Ladies and gentlemen of the Jury,
On January 13, 1999, Hae Min Lee looked forward to another eventful exciting day at Woodlawn High School. Sadly this was not any ordinary day when the afternoon came around and Hae went missing. This was undoubtedly a horrible tragedy but the evidence will strongly support that Adnan Syed is not guilty.
The state's main evidence will strongly depend on the claims of Jay Wilds a criminal and he is known to change his story multiple times. According to Jay's story Adnan planned this murder but this cannot be used as the only evidence to convict Adnan. Jay is a unstable unreliable source and this case is in his hand and dependent on his changing story. The detectives interview Jay and he says that no one would …show more content…
The biggest pieces of evidence of the state are they proven unreliable stories of Jay Wilds and this call. Nisha does not know Jay so Adnan must have called him while they were in the car according to Jay's story Adnan was in the car and not the library but there's one problem that Nisha repeatedly tells the police that she remembers a call talking to Jay and Adnan at the video store Jay worked at not in the car, she stresses multiple times that she cannot remember this call taking place. The other question is how did this call happen if Adnan was in the library how did this call happen. Adnan says he remembers her phone having a answering machine proving it could have simply been a but dial , but Nisha says she does not remember having one. If we think about this, who would know if there was an answering machine? Adnan who calls her frequently or Nisha because clearly she's not calling herself and Adnan is calling her so he would know if there was one or not. When was the last time you actually called yourself and heard your voicemail? Is it not more reasonable someone who calls you regularly would know more than
On January 13, 1999, Hae Min Lee looked forward to another eventful exciting day at Woodlawn High School. Sadly this was not any ordinary day when the afternoon came around and Hae went missing. This was undoubtedly a horrible tragedy but the evidence will strongly support that Adnan Syed is not guilty.
The state's main evidence will strongly depend on the claims of Jay Wilds a criminal and he is known to change his story multiple times. According to Jay's story Adnan planned this murder but this cannot be used as the only evidence to convict Adnan. Jay is a unstable unreliable source and this case is in his hand and dependent on his changing story. The detectives interview Jay and he says that no one would …show more content…
The biggest pieces of evidence of the state are they proven unreliable stories of Jay Wilds and this call. Nisha does not know Jay so Adnan must have called him while they were in the car according to Jay's story Adnan was in the car and not the library but there's one problem that Nisha repeatedly tells the police that she remembers a call talking to Jay and Adnan at the video store Jay worked at not in the car, she stresses multiple times that she cannot remember this call taking place. The other question is how did this call happen if Adnan was in the library how did this call happen. Adnan says he remembers her phone having a answering machine proving it could have simply been a but dial , but Nisha says she does not remember having one. If we think about this, who would know if there was an answering machine? Adnan who calls her frequently or Nisha because clearly she's not calling herself and Adnan is calling her so he would know if there was one or not. When was the last time you actually called yourself and heard your voicemail? Is it not more reasonable someone who calls you regularly would know more than