Analysis Of Mr. Mcchrystal's TED Talk

Improved Essays
Summary
Mr. McChrystal 's TED Talk is listed as 'Listen, Learn, the Lead '. Within the video he explains that a leader is good if they are open-minded, have a willingness to learn, and trust those they 're leading. He starts with talking about parachute jumping and how younger paratroopers were following what they had been taught to do by their leaders. That leading these people well meant they would survive combat, and how important that is to Mr. McChrystal. He shares the 'theoretical war ' changed into a very real possibility on September 11th, and that he was going to have to make significant changes to leading. He goes on to state that he was raised with traditional and personal examples of leadership. Moreover he shares the personal
…show more content…
Mr. McChrystal talks about two distinct periods of time, before 9/11 and the subsequent technology boom, and after it. He uses the before timeline to share personal experiences and growth with leadership. A failure of his past is shown to explain how a few words can change everything. He 'd messed up a practice dawn attack and has to go through an "after action review". Basically, that 's when higherup 's tell him everything he did wrong. Mr. McChrystal was only a company commander at this point and he felt 'as low as a snakes ' belly in a wagon rut ', so it 's safe to assume that his self-confidence and self-worth was very low. When he was walking out of the review he saw his battalion commander and went over to apologize for letting him down. The battalion commander told him "Stanley, I thought you did great." With this one act of communication Mr. McChrystal was put back on his feet, and was taught an important life lesson. A good leader will let their followers fail without letting them be a failure. That is an important distinction because it allows someone to learn and grow, instead of feeling like they 'll never amount to anything. Mr. McChrystal uses this example to imply that a good leader has skills at communication while directly stating a vital technique to …show more content…
McChrystal uses the after timeline to give personal examples of how leadership was changed. The first of those changes was leading a dispersed group that was spread out over thousands of miles and only having electronic mediums- email, teleconferences, chat, phone calls, anything he can get his hands on- to communicate with those he 's leading. He then has to substitute that for in-person communications without losing the ability to build trust and confidence between him and the individual people. It 's much easier to give someone confidence in the leader and themselves if the leader is in the room with the receiver for there is less chance of interference. Another change was the generational shift in the people under his rank. Mr. McChrystal was in his forty 's when 9/11 occurred and now he has served with people who were 11 when that happened. This in turn has caused an inversion of expertise. People are now entering the lower levels of the military having grown up with the technology boom, while elders like Mr. McCrystal do not have that skill. He was taught practices the military wasn 't using anymore. He poses the question "how does a leader stay credible and legitimate when they haven 't done what the people you 're leading are doing?" The answer is to become transparent, willing to stop and listen, and accepting to be reverse-mentor from the lower ranks. A good leader stays a good leader when they can admit they don 't know every and are willing to learn the skill

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Before Operation Phantom Fury the Iraqi people saw the U.S. as murderers who didn’t care about civilians or their cultural views. By the end of this operation their view hand changed, which in turn helped when the U.S. turned the city back over to local control. The key to success for Operation Phantom Fury, was MG Natonski’s early identification of armed reinforcements, understanding capabilities and limitations. His clear commander’s intent allowed for his subordinate leaders to be adaptable to the increased threat in their Area of Operations. This created a waterfall effect teamwork, shared understanding, and a clear commander’s intent enabled adaptable leaders…

    • 1299 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    9/11/01 will forever be remembered as one of the saddest, terrifying days in American history. This date will forever be imprinted on the minds of Americans who lost their loved ones, saw their city turn to chaos and their country in high distress and despair. The terrorist organization “al Qaeda” was responsible for this terror attacks hitting the world trade center and the pentagon, a couple of our most prized monuments. However, this could not bring the greatest land in the world to it’s feet, America is fiercer than that. In George Bush’s speech, addressed just 12 hours after the attack he lit a fire in the belly of Americans, he encourages strength and bravery in the people of the freedom land.…

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At some point, every leader probably thinks about how they want to lead and what is important to him or her as a leader. During the CSC coursework, I wrote my command philosophy, which gave me an opportunity to reflect on past leaders I had encountered, and project how I wanted to lead in the future. The command philosophy was a statement, written to the members of the unit, about what I valued as a leader. As a foundation for how to approach this philosophy, the CSC coursework described USMC General Lejeune’s teacher/scholar leadership approach (USMC CDET, 2013a). This approach to leadership rests on a foundation of ethics, directly supporting an ethos of core values, mode of conduct, leadership principles, and leadership traits (USMC…

    • 1720 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While President Obama is giving his speech at Michigan’s graduation ceremony he starts off by trying to relate to the American people by having to do normal everyday things like commuting in traffic. Obama also wants to connect with the American public by telling them that he reads their letters every day to show them that he is a part of them and not in control of them. He has a progressive mentality when opening up his speech. He is reaching out to the hearts and minds of the average person by telling a heartwarming story about a kid in kindergarten and asking him if people are nice to him. When Obama says “there are some things that we can only do together, as a nation- and that our government must keep pace with the times” I believe that…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In June 2010, I was a newly promoted Private First Class in the United States Army. I’ve been in the active service for less than a year at that point and I was already outshining my peers. My First Sergeant, the most Senior Enlist Personnel in my Company, came up to me and gave a challenge. This Challenge would result in a complete change of direction in my career, my physical toughness, and my mental capacity to learn.…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Mission Command

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages

    During the past decade of war, we as soldiers have seen numerous styles of leadership and command. These leadership styles have been the result of mission commands reactive measures to best adapt to the operational environments currently face. Ongoing operations in Afghanistan and again in Iraq have been complex, involving constant interactions between civilians, enemy organizations, and friendly forces as well as interaction with other factors which affect the mission such as terrain, time, and local political dynamics. While on the battlefield, many commanders face challenges with making immediate decisions that drive and or turn the tides of conflict at the tactical and operational level. Simply giving subordinates task and purpose is not enough for effective mission command.…

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Seek responsibility and take responsibility for your actions, what that means is that when you do something, make a decision, whatever it may be, take responsibility for them. Being a leader of any kind, at any level means someone either looks up to you, or they simply look to you for guidance. When you have people under you, or that you are in charge of, you have to be on top of things, know how to handle any situation, and if you do not know how to handle a situation, then know where you can find information on how to handle the situation. Marines past, present, and future all have had to and will have to take responsibilities for their actions. In some way, shape, or form we cannot just try and weasel our way out of a situation.…

    • 1008 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While the nation watched in terror and unsure if the attacks were over two other events had yet to unfold. Such as, American Airlines Flight 77 flying to Washington, D.C., with the purpose of causing destruction and United Flight 93’s passengers taking a bold step against the terrorists. The first event of American Airlines 77 took place at 9:45 a.m. The flight headed towards Washington, D.C., crashed into the west side of the Pentagon killing 125 people in the building along with 64 people aboard the plane. Although, the situation looked like it could not get any worse.…

    • 1617 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The purpose of this academic work is to interact with a squadron level or sister service commander, reflect on my current command leadership philosophy, and capitalize on the experience as I prepare for the next level of leadership. The body of the report shall cover the following three key elements: my personal leadership philosophy, a summary of my interview with an Army commander, and an analysis of the interview in correlation to my personal leadership philosophy. In closing the analysis will end with a brief summarization and final conclusion. Leadership Philosophy Recently I took advantage of a course being offered at the United States Air Force Academy (USAFA) titled, “The Challenge of Leadership”.…

    • 1117 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the last 1.5 years, the 4th Armored Brigade Combat Team (ABCT) has undergone significant change. Following a nine month deployment to Afghanistan, the Brigade appears to be overcome by stress, fatigue, leadership, and ethics issues. While many might categorize these as normal post deployment occurrences, they appear to run much deeper. The events of the previous deployment coupled with the death of the Brigade Commander, Brigade Sergeant Major and a Battalion Commander appear to be the critical events that triggered the downward slide of the Brigade.…

    • 1074 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Challenge of Command Summaries Chapter 1: Chapter 1 of Nye’s book “The Challenge of Command” begins with an explanation that this is an important book for specialists and junior officers to read so that they may thoroughly understand the challenges that are faced by positions of command. Nye emphasizes the importance of continuation of learning, and laments that with many soldiers learning ceases at a certain point in their career. Nye criticizes the mental process of certain aspects of training, and argues that the current emphasis is on what officer does, while it should be what officer should be. Nye goes on to explain some if the motivational theory propositions, some supported by authors, while others, by social scientists. He is also…

    • 1961 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    George W. Bush’s “9/11 Address to the Nation” was a speech, which was given after the catastrophic event that occurred on September 11, 2001. Two airplanes were hijacked and were crashed into the Twin Towers in New York City on this day, shocking the whole world. He addressed this speech to the people of America on the night of the disastrous event, highlighting how America’s freedom was attacked. Thousands of innocent people died while thousands of people were wounded. After the event, President Bush sent out special forces to investigate who was responsible for this, so they can give them the punishment they deserve.…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    That was probably the most valuable lesson I took from the experience: That no matter how much planning and preparation goes into a mission, things can always go wrong and a leader must be prepared to adapt and overcome any obstacles thrown his way. In a situation where new problems arise, the Troop Leading Procedures and the Operations Process can be applied to aid in completing the…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    General Dempsey brings light to the idea that the Army lost its way as a profession. The Army White Paper: The Profession of Arms discusses General Martin E. Dempsey’s viewpoint on the Army as a professional organization. The Army White Paper states, “In adapting to the demands of combat in Iraq and Afghanistan, as well as to the new strategic realities of the 21st Century, we have been so busy that we have not consistently thought through how these challenges have affected the Army as a Profession of Arms”1. He believes that second and third order effects of multiple combat deployments are the root cause of tremendous pressure on the Army as a Profession. ADRP 1-0 states five characteristics of the Army profession as trust, esprit de corps,…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Platoon Leader Analysis

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages

    LT McDonough Leadership assessment The book Platoon Leader provides a wide range of leadership situations and challenges. LT McDonough was, as a rule, very successful in dealing with intellectually challenging problems. His interpersonal tact left much to be desired and even his resilience was nearly broken down. Overall, he led his platoon very well and successfully.…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics