The Journey To Knight: An Analysis

Good Essays
American Muslims are stereotypically assumed to be a monolithic group by many Americans, and are expected to act and behave in the same way despite big differences in their ethnic backgrounds. This assumption is justified by their perception that there is only one kind of Islam and what fundamental Muslims believe in is universal Islam because they consider the Quran as a rule book to live by without any questions or arguments. In reality, however, this is not always true, as there are divergent views of Islam which often make it difficult for people who have faith in Islam but have some unanswered questions to accept the idea of universal Islam outright. The confusion faced by such Muslims is explicitly portrayed in the book, The Journey to …show more content…
Muslims are spread all over the world and it is impossible for billions of people to have the same interpretations. He talks about various Islamic interpretations and practices that juxtapose the idea of universal Islam. For example, Knight talks about people praying to local saints and performing other acts of worship in some places in spite of the fact that Islam strictly prohibits the worship of graves and humans, including worship of Muhammad (Knight 45). He talks about the use of drugs in Pakistan even though it is considered haram to intoxicate. He also mentions the existence of paintings of the Prophet in certain places like Iran and Turkey despite the fact that any form of visual representation of the Prophet is strictly prohibited in Islam (Knight 136). Knight also comes across a person in Ethiopia who says that all five prayers can be done in one prayer (Knight 161). Even though this idea is against one of the Five Pillars of Islam which requires a Muslim to pray five times a day it is still practiced by some people. This shows that all Muslims do not necessarily follow the same interpretations and there are variations at an individual or group level. It proves wrong the viewpoint of orthodox Muslims that there are not any grey areas for Muslims; if God says something, it 's the law and there can be no disputing …show more content…
Personal interpretation and subsequent implementation of that in daily life often leads to a roller coaster of emotions. There are many people like Knight who embraced Islam with the hope of finding answers to questions they have about religion and life. However, the constant scrutiny of followers of orthodox Islam make them feel a need to prove themselves in order to win acceptance in Islam (Knight 211). People who have trouble accepting what is claimed to be monolithic Islam, but who are also not prepared to compromise on their faith often face certain situations that lead to inner conflict. Knight himself, while in Mecca, reconciles traditional Islam like Bulleh Shah’ views with his Five Percenter learnings (Knight 48). He also feels distressed at times that his decision of converting to Islam has adversely affected his mother (Knight 255). It is very hard for converts like Knight to submit to the idea of monolithic Islam because sometimes they run into situations that raise new set of questions for them. For example, Knight is taken aback when he learns at a point that Pakistan 's Islam that didn 't conform to a Saudi interpretation of Islam was shielded from him during his first visit. He is surprised to know that people did drugs in Pakistan and that every Thursday night, at

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    In other words, humans cannot create an image that is beyond their capacity and resemblance. However, there is a dividing line between two sects in Islam; the divide centers on the depiction of God. While Sunni Muslims believe that there can be no image of God, Shia Muslims worship believed “images” of God and the prophet Muhammad. Most often, Shia Muslims endorse and create these depictions as a tool of worship, similar to Christians. Shia Muslims believe it can be used.…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Such as they each have just one God to worship in their own way, their own worship days, and their own prayer times. However, one of the biggest misconceptions that westerners have about the Islamic faith is that Christians want to believe that Muslims hold Muhammad as revered as they do Jesus. They believe Muslims worship Muhammad in the same manner as they worship Jesus, while I have found through the lectures and the selected readings of the Qur’an that Muhammad was only a messenger of Allah. He was only a prophet, one that was chosen to bring Allah’s word to the people. Muhammad was not to be celebrated as someone equal to Allah to dispute these western beliefs.…

    • 1202 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In his novel, Steyn says, “Of course not all Muslims support terrorists, though enough of them share their basic objectives: the wish to live under Islamic law in Europe and North America” (cite). These claims made by Steyn, though initially are based on facts as he cites statistics, are substantially harmful claims as he insinuates that he is referring to all Muslims as a whole, not a small, extremist…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Islamic Faith

    • 2242 Words
    • 9 Pages

    I choose to complete my report on the Islamic faith because I feel that it is a relevant topic. It seems like every time I turn on the news or visit a news website, I am met with articles about the Islamic faith. I don’t think people fully understand what the religion stands for and only think about a few radical sectors of the religion. I think when most people think of Muslims they think of a radical group or terrorist. This is very unfair because most Muslims are very peaceful and tolerant of other groups.…

    • 2242 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Terrorism And Al-Qaida

    • 1565 Words
    • 7 Pages

    From there comes my assertion that there is no Muslim faithful to the dogmas and practices of his religion that is moderate or tolerant, unless he is hypocritical, ignorant of his doctrine or is ashamed of it. The most glaring example is the Sunni-Shia relationship. The opening of these two groups, one with respect to the other, has not been made, after centuries of conflict and hostility, through alleged values of moderation and tolerance that would be inherent in their doctrines, but because of their integration into The institutions of modern society: the school, the university, the economic market, the company ... And when everyone has regressed to his original doctrine, the conflict has erupted again, but in an even more cruel and destructive way, which makes me say that we are in the presence of two "religions" more hostile to one another than to…

    • 1565 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Muslim Argumentative Essay

    • 1098 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Likewise, what Barack Obama mentioned in his speech to convey his argument is what most of us could have agreed 100% because I believe that there is no religion who accepts the killing of innocent people. In addition, according to ABC News, Abdullah of Saudi Arabia used pathos to convey his argument when he said, “Muslims are not bloodthirsty people. Islam is a religion of peace that forbids the killing of the innocent. Islam also accepts the Prophets, whether those prophets are Mohammed, God's peace and blessing be upon Him, or Moses or the other prophets of the Books.” This shows that most Muslim people are just following their religion’s regulations, which refuses to allow killing people. When Donald Trump said Muslims are terrorists…

    • 1098 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    However I believe that the main reasons that the Arab world are not democratic is because of their lack of belief in secularism, the economic structures, and western worlds war on terror and its influence on the population 's perception of democracy. In the Arab world, the islamic religion is tied into everyday life. Islam itself is one the main reasons that people assume that the middle east has no democracies. While the religion itself is not a direct cause of this lack of democracy, it does have something to do with it. Since the religion is so entwined with everyday life, the population would like to see it in their government.…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Most JW Christians do the same, but those who are trained to do so go door-to-door to teach others about their religion. Despite their portrayal in the media, JW Christians do not force anyone to convert. While Muslims are allowed to engage in war in order to spread Islam, JW Christians are not permitted to enter war at all, following a pacifist lifestyle. Islam is particularly prevalent in the Middle East, North Africa, Western Asia, and Southeast Asia, but JW Christianity does not have any patterns when it comes to prevalence within the regions of the world – the religion is banned in some countries in North Africa, the Middle East, and parts of Asia, where JW Christians practice and spread their religion in secret. However, JW Christianity is most prevalent in Sub-Saharan Africa.…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Due to this, the Shia Muslims practice their faith in secrecy and have said to be “in hiding because of the oppression” (Gooch, 2011). The NFC believes that majority of the civil disputes within other Muslim countries occur because of permitting different sects to practice their faith freely, and Malaysia should prevent this from happening by setting limitations on any sect that does not belong to their official Malaysian sect, Sunni Islam (Gooch, 2011). This leads to many hardships faced by the Shia…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Instead they only follow the spiritual aspects. With the recent presidential campaign many people have voiced out their opinions on Muslims, usually degrading them in the process. However, most Muslims see Islam as merely a religion and do not seek the disciplinary aspects of sharia. Many Muslims in the US have shared the disrespect that they have received for being Muslim. They are constantly portrayed and labeled as terrorist, but is that a reasonable assumption?…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays