Johnson's Conception Of Meaning

Superior Essays
Johnson supports his argument that our understanding of meaning is debilitatingly limited without accounting for the embodied experience of the world by examining five ways that the body engages in it: biologically, ecologically, phenomenologically, socially and culturally. Positing that the body is actively intrinsic to all these areas of life, Johnson reveals through these levels of functioning the ways that it is ‘more than a lump of pulsating flesh” (275). As I made my own ‘conscious effort to change how my mind worked’ through meditation, I experienced changes in my life that relate to many of Johnson’s following categories of embodiment.
1. The body as a biological organism – Describing the body as the “…principal locus” of our “being-in-the-world” from which “(our) world extends out from”, Johnson discusses the intricate coordination of biological systems that provide the palette for all experiences from which we infer meaning in life. Referring to Putnam’s ‘brain in a vat’ hypothesis, Johnson states that beyond the brain and nervous system, it is our “… body-in-interaction-with-our-world that defines human meaning, reference and truth” (275-6). Science supports
…show more content…
To my mind at the time, the idea of eating raw fish was hilariously bizarre. Almost as bizarre was the practice of yoga that I started noticing, which was embarrassing to watch from my repressed, Canadian perspective. Years passed, and eventually I found myself loving sushi and doing a lot of yoga. Both of these cultural practices that were grafted into my Canadian life expanded my world in different, tangible ways. Sushi provided an increased intake of Omega 3’s in my diet and a more adventurous palate; yoga opened my world up to physical flexibility that coincided with a attitudal flexibility that only increased when I started practicing its counterpart,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In this paper I will argue Cartesian dualism offers a more rational explanation of reality than Darwinian monism. I believe people have both body and soul, and they interact with each other. Jonathan Haidt described the relationship between body and soul as “like a rider on the back of an elephant”(11) in his book “The Happiness Hypothesis”. Our body like an elephant, our soul like a rider on it’s back and try to control it. But the problem is that the soul is not always a good rider.…

    • 423 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In your essay, you reflected on Dr. Winston’s idea that meaning is not a concrete thing that everyone shares and that we can never pass on one individual’s meaning in its entirety to another individual. I was talking about this idea just yesterday with an interpreter who used to work at a school for the Deaf but now teaches in a public high school. She compared it to one of the new Common Core standards that requires students to look at a key idea in two different artistic mediums (literature, painting, sculpture, music, etc.) and analyze what is being emphasized or absent in each medium. She said that as we interpret we are making choices about what to emphasize and what to leave out.…

    • 182 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Bodies that Matter Judith Butler replies to the criticism of her earlier book Gender Trouble. She argues with the feminist thinkers who see the body as matter--a material body with a sexual specification. According to her the body does not exist beyond a cultural construction. It serves as a site for the feminist theory independently of such a pre-discursive definition. In her introduction she explains: For surely bodies live and die; eat and sleep; feel pain, pleasure; endure illness and violence; and these “facts,” one might skeptically proclaim, cannot be dismissed as mere construction.…

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are two parts of every person, the part that you can see, the parts of themselves that they let out for the outside world and the part you cannot see, the things people keep to themselves. This sets up the two parts of human beings the body, which is physical, the thing that we can see and what ties us to the world around us and the mind, which we can not see, and is intangible. When it comes to our perceptions of other human beings we know they have bodies too, but we have no real way of knowing whether or not they really possess a mind. There is a disconnect between people and their mind and other people and their mind because their two minds cannot interact, they can only interact between the physical, what comes out of the mind and…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In other words, we are as much individuals through our own experiences and senses as we are a product of society through our thoughts. Finally, the body and soul are separate entities- the body profane and the soul sacred. The body experiences the world through senses whiles the soul recognizes what is right and wrong. Although they are two parts of human nature they contradict one another because the soul can exist without the body; the soul is what separates one from…

    • 2171 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dualism vs. Materialism The debate of mind and body was a serious subject to the philosophers of primitive times. There are several theories which have attempted to justify their perception in this regard. One of them is the theory of dualism by Descartes while the one totally negating is Churchland’s theory of Materialism. Churchland’s theory sounds much more believable and justified in the advanced era.…

    • 875 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The mind and body have been studied throughout time both in conjunction and individually. Ancient philosophies such as Plato’s (Silverman, 2013) viewed the body as temporary where as the mind was from another world therefore being able to transport. This means that the two were only united until the death or decay of the body and because the mind was from another world, it was the only thing capable of viewing universal truths. These philosophies are still being represented in 20th century literature. However, thanks to the development of both society and technology these ancient philosophies are being challenged in the way that more recent works of literature are viewing the body as either equally or even more powerful than the mind.…

    • 1497 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Relieving Tensions through Unconventional Methods Mehmet Oz once declared “What happens when you have great grief in your life is the arteries of that heart begins to spasms down, just literally squeezes down like this because you’re feeling the tension of your life and then the heart muscle itself also begin- to get stressed out.” While my mind was more attentive and energized due to the continuous use of my meditation regime, my body still experienced tensions and soreness. As discussed in my last paper, I mediated every Saturday, to the sound of a grandfather clock, as a way of being in the moment and calming down. Meditation proved to be enjoyful and beneficial, but the soreness also proved to be a distraction, thus I opted to employ a different method for coping.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Empiricism Vs Dualism

    • 2134 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The nature of the mind in relation to the body is a widely debated and unsolved topic that has plagued the human quest for truth. The question has deep philosophical roots and has several titles, for example, the mind-body problem, mind-body interaction problem, or the hard problem of consciousness. Prima facie, the question may appear unnecessary as we ourselves obviously have minds, and we can physically feel and experience the world around us. Descartes famously stepped up the game on this question with his Meditations’. He broke down the empiricist approach to knowledge, that all knowledge is gained from experience, and showed that we cannot trust our senses and our perceptions of the world.…

    • 2134 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An ongoing problem presented in philosophy is the question of whether our bodies have a separate entity lurking inside them--controlling and being controlled by it. This question is called the mind-body problem. Many philosophers across time have struggled with the question of where the mind resides. While some believe in physicalism, holding the view that everything that exists is no more extensive than its physical properties, others are convinced there are some parts of the human experience that cannot be reduced to our physical brains/physical processes. In this paper I will make a case for the dual aspect theory, evaluate it using Churchland’s arguments, then explain why I believe the dual aspect theory is correct.…

    • 953 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The philosophical debate as to whether the human mind is a purely physical substance or a non-physical substance is an argument that has been around for centuries. Philosophers around the world have formulated a multitude of responses to the debacle, but none of the arguments have been universally accepted at this time. The debate has two main viewpoints. The first being the monistic view of the mind-body problem where the mind is a non-physical substance and the second being the dualism view of physicalism where the mind is a physical substance (Herrick). In this paper, I will favor and argue for the view that the mind is non-physical substance.…

    • 1122 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fish Consumption Improve Body Functions and Emotional Stability Lastly, eating fish can help to improve body functions and emotional stability. Intake of fish regularly, helps to protect and maintains the function of human’s organ such as brains, eyes, skins and hairs. As time goes on, man continues to grow and becoming old. Organs in the body also grew older and the function of the organs such as the eyes and brain started to deteriorate.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Embodied cognition is the possibility of unification of neural networks in our brain and direct interaction with the physical world. The body contains, regulates, and shapes the nature of mental activity. Arthur Glenberg argues that our brains guide the body for interacting with the social world (1). When a situation arises, one must analyze and produce a solution given the abilities that the body can perform. For example, when a human is threatened by violence, they do not have a shell to shrink into for protection, whereas a turtle has a hard shell that can protect against most predators.…

    • 1409 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Writer Franz Kafka is widely known for his deeply philosophical and existentially conflicting stories. While many of his works make it difficult to identify a singular theme, many of them revolve around the concept of the mind and the body and the relationship between the two. Some of his most famous short works, including “The Metamorphosis,” “A Hunger Artist,” and “In the Penal Colony,” portrays characters who are stuck in between fulfilling their spiritual wants and answering to their bodily needs. Despite generally nightmarish occurrences and events, a theme of how one’s spirituality transcends his bodily concerns can be identify in these short stories. By including a theme of mind versus body, Kafka’s works supports the existentialist…

    • 2038 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Looking at somatic psychology from a structural level, somatic psychology is uniquely positioned to offer an understanding of the way in which an individual adjusts as a ‘normal citizen’ and how this contributes to the reproduction of the cultural and socioeconomic system within which he or she becomes adjusted (Johnson, 2009). When we conform to prohibitions and inhibitions dictated by our culture, this requires a loss of attention to the voice of our embodied experience. This is where somatic psychology, through the practice of becoming aware of our embodied experience, may have revolutionary potential. The way in which these prohibitions and inhibitions show up throughout our embodiment appear as blockages to the free-flow of energy (Johnson,…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays