someone pretends to save one’s life, he or she says a paternalistic lie because they are protecting him or her. However, if we do the right things for the sake of duty, we are going …show more content…
So, in order to be moral, we have to respect the other person’ life. Our actions and decisions can be considered whether they are moral or not. By reasoning, we can identity the limits of understanding any particular situation and respect opinions or decisions. Utilitarian says that lying is right as long as it benefits the most number of people; Kantians, lying is always wrong. For example: a very young girl gets pregnant, and she is deciding either abort or not. She thinks that she has to take care of the baby, stop studying for a while, moved out to another house because of her parents would kick her out. She finally decides that she is going to abort no matter what. She did it and tells her mom that she will be on vacation for a week. She never told her boyfriend that she was pregnant. For Kant, she is not being moral because she is not protecting the baby’s feeling and her parents’ feelings. The baby is not born yet, and has the right because the baby is a life. Even if her parents get mad, she could have handled that for herself along with her boyfriend. Furthermore, she is not counting her boyfriend’s feelings as well. She is choosing for herself. Yet, she is not thinking rationally and lies to everyone just to “protect the baby, parents, and boyfriend’s feeling” and they do not get worried, but she is not doing

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    It is better to be benevolent than to be truthful and abrasive. All in all, lying is a factor that makes us all humans, whether the lies are bad or good. We are not perfect, but the art of lying can be perfected and should be if it is being practiced. Still, lying should not be an option because it hurts others. Both Twain and Ericsson are right about their perspectives on lying because lying is bad as Ericsson reminds us.…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Half-truths are lies– In connection with the second application is the use of half-truths. Half-truths are distorted truths, making them a lie. It doesn’t matter what your end goal is, never use shortcuts when telling the truth. 4. Be truthful to yourself – People, when consumed by their desire to feel happiness, resort to rationalization, denial or repression when in stressful situations.…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This law prescribes that rational, autonomous agents should only perform actions that would maintain their function if adopted universally. If one were to tell a lie, they would be conforming to the rule that “Lying is acceptable.” Such a rule would prove to be self-defeating in the context of universality; lying would lose its purpose since everyone would expect deceit and be cynical of one another. As a result, Kant argues, lying should never be acceptable. One may be inclined to argue that rules should have exceptions and specific circumstances of forgiveness. A rule that states, “Lying is acceptable when one is lying in order to save a life,” may pass the universality test without contradiction.…

    • 1554 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Remy had never noticed there was a distance between her and her mother until her fight with Don. It established the fact that even though her marriages have never been successful, Remy’s mother chooses her husbands over her own daughter. Her mother’s five, unsuccessful marriages taught Remy that love does not exist and she has commitment issues because she was never shown a lasting relationship. This belief that love does not exist or last causes Remy to have a negative and cynical belief in relationships. This is why her boyfriends have “expiration dates”; Remy goes into a relationship knowing she will give “The Speech” to slow down the relationship, then sleeps with them, and then reasons with herself that it’s time to end it (135).…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Essay On Right To Lie

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Honesty and transparency to ourselves and the society cannot be tolerated just as lying. From an ethical point of view, the right to lie does not exist and should not be established since it interferes with the essential element of human dignity i.e. self-worth. The arguments raised by proponents of the right to lie seem to suggest that lying should be justifiable in certain situations and not others depending on the objective. If the right to lie is established based on proponents’ arguments, it can be easily manipulated to contribute to increased unethical behaviors in the society and cause harm on individuals.…

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Ericsson believes that lying is immoral, but everyone does it. She implies that it is justified to lie at times, but that it should not get out of hand (Ericsson 160). Nietzsche would agree with Ericsson because he believes that truth is relative to what a person believes, and that whether or not to participate in immoral acts is a decision that people make with their own free will (Nietzche 355). Lying is immoral, but can be justified at…

    • 1018 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If they thought that these were acceptable actions then they would not deceive their loved one about what happened that day. In similar situations cheating has ended badly for all which is proof that this encounter was unethical and would lead to bad results. Society’s impact on what is viewed as socially acceptable or the social norm can be seen to play an important role. All in all I believe that the encounter was unethical based on reasons previously found in both Rule Utilitarianism and Kantians Ethics of Duty…

    • 1309 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Kant Happiness

    • 1519 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Kant believes that lying is inherently wrong. If looked at from a universal point of view, lying is detrimental to society. If everyone were to lie, we would not be able to trust anyone. To Kant, to allow lying in any scenario is to allow it in all scenarios, which is unjust. With all this being said, Kant holds that sometimes lying can be the correct action to take, that sometimes the correct thing to do is unjust.…

    • 1519 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Her role as a mother is nowhere to be found. A mother is supposed to be caring and honest with their loved ones, but she fails to do both. Because of this, it harms the family to be in the state that they are. She wants stay out of trouble, so she ignores all family matters. In the story it said the mother knew all along that Liam was transgender.…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If a person believes that they are nice person, but they go around and perform mean actions then some existentialists would say that they are mean person based on the actions they performed. There are no good or bad situations. Overall, Kant would not be okay with a person lying because it would create the opportunity that it is okay for everyone to lie. Mill would be okay with a simple white lie because someone other than yourself is benefited from it, but Mill would not be okay with a big lie. Sarte’s views align with Mill and Kant by simply saying based on what we do, we determine how humans are supposed to…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays