Manchu Girl Analysis

Improved Essays
Much like the way American media portrayed the occupation of Japan as a moral right by claiming that they were “liberating Japanese women” and creating a better Japanese society, Japanese literature produced during the prewar era similarly attempted to improve the Japanese attitude towards the state; people were given a role in the creation of national identity, with a particular focus on Japanese imperialism. In the postwar era, the literature that reflects the psychological effect of American occupation is evidence of the deep penetration of those prewar ideologies. By analyzing the way Japanese empire was portrayed in literary pieces aimed at children and women, as well as stories that illustrate the psychological toll of American occupation, …show more content…
In the story, the author’s husband justifies “buying” another Manchu girl (Guiyu) to be their helper by saying “by taking care of this child and helping her understand the proper viewpoints of Japanese through our way of living, isn’t this working for goodwill between Japanese and Manchu…?” In this way, not only are the Manchu people assumed to be backwards and ignorant, but through the constant help of Koizumi and her seemingly “motherly” nurturing of Guiyu, it becomes evident that the notion of “imperialist motherhood” was used to incorporate women into the goals of the nation. The author’s “bringing up” of Guiyu parallels with Japan’s imperialist motives in the “young, newborn nation” of Manchuria. By portraying Japanese imperialism under this pretense, a role for women becomes established. Although normally disintegrated from society, especially along the lines of political representation, women are gradually seeing themselves as being part of the nation and having an important place in its efforts from these texts. Kimberly T. Kono, in her response to the “Manchu Girl” story, writes that “motherhood represented one of the main avenues for Japanese women to perform loyalty to the nation and achieve recognition as national subjects.” Undoubtedly, …show more content…
Kyoko constantly nags Toshio, saying things like “you ought to go to America too,” and often boasts about the American life as described by the Higgins’ family. The constant comparisons Toshio makes between the Japan and American appearance, culture, and habits demonstrates the sense of inferiority that people felt in post-imperialist Japan. Nevertheless, as the arrival of the Higgins’ was inevitable, so was the presence of Americans in Japan. Because Toshio’s resentment towards Americans came from his own experiences with the war, it became further enhanced through the penetration of American culture after the war in the form of American hijiki, chewing gum, MJB coffee and so on. Ultimately, literary pieces like “Child of Okinawa” and “American hijiki” with their extremely sexualized and anti-American atmosphere, were able to effectively express the psychological loss of

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    a. Experimental group/pg. 132: the group of subjects in an experiment who are exposed to the independent variable. When watching China’s Lost Girls, it can be said that the whole documentary was focused around the study of American parents traveling across national borders in order to adopt Chinese baby girls. The causation for this ‘experiment’ could be traced to many different reasons; sterile parents who are unable to rear a biological child themselves, lonely married couples who have raised their own children already and want to do so again, or simply those families who want to add diversity and culture into their lives by way of a new Chinese female family member. Regardless of the causation, the soon-to-be parents are reaching out to…

    • 1872 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    What does it mean to be an American? How does pledging allegiance to America secure one’s civil protections under the law? Why does the federal government “lawfully choose” to encroach upon its citizens’ rights during times of war? The gripping novel, When the Emperor was Divine (2002), evinces a narrative about Japanese internment seldom told in historical accounts about World War II. Julie Otsuka recounts the story of a Japanese-American woman and her young children’s dogged journey to survive the horrid domestic policy consequences of war abroad.…

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Children did not only face these encounters in public places, but also at school where one is to feel safe and cared for. “Gee, I didn’t know you could speak English” (Page 113). The classmates of these Japanese children also believed that the Japanese race was inferior due to what they had acquired from their parents’ beliefs. This shows that by segregating the Japanese people in America, the offsprings suffer the most since the children of other races are taught by their parents to not socialize with other Japanese children. Both Japanese children and adults had faced many challenges due to their race which resulted to them feeling unsafe and…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In her essay “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior,” Amy Chua informs the readers of the Chinese way of raising a “stereotypically successful child.” The Chinese childrearing method forbids many activities, including having “playdates” and excelling in drama. Chua’s method is not only extreme but also counterproductive. Firstly, when Chua condescendingly refers to the time a child spends bonding with other children as “playdates,” she is ignoring the vital skill learned through these bonds, these personal connections, which can be advantageous in the professional world.…

    • 447 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Through the progression of the boy and his measures to cope to the trauma of incarceration, Julie Otsuka, author of When the Emperor was Divine, suggests a general basis of the emotions Japanese Americans have faced, as outlined by the Kübler-Ross model, or in other words, the five stages of grief. When the Emperor was Divine follows Japanese Americans through the perspectives of a four-membered family, from spring of 1942 to 1946, a period of time in which both issei, Japanese immigrants to America, and their nisei offspring were subject to anti-Japanese hysteria, through means of extreme propaganda and incarceration. Otsuka highlights the distinct lifestyles a Japanese American family faces, before, during, and after the overlying trauma…

    • 1433 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Silence In Obasan

    • 1289 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “Shikata ga nai” are words that has occurred in the minds of many Japanese Canadians, “Shikata ga nai” translates to “nothing can be done or helped”. These proverbs are used to define the silence that has consumed the lives of the Japanese Canadians during the prejudice demands of the government during the internment in 1942. In Joy Kogawa’s harrowing novel Obasan, the Canadian government discriminates harshly against the Japanese Canadians during the internment. The Japanese Canadians do not protest, instead they keep themselves peacefully while living in silence in the interior of Canada. Kogawa highlights the theme of silence, the silence that is kept quiet but becomes beneficial and the unspoken silence that is dangerous.…

    • 1289 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Style, shows how being American is not always the most valued trait. Nakashima was born and raised in America and came from a “thoroughly American background” (Nakashima, 204) but after Pearl Harbor, he was not seen as American. All people saw were his Japanese ancestry. Throughout his piece, Nakashima emphasizes how “American” his life was and offers a sense of what it means to be American. He states, “I left a life, highballs with our American friends on the weekends”…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Before and after 1949, the gap between the possibilities and limits of Chinese women’s lives was large, where the limits on women far surpassed the possibilities for a prolonged amount of time. Societal views were placed upon women, creating a system in which women must conform to a specific type of person or they would be shunned upon by those around them. This system was what determined the future of a woman in China. In the following stories, “Sealed Off”, by Ailing Zhang, “A Woman Like Me”, by Xi Xi, and “Fin de Siecle Splendor” by Zhu Tianwen, we explore the status of women during these periods of times.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Stereotypes of people of color and minority races have been around for many years, and have proved themselves to dominate the perception of people of color in everyday life. Films portray people of color as they are perceived by white Americans, not how they truly are, unique. Film has only dirtied the minority races’ image over time, though if the movies were not made by other Americans, they were more accurate to their race. Stereotypes of Asians have been around for a long time, ever since Asians were introduced. Stereotypes such as Asian students are smarter, Asian women are more exotic and tend to wait on men, Asian women are submissive, Asian people are all from China, and many others.…

    • 1951 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Why is it that in our generation, sometimes we don’t even treat our blood relatives like family anymore? Well in the short tale “The Girl & the Chenoo”, we learn a very valuable lesson about love and respect. Though the love may have been a result of desperate fear of the girl, I believe message from the tale, is we tend to love what has the ability to hurt us. God is a prime example, we praise and love this higher being because we fear what our consequences will be if we don’t. Ironically, the big scary monster had a big heart of his own.…

    • 191 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ding Ling’s “New Faith” resembles other stories that she wrote depicting the social conditions which she was concerned about. Namely, those conditions focused on the issue of gender identity as expounded by Tani Barlow’s essay on “Mother.” “New Faith” was not Ding Ling’s first story to focus on the shift of women’s gender identity during the modern era of Chinese civil war. As Barlow points out, Manzhen in “Mother” makes the change from an individual female character to an asexual political entity when she forms a sisterhood with her friends at the normal college.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This document is an excerpt from a book written by scholar and official, Yuan Cai, in the twelfth century. This book was written for leading household men and consists of advice to manage matters within the family. What I find interesting about this document is the way women were treated in this culture, at this time. The author regards women as almost a prize that is to be cherished with utmost care, while at the same time, giving the women absolutely no right to family matters or give them their own say in their life.…

    • 1321 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    From ancient to modern time, men and women were situated in different positions and were viewed as having unequal capabilities and values. The modern Chinese literature works may serve as a great source to understand the prevalent thoughts and values about women since they reveal the social construct and prevailing ideas about women during that time period. Texts such as “A Posthumous Son” and “When I Was in Xia Village” both depict how women are valued and the social norms regarding women. The examination of these texts, along with the historical backgrounds of society, suggests that the role and status of women are established through the construction of political ideologies, in that woman from childhood to mature lives were assigned with…

    • 1921 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Plague of Progress: Mishima’s Characterization and Views of Westernization A common misconception is that change always equates to progress, yet sometimes change can strip a society of its fundamental characteristics. Japan endured similar events, surrounding World War II that resulted in an increasingly Westernized country that lost it’s integrity and beliefs. In this allegorical novel, The Sailor who fell from Grace with the Sea, Yukio Mishima uses the characters Fusako, Ryuji and Noboru whom symbolize the different states of Japan to illustrate the plague of Westernization and convey the value of tradition in Japan. Primarily, Fusako embodies modern Japan with her obsession with foreign goods and focus on economic growth, which conveys…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The subject of the post-Pearl Harbor reaction of the United States has become a topic of study by various historians. One such is John W. Dower who explores the intriguing comparison between American and Japanese depictions of each other in his short essay titled Race, Language, and War in Two Cultures: World War II in Asia. It is Dower’s essay that takes this interesting case study to draw the conclusion that the Japanese and the Americans were not that different in their propagandistic depictions. In his essay, Dower appears to make multiple claims on the dynamic played out by the prime super powers of the Second World War, specifically the United States and Japan.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays