Joan Brumberg's The Body Project

Improved Essays
In Joan Brumberg’s book The Body Project: An Intimate History of American Girls, she examines the familial, cultural, and institutional forces that played a significant role in shaping women’s bodies and attitudes and uses historical evidence to illustrate them. In the nineteenth-century, one’s morality was the hub of adolescence. (Brumberg xx). Mothers took initiative into instructing their daughters on how to properly groom and dress themselves. Society also discouraged women from discussing bodily concerns with anybody, since that kind of behavior was considered indecent (Brumberg xix). This made adolescent girls keep their concerns personal - rather, they recorded their worries and/or accomplishments in their diaries. By the turn of the …show more content…
Brumberg argues that although women have more freedom over their bodies, historical changes have put them at risk due to biological, cultural, and societal changes of the female body throughout history (xviii-xv). Brumberg theorizes in her book that the “stunning freedoms” that modern women enjoyed in the beginning of the nineteenth-century came with a cultural demand that they learn to control their bodies, which only intensified and became more powerful by the end of the twentieth century.
Brumberg argues that familial forces caused women to agonize over their skin because cultural and societal norms that required women to have smooth skin was institutionalized since the nineteenth-century (1997, p. 61). Victorian society viewed the skin as a marker of one’s moral life - generally, adolescents who had acne were accused of being engaged in sexual behaviors like masturbation (Brumberg 1997, p. 63-4). In turn, this notion aroused suspicion within middle-class families. Acne was also connected to various skin diseases like smallpox and tuberculosis. Although Victorian physicians recalled those beliefs by the end of the

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    The mid twentieth century was a defining moment in American history-particularly with respect to the securing of ladies' rights. While the period was thought to be prosperous and later idea to be a cheerful time, in reality, it was a period of grave social clash and human enduring (Parish, 110). Among the individuals who persevered through much enduring were ladies. As Margaret Sanger discovered, ladies, particularly the individuals who were poor, had no way out with respect to pregnancy. The main route not to get pregnant was by not having intercourse a decision that was quite often the husband's.…

    • 1591 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Great Gatsby The Great Gatsby, written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, is a great American novel shadowing the lives of several mysterious, but stereotypical characters. Daisy Buchanan, Jordan Baker, and Myrtle Wilson all play a significant role in The Great Gatsby, specifically because they are women whose characteristics set a sense of change for other women in society. The Great Gatsby takes place during the summer of 1922, which was two years after women gain the right to vote. This promoted the idea that society should move away from traditional gender roles; which is exactly what Fitzgerald portrayed in his book. Throughout history, women have been under the influence of men having the upper hand in society.…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Private and business life clearly intertwined for the Mann-Simos; now, we turn to defining the second component of the jar’s cultural biography: the family members themselves.. The Mann-Simons were a black middle class family who lived on the evolving property at the corner of Richland and Marion Street for more than 100 years. Celia Mann, a freed slave and midwife, first moved onto the property with her husband in 1843. Generation after generation, the family worked tirelessly to shape businesses and build their home (see Fig. 3). That hard work placed them in a uniquely liminal position: economically and socially, they were better off than their black friends and neighbors.…

    • 946 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Micheaux Ferdinand Reflective Essay #3 Brodsky SOC 333 Women, in Western Society, are culturally raised to view their bodies as a project to be worked on, however, this viewpoint can be dissected into two different arguments. By describing their bodies as a “project”, one can interpret that the body of female is being objectified and further the oppression of women by forcing them to take certain daily rituals, that waste time and money, to further the ideal of the “male gaze”. The opposing argument could be that teaching women to work on themselves can both allow them to express themselves, and help them become the best person they could be in life. Both of these arguments have valid reasons in the social and cultural history of the Western…

    • 942 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In today’s culture, there is a cloud that simmers over teenage girls; this cloud is called body image, it lingers and constantly pressures girls into thinking that they need to attain a “standard” weight and have a “certain” body type to be appealing to society. One contributing factor is the media; it has poisoned the minds of our generation and now the damage seems to be irreversible. Girls are constantly bombarded with ads that tell girls they need to groom, get that bikini wax, buy this facial, have this hair style, buy the latest clothes and keep that weight down. The list goes on and on, the focus isn’t on the products anymore it’s on shaming girls into buying products in hopes of attaining that model figure. Although she successfully uses pathos to show how girls have been manipulated and succumbed to society's view of body image in her article, “From Girl's bodies, Girls selves”, Elline Lipkin fails to strengthen her argument by discarding the opposing view points forcing the reader into a one sided opinionated…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Sexual attitudes have changed tremendously throughout history. In the 19th century women were seen as inferior individuals and did not equal up to the status of a man. Education and beauty did not at all matter to the superior sex of males. Women’s roles, economic status, and social status were all dominated by the male society. Silence lingered among women during the 19th century.…

    • 2567 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Questions for “Hunger as Ideology” 1. What’s Bordo’s criticism/analysis of the FiberThin ad? Bordo’s first criticism is of the romanticisation of low-weight management in young girls. Bordo’s second criticism is of the glorification of women having a blasé attitude toward foods.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “The Making of America’s Beauty Culture” by Kathy Peiss, and in the anthology of pieces commenting on the modern youth of the 1920s, the authors examine of the substantial cultural shifts taking place in the early twentieth century, hallmarked by the shift from Victorianism to Modernity. The 1920s sparked the mass influence of cosmetics and self-conceptions, and the radical change in sexual ideologies and morals, a revolutionary take on the meaning of freedom. In Peiss’s piece, she address the progressive acceptance of cosmetics, and their psychological, economic, sociological effects over time. The irreparable damage done by the beauty industry to women’s self-esteems through the ages is chronicled in her work, and she does recognize the positive effects of the industry as well mentioning the role of cosmetics in fulfilling fantasies. The anthology of works both criticize and applaud the modern yearning for freedom through the denial of antecedent schools of thought through “radical” sexual behaviors and decorum.…

    • 1365 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Prompt title: “Seeing Eye to Body: The Literal Objectification of Women” Prompt authors: Nathan A. Heflick and Jamie L. Goldenberg The main point of this article is that women are often objectified due to having their bodies sexualized. This objectification leads to women acting sort of like objects because they self-objectify themselves, meaning that they are focused on changing themselves, or how they look, instead of focusing on how they are mentally. These objectifications can be due to the way they appear physically. Due to this objectification, women are perceived as being less human, meaning that they do not have the same characteristics as people such as: warmth, capability and ethics.…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout the colonial period, various broad stereotypes have emerged of women. With different struggles and obstacles to overcome, each woman is unique to the individual. This identity of a unified or singular group with a single set of interests and goals is an idea we have to move away from. A mired of different experiences have shaped the “women’s” experience of the colonial period.…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Introduction to Beyond the Natural Body” written by Nelly Oudshoorn and “The egg and the Sperm” written by Emily both emphasize the idea of a woman’s body being examined through a social construct instead of a science classification. In the 1970’s, the female body was explained in terms of how the male body was perceived, for example: in texts written by the Ancient Greeks would refer the female genitals, the ovaries as the “female testicle”, as it used the male organs to lead every description. The illustrations that were shown of the female genitalia very closely resembled the male penis and someone could believe that there really is no difference between the two genders, as they were trying to make it the “one-sex model” (Laquer 1990).…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In "The Story of My Body" Judith Cofer recounts significant life moments similarly to how society picked her apart, attribute by attribute. Cofer 's body image was criticized due to societal values, image standards, and cultural differences, thus giving her a different perception of the world as a whole. Moving from Puerto Rico to the United States caused Cofer to view herself in a different light, due to the difference of image values in the two countries. The American society places a high value on looks and physical appearance. While criticizing appearance seems extremely American, it happens across all cultures but different attributes have a different value.…

    • 1259 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    These insecurities constantly immersed women in a concern that they would not be valuable enough for their husband. Creating these distortions in body image was the reason “natural beauty became displaced by artificial beauty” (Hansen & Reed, 1986, p. 63). The outcome of this adaption held the place that “individuals were made to become emotionally vulnerable, constantly monitoring themselves for bodily imperfections which could no longer be regarded as natural” (Featherstone, 1982, p. 20). A paradigm of this drastic outlook on body image was in the Victorian era, when women had corsets synched to their waists, so that they gave the illusion of having an immaculate hourglass figure. Women were defined by the dimensions of their compressed waist and proportionate figure.…

    • 1555 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The rise of new forms of sexual control stemmed from a cultural shift that was occurring throughout the nineteenth century in America. This shift was the rise of the middle class— a small part of the population defined by the privacy of the home and principles such as the importance of childrearing and sobriety. The middle class held significantly different values from the ones afforded to the working class and the sharp contrast between the classes led to new sexual authorities creating definitions of sexuality based on status. The advent of public versus private spheres also characterized this time and the ideal of sexual privacy led to the creation of the “natural woman,” a view that to be womanly is to be chaste. Between 1860 and 1930,…

    • 1665 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this article, becoming a Gendered Body by Karin A. Martin, the social problem being researched is how bodily differences are constructed. The idea investigated are how gender differences and bodily differences throughout school, could possibly be the beginning of gender inequality. Observing the practices that take place in not only the school curriculum, but the physical instructions in and out of the classroom. These actions appear to have the ability to shape young children into their expected societal gender roles. Our bodies are a large part of non-verbal communication the way we walk, talk, hold ourselves reflect in ways we may not imagine.…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays