Irving Shapiro's Fallacies Of Logic

Improved Essays
In “Fallacies of Logic” Irving Shapiro describes the different ways a person, intentionally or unintentionally, can attack their opponent. Fallacies, when used, could be effective tools to confuse and distract opponents. The use of logical fallacies, also known as con, date back to Athens when a school taught students to win arguments using fallacies. The following are the most common fallacies used. Fallacies are easy to agree with and are simple statements with little or irrelevant information to back them up.
Some fallacies are based on the assumption that different events and observations are correlated. “Over-generalization” is a common fallacy that applies a certain observation to an entire group, drawn from an unrepresentative sample. Such observations lie in the past or present and are flawed because they are based on a small sample. These unfair assumptions involve making a general claim based on limited or specific evidence and applied in a greater context. A “thin entering wedge” have
…show more content…
One fallacy, commonly known as Ad hominem, attacks the person directly suggesting that the other opponent ran out of ideas on the subject. This reasoning focuses the attention on the person who made the argument like criticizing his or her personal appearance. Such fallacy is irrelevant since a person has nothing to do with the discussion. The other one questions the authority of the person to make credible comments on the subject in which the opponent may undermine the qualifications of the victim. For example, an international economist being questioned of his experience when commenting on future fluctuations. Tu quoque also deviates the attention on the current argument in which the opponent “leaves the assertion unaddressed” (Shapiro). The comments added to the discussion can be completely off topic and do not necessarily take a position on the

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    For one, the red herring fallacy was the most common fallacy that these two candidates displayed in their arguments. The red herring fallacy is a fallacy that utilizes other appealing information to draw away the audiences attention, in order to distract them from the main argument. The audience continually asks the candidate a question and the candidates deflects the question with ease. In the debate, an audience member asks, “Do you feel you are modelling appropriate and positive behavior for today’s youth? (CBSNewsOnline)”…

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fallacies In Hoops Dreams

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages

    One occasion an illogical fallacies is used is when Arthur’s parents are told the half-truth of the scholarship to St. Joseph’s. His parents were told that Arthur that they wouldn’t have to pay for Arthur’s tuition to St. Josephs. However, what they didn’t know was Arthur would be receiving a partial scholarship to the school and if he had produced results for the basketball team then he would receive a sponsor for the rest of his tuition. For Arthur’s case, he was wasn’t providing good enough results because he wasn’t physically growing unlike his teammates which deemed him unworthy enough. On the other hand, William Gates was given this opportunity and went on to excel as a basketball player.…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Rhetorical Analysis of a Central Argument in Malcolm Gladwell’s Outliers In his acclaimed novel Outliers, a book that details the various factors that contribute to success, Malcolm Gladwell aims to convince his audience of the simple yet powerful assertion that success cannot simply be attributed to the choices one makes, but rather that it is a product of opportunity. “Outliers are those who have been given opportunities — and who have had the strength and presence of mind to seize them”, claims Gladwell. Although he makes several noteworthy points within this novel, the idea that success and opportunity are tightly interwoven serves as his most pivotal argument. The use of such devices as anecdotes and statistics help Gladwell construct…

    • 1094 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I agree with Howard Zinn’s viewpoint of objectivity and subjectivity in a way. In Zinn’s excerpt he proclaims how “One, that it’s not possible. Two, it's not desirable”. Zinn was talking about how If you were to take a history book of some sort and start putting certain facts into the book and big ideas it’s already subjective. For a history book, website or museum to be objective it would need to have every fact of every story from every angle of that event.…

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A 7-2 majority ruled on the case of Dred Scott v. Sanford, citing a wide variety of constitutional grounds for support. One of the weakest arguments of this case was the argument for Dred Scott not being able to be classified as a citizen. As a result, he was not subject to the full right of freedoms and due process of law. Taney wrote that slaves lacked sovereignty and that they were not intended to be included by the framers of the Constitution (5). He writes that slaves were actually, “intended to be excluded from it.”…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Life is what happens when you put down your phone” (Montague 41). Kids are often thought of as being uninvolved in their communities because they are “too small” and they can’t do what others can. It is thought that if you just put a child in front of a tv or computer that they will be content. Robby Novak has blown that stereotype out of the water. Robby Novak, also known as Kid President, is a hero to many because he positively, bravely, and significantly made a lasting impact on the world, but he could also be considered an epic hero because he holds a weapon in which only he can wield, he had an unusual circumstance of birth, and he is currently going on a remarkable journey through his life.…

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Example Of Ethos Logos

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages

    One popular fallacy that Ann Coulter uses her article is an ad hominem. Some examples of an ad hominem is included in the lines “The most likely explanation is that the reporters and investigators are incompetent nitwits” or “Among the questions not being asked by our wildly incurious media. ”While Coulter thinks that she is establishing her credibility by putting down other media outlets and the authorities, she simply comes across as arrogant and egoistic and alienating a portion of her…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    While reading chapter five, Fallacies of Argument, and chapter six, Rhetorical Analysis, there were key words that stood out to me that related to the podcast, Researchers Study Effects Of Social Media On Young Minds. Fallacies are argumentative moves flawed by their very nature or structure. There are fallacies of emotional argument, such as bandwagon appeals, which is when we urge people to follow the same path everyone else is taking. Continuing, fallacies of ethical arguments are important to think about when determining an argumentative writing piece; stacking the deck means that the person talking is showing only one side of the story, going with ethical arguments in writing. Rhetorical Analysis is the analyzing of how well the components…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Argumentative fallacy 's can be seen in everyday life from talking with one 's mom to speaking with their boss, the trouble is identifying these fallacy 's and being aware that they do exist and can affect oneself and the person they are speaking to. Being able to know the difference between an ad hominem and straw man could be the difference between winning one 's argument. To begin with, two quite opposite articles have been provided that contain a central claim about the Iraq war. One of these articles is written by Anna Quindlen, 'We 've been here before ', while the other one is by Donald Stoker, 'Insurgencies rarely win '.…

    • 1019 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Logical fallacies may seem benign — and most of the time we are quick enough to catch them and save ourselves from being fooled. But they can also be callous. The use of logical fallacies can be extremely misleading, only there to promote an agenda. They infiltrate our minds, shape our thinking, and distract us from the real issues at hand. I’ll label this one a “False Analogy,” because it wrongly compares two ideas, leading to a false conclusion.…

    • 108 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Comparing Two Extremes

    • 120 Words
    • 1 Pages

    When it comes to evaluating fallacies there are two extremes that one must avoid. The two extremes are: finding fallacies only in the thinking of others (Paul & Elder, 2012, p.342). Is the point at which somebody is unconscious bias towards distinguishing fallacies with those with whom you can't help contradicting and non-in your self. The Second extreme to avoid is finding an equal number of fallacies in everything you read (Paul & Elder, 2012, p.342). When somebody comprises in coming to trust that everybody confers an equivalent number of fallacies, what's more, along these lines, you have no motivation to worry about it you fundamentally feel the circumstance is dead and there is no motivation to give it life.…

    • 120 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the logical fallacies that I found is Post hoc ergo propter hoc, which means the author assumes that one event causes the other. For example “Times of carnival temporally marginalize the monstrous, but at the same time allow it a safe realm of expression and play: on Halloween everyone is a demon for a night” (Cohen, 191). The author is assuming that in Halloween most people dress up as the monster they desire to be, which led all the expression to come up and also the real actions that a human have by dressing up as a monster. Another logical fallacy found in Cohen article is Begging the Claim, in which the author uses enough evidence to support his claim.…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Hasty generalization is an informal fallacy of faulty generalization based on insufficient evidence. Brian Crooks tries to explain this throughout the essay for example when he was in the 5th grade and his teacher asked him to form a rap song as part of a class presentation even though he had shown no previous talent or capability in music. She was stereotyping and automatically assumed that just because he was Black he would know how to rap. He uncovers how people instinctively and sometimes subconsciously treat others differently based on previous generalized stereotypes that have existed for generations. He shows how a person is discriminated and treated inferiorly just because of his skin color.…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Logical Fallacies

    • 235 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Sometimes I will unconsciously use logical fallacies. I remember there was a period I was addicted to playing computer games and often had quarrels with my parents about this. They thought the computer games was meaningless and a waste of time, but I considered it the way to relax myself. Each time they blamed me, I would respond as many other rebellious kids, you don’t have the position to blame me, because you would do what I do now when you were my age. That’s exactly a logical fallacy, but I just realize it until now.…

    • 235 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There are three main reasons why we commit fallacies. One of them is intent. Some people are well-versed in logic, yet they choose to intentionally use informal fallacies to their own advantage. For instance, while attorneys use informal fallacies such as Red herring and Straw man to win cases in a court of law, other people commit fallacies because they lack the knowledge to communicate properly without using fallacies. Another reason that may lead to people committing fallacies is their emotional state of mind.…

    • 140 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays