Is Jay Lying Case Study

Is Jay lying? From the get go Jay is a character that I find a little off-putting. His story constantly changes and is never the same twice. Key details get switched around when they should have been certain, friends of Jays are seemingly covering for him, and he plays the victim role all too well. This case has more twists and turns than a maze. There has never been any hard evidence proving that Adnan killed Hae. All the prosecution ever had was Jay’s testimony and without that the whole case would have fell through. Jay is being untruthful about what happened on that fateful night and truth will eventually come to light. The events of that night are quite different when told by Adnan versus Jay. On one hand Adnan says him and Jay were just riding around, getting high, and doing his normal day-to-day routine. When Jay tells his side he spins a …show more content…
That doesn’t really scream criminal mastermind to me. Common sense would tell anyone that the police prefers murders over drug dealers any day. If Jay had went to the police when he supposedly first learned of Hae’s death he could have avoided any involvement in to the crime. Had he gone to the police when Adnan told he was going to kill Hae the murder never would have happened. If you had the opportunity to save a life would you stop to think of the consequences? One thing about this case is undeniably certain. Jay is somehow connected to the murder of Hae Min Lee. And I have an aching feeling that he is closer to it than he is letting on. Jay’s stories do not add up. Could be that they’re never the same, could be that his friend’s stories are fishy too, or it could be that he is trying way too hard to appear innocent. Whatever the case may be Hae’s murder is being looked at closer than ever before and Adnan’s chances at freedom are looking better than