John Ford's Inaccuracies In The Searchers

Improved Essays
Tom Colonnes, a Santee Sioux, feels that John Ford’s The Searchers was one of the first films to actually provide a counter argument to the traditional white hero westerns common in the 1950’s. Mr. Louis Owens, a novelist who is part Choctaw and Cherokee, also “believes it is the best Indian movie ever made” (335). The Searchers demonstrates that the whites were actually the aggressors, and how the protagonist was so beset with racism and rage, he was willing to kill his niece rather than see her live with the Comanches. Nevertheless, John Ford’s film also contains numerous inaccuracies; such as the generic Indians…who wore Hollywood costumes rather than traditional garb and spoke Navajo, despite being depicted as Commanches (340). Furthermore,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The West is romanticized in a manner that creates a stereotype that exemplifies the idea of cowboys and Indians. In addition, these images deliver the story of changing roles and adaptation to new circumstances while seamlessly integrating the relationship between diverse cultures. Beginning with the earliest piece (Lost in a Snowstorm-We Are Friends, Charles Russell, 1888) an encounter between cowboys and Indians lost in a snowstorm illustrates the…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It was a widely held belief that the frontier was open for the taking. A belief not only incorrect, but simply one of ignorance. Everell Flecher’s youthful imagination and inaccurate education in Hope Leslie is fractured and set straight by a single story. He learns from Magawisca, a captive Native American, that the frontier is made up of false images and stories and thus it has become this “imaginal place” (Schneekloth 210). Young Flecher was so caught up in what he thought was right that, when he learned the truth, it vexed him so much that he cried.…

    • 1949 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In her article “A Sea of Good Intentions: Native Americans in Books for Children”, Melissa Kay Thompson argues that several institutions use power to display demeaning stereotypes of Native Americans and use those stereotypes in children’s books to further diminish the Native American culture. Thompson begins by stating that many of the children’s novels that portray the lives of Native Americans have a subliminal message which is white dominance and Indian savagery. Furthermore, the author discusses three types of novels that have good intentions to share the Native American culture but, make several contradictions by disregarding historical facts. The three types of novels that lack factual historical context are “Perils-on-the-frontier stories,…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The whites are against the Indians because of their beliefs. In the whites’ eyes, all Indians do is steal, scalp, kidnap, and murder. In comparison, in the Indians eyes, all the whites do is steal their land, kill their people, and cheat them of their belongings. This story displays both sides evenly; Richter explains and gives supportive evidence towards whites hating Indians, and vice versa.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Outwardly, the film appeared to be racist due to the historically inaccurate Indian costumes, the white Indian chief aka. Scar (Henry Brandon), and Ethan’s dominating presence, but the overall message of the film defines the unethical and immoral massacre of Indians in the settling of the west. Ethan’s racist as a former Confederate solider defines the underlying theme of hatred and violence that took the form of a genocidal vengeance against Scar and the Comanche tribe. More so, it defines the cruel nature of racial purity that Ethan pursues in denying the humanity of Martin and Debbie (in a cultural manner) as Native Americans. The Searchers portrays the ugliness of racism and the hateful spirit of vengeance that is embodied in Ethan’s central role in the film.…

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Cowboys and Indians: The United States and the Lasting Legacy of its History of Conquest Ned Blackhawk is a Western Shoshone professor of history and American studies at Yale University. His works have focused primarily on post-Columbian Native American history. Within his work, Blackhawk has argued that ‘the history of conquest has an important though largely ignored legacy in the modern United States’. This essay will be an analytical evaluation of the validity and implications of that argument from a historical perspective. This central argument of this essay is that the legacy of the United States’ history of conquest can be seen on a political, sociological and culture level in the modern United States.…

    • 1683 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Reel Injun Analysis

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The scenes with Russell Means, a native of Pine Ridge Indian Reservation, and John Trudell, a native of the Santee Dakota, show an interesting perspective into how the extreme poverty and corrupt politics still factor into daily South Dakota Native American life today (Diamond, "Reel Injun"). These interviews with the two men could be used to supplement a speech portion of an English Language Arts class. The students could look for ways the men are arguing for a change in Hollywood and in America at large. The “Incident at Wounded Knee” in 1973 could also be used as a topic for debate by bringing up the history of the “Wounded Knee Massacre”, other historical background from both sides, and the attention Marlon Brando helped Sacheen Littlefeather (Diamond, "Reel Injun"). The students could argue whether or not Sacheen should have done what she did and whether or not…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For decades, non-native writers, filmmakers, and artists have continually portrayed native people as noble warriors or hostiles savages. “This noble savage will help the main character achieve his goals rather than achieving his own wants and desires. The hostile savage, on the other hand, is out to thwart the main protagonist and his dreams.” ( Kiyawasew,…

    • 1122 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    James Fenimore Cooper

    • 424 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The venerable images of Indians were learned from other white writers. In the novel “Last of the Mohican, cooper personified good and bad by tribe and individual. For example Uncas and his father Chingachgook and the evil Magua. In the book, he characterizes them in two group, one is the noble savages and the other the ignoble savages. In addition, writing about he Indians was not something he wanted for himself but a competition against another writer “he bet his wife that he could write a better novel than the British novel” (Baym, 483).…

    • 424 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article explains the various mistreat that Indians received from the Americans, at first Indians were considered to be “white” because they had a similar appearance to the Europeans. With time that idea had changed and instead reflected that they were defined as “children’’ or “savages”. The main fear that the country has always had is the fear of the unknown, “in 1892 ceremonial behavior was misunderstood and suppressed” (Rothenberg, 2014: 503). Indians were forcibly stripped from their origins and were being left with no land, no identity, and no respect. The documentary Race: The Power of an Illusion: The Story we Tell,…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    For generations thousands of North Americans have grown up watching old classic western films of the “Indian and cowboy”. Such films portray the wise elder from the film Little Big Man, the drunk in Tom Sawyer’s films, the breath taking Indian princess from Pocahontas, and who can’t forget about the loyal sidekick Tonto from the Lone Ranger. It is these iconic films that have shaped the public’s perspective of Aboriginals and has even affected the Aboriginals perspective of themselves. These films have reinforced the notion that Aboriginal only exist in the past forever chasing Buffalo or forever being chased and killed by the cavalry. These films have created false and romanticized stereotypes of the Aboriginals.…

    • 2238 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cultural discrepancies always play a role when it comes to conflicts. For example, language act as a barrier when trying to get ideas across and are often at the root of all miscommunications. Excluding background differences, all people are human. They feel, they cry, they tend and they’re especially prone to mistakes and hypocrisy.…

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Dear John Wayne” by Louise Erdrich, it becomes obvious to the reader that Erdrich feels as if Native Americans, such as herself, are inferior to the entire white population. Throughout her poem, Erdrich expresses her opinions and the actions of white people like “John Wayne.” The message she sends to the reader brings attention to the display of Native Americans. Erdrich strives to express her opinion that the media displays Native Americans in an insignificant fashion and that the media believes their worth is inconspicuous. First of all, Erdrich’s use of John Wayne indicates additional information than just the importance of his movies and the drive-in.…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Little Big Man challenges typical American narratives of history through the inclusion of numerous Natives American characters with multidimensional roles in order to help promote the idea that they were merely the victims by European settlers during the colonial days, the real “savages.” The film’s main character, a white man who plays plays the role of both a European settler and a disguised Native, helps expose the brutal realities of the frontier, by his own people against the Natives who take him in at a young age and treat him as one of their own, despite stereotypes that depict them as ‘uncivilized.” The film posits the Natives in a positive light despite their usual depiction as “savages,” the aggressors, and perpetrators of violence,…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In My Darling Clementine, the drunken Indian is expulsed the town that leads to Wyatt obtain the Marshal’s job. Despite the duty of Marshal to some extent represents the relative high moral stature than other, the prejudices of Native Indian disclose the historical phenomena in real life. In this context, the phenomena represents the existing cultural and religious values hold by American White towards Indian that is the sentimental symbol of ‘anti-humanism’. Indian is the sign of evil, wildness and in danger in Ford’s films, while this also discloses American’s fear and doubts upon the savages. Meanwhile, the combat between Wyatt and Indian emphasizes the image of warrior of Wyatt against wildness in white traditions.…

    • 1609 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays