Isolation In Katherine Mansfield's Miss Brill

Superior Essays
Katherine Mansfield's short story "Miss Brill" introduces an aging, lonely woman living in Paris during 1922. The fictional character, Miss Brill is depicted as disillusioned and desperately seeking acceptance from society in which she lives. As a solution to escaping her isolation, she repeatedly takes a Sunday afternoon stroll to the Jardins Publiques park where she thinks of herself as an actress performing to an audience. Adorned to her precious fur, she sees herself as an active, important participant, in the world around her. However, her blissful fantasy was shattered when a young couple commented on how stupid and ridiculous she looked. After overhearing the hurtful comment, Miss Brill faced the knowledge that she is actually just …show more content…
She then enlightens readers of the protagonist, Miss Brill, who is a lonely, sickly woman in denial. Miss Brill lacks self awareness which is evident to everyone but her. She is quickly aging and her body is slowly deteriorating, although she does not acknowledge it. She feels tingling in her hands and arms but ignores the situation by thinking it supposedly came from walking, line 131. She then expresses her feelings of alienation through her fur coat. Miss Brill treats the coat as her human companion, interrelaying emotions with it. This is evident in the question, "What has been happening to me?", line 131. At this point, Mansfield submerges the point of view into the psyche of Miss Brill. This allows readers to witness her pathetic attempt to create a fantasy world to escape the harsh domains of her …show more content…
The fur that Miss Brill wears in the park in many ways mirrors her own life. It is old, like Miss Brill, and has been taken out of a box, a dark place, which is similar to Miss Brill’s own environment. At the end of the story, the fur is returned to its box like how Miss Brill too returns to her lonely room, the highlight of her isolation from the joys and delights of the world. The fur coat may also be important as it too in some ways mirrors Miss Brill’s life. Mansfield describes the fur as being alone which would mirror Miss Brill’s life. The fact that it is described as yellow and shabby may also be important as Mansfield may be suggesting that it has not only seen better days but it is also old which would mirror Miss Brill’s life. She too is old and may possibly have seen better days before her sickness. Also, when Miss Brill said that she heard something cry, she may have heard herself

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Society is always faced with alarming situations. The traits and qualities of the people within these societies are contributing factors to overcoming the spine-chilling events. In the story of Jane Eyre, when a person's life is affected in a negative way it takes strength and resilience to rebound to positivity comparable to the recent real life situations of the survivors in the Paris Attack, written about in “Paris Responds to Tragedy with Silent Respect and Defiance” by Peter Wilkinson and Ralph Ellis. Furthermore in Jane Eyre, Jane is forced to live through isolation and alienation. The recently elected mayor of Salt Lake City mirrors the treatment of Jane Eyre in her own life struggling with the way society deals with her being outwardly…

    • 201 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    The roles of women reflected in the late nineteenth century up until the 1960’s were known to be portrayals of the perfect housewife or of one who lacked status. Jamaica Kincaid’s “Girl” and Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour” both represent the gender role that was expected of woman in their time period and their restrictions to having their own identity. Mrs. Mallard and Girl are similar because they both lack their own true identity and have expectations from others as to how they should act and who they should be. A common theme shown in both stories is repression.…

    • 1265 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    She only sought a brief respite before returning to society’s mold. Evidence for this presents itself in her grief and despair once Mr. Boyer has abandoned her. While she lingers in her depression after both men have left, her melancholy truly begins while Major Sanford remains, even though she retained her attraction towards him. Mr. Boyer represented the standard to which she held internally, her family and friends externally. Without the option to eventually conform, she recognizes her loss of freedom, even as Major Sanford remains available for a time.…

    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lady Bracknell is the embodiment of the Victorian era’s aristocracy, and her preoccupation with maintaining wealth and class plays a large factor in her standards for Gwendolen’s future. When Jack mentions his home in the country, Lady Bracknell is quick to assert that city-life is critical to Gwendolen’s hand, insisting that “[a] girl with a…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When passing the property where her house once stood, she remembers all of her “pleasant things that in ashes lie”. She can not help but to feel sorrow over the lost memories and belongings. Bradstreet creates a sense of loneliness by stating, “Under thy roof no guest shall sit, Nor at thy table eat a bit”, which causes the reader to feel empathy for the author. While grieving the loss of her property, she revisits the places where she would sit, and where she had her furniture. However, she knows that these objects did not give extreme joy, only a subtle amusement.…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Romanticism In Miss Brill

    • 2025 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Even though the narrative focalizes through the perspective of the protagonist, it is not her direct voice: ‘Miss Brill put up her hand and touched her fur’ (Mansfield 2007: 331). We never find out Miss Brill’s first name, which could arguably represent that we never find the true her, only the version constructed by the narrator. ‘Just as Miss Brill’s imagery reveals her personality to us, so does the narrative discourse reveal the distance and attitude appropriate for the reader’ (Mandel 1989: 477). The purpose of the 3rd person narrative in Miss Brill is to distance the reader enough that there is a noticeable movement between discourses. Mansfield constructs the narrative to control this distance, showing the manipulation of Miss Brill’s inner world of the imagination, by the outer world of the narrative.…

    • 2025 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Miss Brill” compared to “A Rose for Emily” “Miss Brill” was published in 1922, written by William Faulkner with the main character being that of Miss Brill. “A Rose for Emily” published in 1930, written by Katherine Mansfield with the main character being Emily Grierson. Although both stories were written long ago the stories are just as prevalent in today’s society. Similarly both Miss Brill and Emily suffered from loneliness and their own delusions, on the other hand Miss Brill was never involved romantically with a man, but Miss Emily’s only romance ended in murder. Miss Brill worked as a teacher and also read the newspaper to an elderly man.…

    • 621 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The scene where Jane first comes to live at St. Anne’s demonstrates the loving ecological relationship the community has with all natural beings, as Jane is startled by finding a large bear named Mr. Bultitude nonchalantly in a bathroom. Mrs. Maggs, Jane’s former maid, explains to Jane that Mr. Bultitude lives in the manor with them and assures her, “don’t be frightened, Mrs. Studdock. He’ll let you stroke him” (Lewis 98). Because St. Anne’s is welcoming not only of all humans regardless of their social standing in society, but also of all animals as well, the institute at Belbury provides a sharp contrast as wild…

    • 1609 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Upon hearing the news of her husband’s death, Mrs. Mallard is in a sudden grief and weeps at once. However, after she has calmed down and is alone in her room, she realizes she is now an independent woman. She sees all the spring days and summer days without her husband, and this excites her. When she acknowledges the joy, she feels possessed by it and must control herself from letting the word…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When discovering our own personal identities, there are a great number of things that can sway the way that identity ends up looking. In the novel To Kill a Mockingbird, Harper Lee explores how the influence of isolation, discrimination and loneliness can reflect upon our identities. Evidence of how these feelings impact our individual identities can clearly be seen in the lives of characters Tom Robinson, Mayella Ewell and Boo (Arthur) Radley. Boo Radley is perhaps the most misunderstood character that Harper Lee crafted. Scout and Jem believe he is a monster who eats raw animals, a great giant of a man with yellow teeth and perpetually bloodstained hands.…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Blanche Dubois enters the lives of Stanley and Stella Kowalski when she arrives at their apartment at Elysian Fields. The beautiful and cultured Blanche clashes with the primitive Stanley. However, unlike the cultured Blanche first seen, the real Blanche is penniless and has a history with many men. When Stanley reveals Blanche’s impure past to everybody, Blanche struggles to continue and ends up in a mental facility.…

    • 1362 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Miss Brill Loneliness

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Typically, children are the ones who fabricate imaginary friends to fill voids when they experience loneliness. Because the fur and the aging woman are basically analogous to a child and his/her imaginary friend, the reader is pushed to perceiving Miss Brill with the same type of patronizing empathy one would a child. As will be argued later in this essay, Miss Brill’s fur enables her to see the world as a spectacle through rose-colored glasses, where she can delude herself into contentment. That is why towards the end of the piece, when Miss Brill overhears a young couple mocking her, her idealized world is shattered. Specifically, a young man attempts to persuade his girlfriend into assumingly being affectionate with him in the public space, and when she refuses, the young man questions her: "But why?…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is important to the reader because she is embracing the death of her partner, not grieving for as long as most women would. The environment also symbolizes imagery, which connects Mrs. Mallard’s new sense of happiness with the beginning of the spring season. The audience can see her transforming into a lively woman full of life and contentment as she is leaving her old life behind. Her last name, “Mallard”, represents a bird. It is important for the reader to be aware of this…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Role Of Guilt In Atonement

    • 1326 Words
    • 6 Pages

    From the very first pages of the novel readers “meet an instance of Briony’s literary imagination before [they] get to know her as a personality” (Finney). At the ripe age of thirteen Briony “is an author first, and a girl on the verge of entering adolescence secondly” (Finney). Because of this, Briony cannot see the world clearly as it is; she lives in a fictive world. Similar to in her writings, to Briony there is only right and wrong, establishing her inability to see that there are gray areas in between the two. Her failure to see the gray eventually adds to her readiness to accuse Robbie Turner of raping Lola.…

    • 1326 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Garden Party Setting

    • 1692 Words
    • 7 Pages

    (Mansfield 14) This imagery shows the juxtaposition between the two settings and emphasizes their contrasing mood. This contrats in setting also causes Laura to be in conflict with the darker setting. Laura “[wishes] she has put on a coat” (Mansfield 14) and regrets wearing “the big hat with the velvet streamer.”…

    • 1692 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays