Jefferson Davis And Frederick Douglass Essay

Improved Essays
Fix These Problems

Slavery was one of the biggest struggles faced by the United States, tearing the country in half between those who oppose it, and those who support it.
There was many conflicts about slavery back in 1860 when both these documents were written.
The rights of citizens is more broad than the rights of the states as a whole.
The north and south had completely different ideas on how the united states should be run.
With the southerns seeing the slaves as property they believed it was that the Constitution gives them a right to property.
“All men are created equal” as written in the Constitution, but apparently people didn’t think that before the Civil War, and even after.
The government has the power to ignore the Constitution
…show more content…
The powers of government were debated often in the 1860s, as an example, whether the government could interfere with slavery?
Now the real problem came up, how to the conflict.
Both of these selections were written by good authors, and both had very good audience throughout their documents. Jefferson Davis and Frederick Douglass were both men that had their own perspectives and views on slavery, and while both had good points in their arguments, they both also had their faults, which made them human.
Starting from when America was still the 13 Colonies under the rule of Great Britain, slavery still existed until the 1800’s when President Lincoln signed the Emancipation Proclamation declaring all slaves to be freed.
However, before the war, there were many debates on the morality of slavery and whether or Constitution supported this practice.
Being a plantation owner in Mississippi, slaves was part of the defintion of “property” since they were owned by someone.
He saw it as an overstepping of it’s power by making decisions no in their power.
People have disagreed on how government should be ran since the birth of this
…show more content…
So why did we own people?
Douglass expresses his views on slavery both through legal matters and human morals through his writings that became increasingly widespread and famous through his lifetime, and after.
With property being slaves and their families on the plantations.
Douglass was an ex-slave, and also felt the pressure of being a black man in a slavery-ran world, and spoke about how black people were not property and that slavery was only Constitutional because slave owners had bent it that way.
Douglass felt that is was very contradicting to the Constitution.
The two documents point out the power of the government and slavery, but as clear as day anyone can see that they are both for the fact that one is 100% against slavery and the other thinks that it is a right to protect their property.
Slavery completely overlooked the Constitution by turning man into “property” that can be owned.
However, the southerners believed that all slaves were property and the Constitution states all men are entitled to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    After The Civil War ended, he lived to see his vision filled. Being one of the most influential abolitionists, Garrison was able to go against the common belief and changed history. In the horrible time of slavery, the United States of America was split into two different views about slavery. The North, was mostly anti-slavery and wanted to abolish slavery of African-Americans, while the South was pro-slavery and wanted the way of life to not change. After the Missouri Compromise of 1820, the US was split in half on the amount of slave-states, which permitted slavery, and free-states, which were closed to slavery.…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The new constitution that confederate formed had put it to rest, everything relating to black people rights. The status of black people was of a slave in the new constitution. The confederate would never treat black people equal, rather they were property to be owned. Stephens believed that “the Northerners were attempting to make things equal which the Creator had made unequal. (1)” Stephens believed that Union wants to topple the natural order which places Negro as subordinates and slave to white people.…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The same white Southerners were the ones that claimed that the "Northerners had betrayed the Compromise and the Constitution" (Roark 363). This shows how Douglass is correct about the Southern whites claiming that slavery is mandatory in the Constitution and other national acts. As Douglass states, slavery is not a part of the Constitution, but rather it is a part of the mindsets that the people follow more than the law itself. Similar to slavery in the eighteen-hundreds, the two-thousands has its own issue regarding, human trafficking. Human trafficking is the act of controlling another person to engage in commercial sex or soliciting labor against their will and without consent.…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the declaration of independence, Jefferson started by the fact that all humans are equal and should have the right of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. However, Jefferson’s beliefs in the necessity of slavery abolition were from a superior view that blacks and whites cannot peacefully live together (Christa). Thus, he died a slaves’ owner. Although Franklin grew up a slaves’ owner, trader, and promoter, he had lately come to believe in the blacks’ right of equality and started calling for the abolition of slavery. “Slavery is such an atrocious debasement of human nature, that its very extirpation, if not performed with solicitous care, may sometimes open a source of serious evils (Franklin).” Franklin also believed that black people have the ability to learn the same as the whites and therefore they should have the opportunity for education.…

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This book, which was a nearly immediate bestseller, had a huge impact on how Northerners viewed slavery. It opened their eyes to the harshness and inhumanity of slavery in the South. There was also the Dred Scott Case where the verdict declared that Dred Scott, who was held a slave in a free state, did not have the right to be a free man. One of the last events that transpired before the secession of the Confederacy, was the election of Abraham Lincoln as president. South Carolina was the first state to secede, which was then followed by six other states.…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    African Americans have had it hard ever since we arrived to the New World that we now call the Americas; we have been abused and demeaned beyond despair. For centuries, we have been fighting to be treated as we deserved, but laws along with intimidation in addition to everything else harmful to African Americans were set forth to keep them from advancing as a whole. Fast forward to the president election of 1860: Stephen Douglass vs Abraham Lincoln. Although some businesses up North benefitted from slavery, owning slaves and running a plantation meant having wealth and power down South; the South’s economy depended on slaves to thrive. During the election, Lincoln promised not to abolish slavery, but to keep slavery from spreading to the US territory.…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The topic I chose to analyze from the book Taking Sides is rather the Civil War fought over slavery. This issue occurred in the 18th century and impacted black slaves and whites across the United States. Prior to the Civil War in the southern states (which declared themselves as the Confederate states when they separated from the United States) there were lands that included laborious work and the slaves would do the labor from sunup to sundown. The Confederate states desired to have more slave states and they declared secession from the United States. The Union noticed the Confederate states as a threat and a group of rebels who wanted more power but, the Union wanted balance and would continue to have power.…

    • 1928 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Finkleman expresses that Jefferson was always intensely dedicated to slavery and harbored hostility to blacks both free and enslaved. Furthermore they point out his actions of owning over six-hundred slaves which differed from his words that spoke of freedom and equality for all and emancipation. This essay looks at Jefferson’s hypocrisy, which was his morality set against politics in those times. Observing if he was actually an outright run of the mill racist like majority of whites were or was it merely his conforming to maneuvering alongside a backdrop of ever changing politics of colonization. Even though he played a big factor in supporting…

    • 1088 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Civil War Slavery

    • 1092 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Throughout American history the most horrific action was argued against and sought as a positive activity. Before the Civil War, there were many debates on the topic of slavery. As Northern abolitionist attacked slavery and an unjust event, white Southerners had to defend the attacks made on slavery from the North. The North’s economy was set up through industrial work, employed by many immigrant workers who were paid less than the average worker. While the South’s economy was based through agriculture work, employed by African American slaves.…

    • 1092 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, as the war escalated, there was a dilemma among the slaves. Should slaves fight for their same masters that held them in bondage or fight for the British who ask them to desert their master who mistreated them all their lives? Many blacks made their own judgement of the conflict and supported the side that benefitted them the most. Although the Declaration of Independence promised Liberty for all men, it did not include black men. So the relationship between the American Revolution and the black freedom was based on untapped manpower or in exchanged of a cowardly son.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays