Law And Oppression: An Analysis

Great Essays
Legal scholars have long studied the interconnecting systems of oppression. The imbalances of equality in society have been a difficult concept to comprehend. The purpose of this paper is to critically analyze how law and subjectivity intersect with the working poor and unemployed individuals in society. This essay’s aim is to broaden the understanding of the ways in which the notions of law and poverty overlap in society to ultimately reproduce the flaws in the law’s promise to equal justice (Munger, 2004, p. 331). This paper will begin by providing an overview of the context of the working poor and unemployed people to familiarize the reader with the material before the analysis portion of this essay. The terms “poverty” and “working …show more content…
Capitalism has eventually entrenched the conception of substantive equality in our society. This is the concept of understanding social contexts that recognize that oppressions and disadvantages in society are realities (Rosenfel, 1986, p. 1687). As a result of this type of thinking, those who are in a lower class will not be treated the same. This notion perpetuates that the playing field is not level and rather than establishing all members of society with having “equal opportunity” of achieving the same goals as others, it creates a major divide between the opportunities that are given to some and out of reach for others (Rosenfel, 1986, p. 1687). In relation to Rosenfel’s description of substantive equality, Majury argues that substantive equality “addresses the new mutations and shifting manifestations of inequality as well as deeply entrenches systemic inequalities” (Majury, 2006, p. 5). This means that the concept of substantive equality understands that notions can be greatly embedded into the law to the point where it becomes part of the …show more content…
Through this analysis, we can see a clear line drawn between the creation and sustainability of poverty, ultimately concluding that the state is of heavy influence on how the working poor and unemployed are treated in society. This critical analysis draws on providing and explaining the roles that other entities play in the same society to showcase a power balance in conjunction with class inequity The background provided in the beginning of the paper provided a general insight on the contents of the paper and how the relationship is perceived on the surface. Through the analysis of how society is structured, we can recognize that the perseverance of poverty means that our society is not as advanced and developed as we believed.By understanding and critically analyzing the working poor’s relationship with the organization of society, role of the state and lack of access and assistance, it is evident that there is a great intersection between how law can affect society in abstract ways. Not only does law and subjectivity intersect with poverty, but many other factors that were not discussed in this paper are also greatly beneficial to the quality of life that an individual can maintain. Poverty is only one key determinant in interpreting and discerning the types of resources

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Ehrenreich Is It Now a Crime to be Poor?, is an article by Barbara Ehrenreich that discusses the manner in which poverty has been criminalized in the American society. The main technique that Ehrenreich uses to make her argument that on the topic under discussion is the provision of real life examples. The approach has a great impact in convincing the reader that the delivered arguments and information are factual. In the article, Ehrenreich provides numerous examples of individuals who have faced the law for being poor. For example, Mr. Szekely, an ordained minister who neither abused drugs or alcohol nor cursed in the presence of women, had an arrest warrant.…

    • 288 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Between the years 1984 and 2016 a lot has changed, but a lot also still remained the same. The social injustices our current day faces are also similar but vastly different. Better? Maybe. In class we have been learning about social justice and the major impact discrimination, oppression, inequity and prejudice has brought to our history.…

    • 395 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This is expressed through the societal conceptual understanding of poverty, the institutions and arrangements that govern resource availability and access and the continual sustainability of that access as well as understanding the foundations and institutions that orchestrate the generation of poverty and challenges that arise with going up against a system that is built and preys on the disadvantaged and poor members of…

    • 2064 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As observed in two unique, but contrasting forms of writing, both Nickle and Dimed by Barbra Ehnreich, and Plato’s famous Apology and Crito, spotlight injustice in society. For Ehnreich, her novel’s purpose was to shed a light on social justice in America through research in the low-wage work force; as for Plato, he addressed injustice through dialogue on his teacher Socrates’ trial and penalty. Although these works of writing were published in dramatically different time periods, it seems one pertinent aspect of society in 399 B.C.E, is still relevant in today’s 21st century – we do not live in a just society. “I grew up hearing over and over to the point of tedium,” Ehnreich states, “that ‘hard work’ was the secret to success: ‘Work hard and you’ll get ahead’ or “It’s hard work that got us where we are.” Barbra speaks words taught by her father who shoveled his way up from the mines to the middle class; he was a source of inspiration…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Hill Collins, is oppression full of contradictions because each group describes the type of oppression they feel comfortable with as being fundamental and thereby classify other oppression as less important. This approaches fail to recognize that there are only few people who are purely victims or oppressors. Each person has varying amounts of penalties and privileges from different systems of oppression that frames everyone's lives. This makes oppression to be full of contradictions. Social activists fail to understand how their action and thoughts may uphold someone else's subordination.…

    • 343 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Every country around the world has economic inequality within it. The income inequality encountered in the United States in ranked sixty four in the world. The economic inequality divided in the United States has a major impact on three factors: social class, education and power amongst the citizens. The economic inequality seen in “Parable of the Sower” by Octavia Butler reflects on how separation between poor, middle and rich class lead to a dystopian future. “Inequality for all” examines how economic inequality can impact social classes such as upper, middle and lower class.…

    • 1759 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even with an education and equal experience, if you’re a minority or woman, you will still make less than an individual who is not. This module, has allowed me to the reality of the economic disparity that exist and has provided me a view of life through the lens of the privilege, as Patricia Hill Collins’ stated in her piece, titled “Matrix of Domination” (Collins, 1990). The detrimental effects of economic disparity are as follow: • Families are not able to afford quality childcare, housing, health care or in some cases education. • More than 12 percent of women ages 65 and older and nearly 65 percent live below the poverty line (U.S. Congress Economic Committee, 2016). • Little or no retirement saved.…

    • 144 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marx and Nozick make compelling arguments against inequality, however, their arguments fall short when compared to arguments in favour of equality. Equality is a level of impartiality either in services or wealth for citizens to provide fair opportunities. Citizens have some uniform treatment by the state in order to remove barriers between individuals. These contentions vary between levels of intrusive means; they allow more or less freedom for citizens. More equality stems from more intrusion, or less equality from less intrusion.…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the essay “Poverty in America: Why can’t we end it?” Peter Edelman laments over the ever present issue of Americans living below the poverty line. He enlightens his readers to the possibility of changing what has become the status quo with a passionate voice. Going through several notable changes in tone to convey a strong yet somewhat subjected point Edelman educates his reader through poverty statistics pulled from credible sources. He then manages to balance out the dire news with noted success in fighting poverty in America.…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Everyone has his or her own understanding of “justice” and their meanings of the word are shaped by different characteristics like culture and personal experiences. In today’s world, “justice” is a vague term with potentially biased notions since it is difficult to set up a perfect and universally acceptable criterion that describes ultimate justice. For the purpose of this essay, a more flexible and practical definition of justice should be employed. Upon examining the social realms across disability, education, and labor fields in America, social phenomenon disregarding fairness leads to injustice as a huge disparity of social power and opportunities between the powerful and the powerless remains unsolved. In Hing’s text “Race, Disability,…

    • 1508 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Poor Kids Movie Analysis

    • 1252 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The poor in American Society are the victims of the social theory referred to as CONFLICT THEORY. The theory explains that the social STRATIFICTION SYSTEM is not functioning properly and the rich benefit more from the governmental decisions at the expense of the disadvantaged, those who rightly need the assistance. This theory is shockingly apparent in the Frontline documentary “Poor Kids”. This film follows the lives of three families’ struggling to deal with life’s most crippling situations the best way they can. The film demonstrates that being poor is not always a question of a PERSONAL PROBLEM related to the ABUSE of drugs or alcohol, but of a SOCIAL PROBLEM with unemployment, lack of job opportunities, and in this particular film, recession.…

    • 1252 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Poverty is a multidimensional concept that encompasses inadequacies in the three most fundamental pillars of human life: access to healthcare, education and living standards. Due to the capitalistic nature of our societal mechanisms, corporations exploit and thrive off of poverty. Cheap labour is a facet of their exponential profit. Poverty is not the root of socially immoral behaviour but is rather a product of it, as it is a result of the free-market’s hierarchical, trickle-down wealth pyramid where CEOs and corporation heads receive large sums of money opposed to their workers who are paid minimally, further polarizing wealth classes. This wealth scarcity amongst the working-class furthers the free-market’s aims by encouraging and allowing for exploitative behaviour as their needs are never satisfied and thus they endure harsh working environments, like those in sweatshops, for minimal compensation.…

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Analysis on “The Working Poor” Although, I disagree with critic Katherine Newman of “The Wages of Fear” and Kathleen Courrier of “Ain’t it Hard?” who both argue that the conclusions on poverty in “The Working Poor” by David K. Shipler is imitative to other experts as well as derelict on certain solutions. I also agree with both the critics who find Shipler’s perspective of living in poverty insightful and pragmatic on the stigma that follows the lower working-class. Therefore, the incisive critics argument of Shipler’s aspect on poverty has precision on the dilemmas the working poor experience as well as the deficit obstacles poverty struggles in.…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Poverty vs. Equality There are many ways to view poverty and equality, and it’s easy for someone who never has suffer of hunger or lack of education to assume that the poor can improve by their own, but can they really? People with high income work hard to earn money, they spend who knows how many time studying and working, it would not be fair to take away what they clearly deserved. “What Is Poverty” by Jo Godwin Parker shows a very detailed view of poverty, meanwhile Stephen Moore and Peter Ferrara in “The Poverty of Equality” describe what equality is and the issues it has. Both articles express their opinion about social safety nets, their completely different views of equality and the value of work.…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Effects of Poverty on the Mental, Emotional, and Behavioral Health of Children and Youth Implications for Prevention Summary Poverty affects children many ways. Many would argue that the more poverty stricken a child is, the less likely they are to show high levels of mental, emotional, and behavioral health. This article contains four main purposes in mind when evaluating this issue and its effect on children. Its goals were to define and describe the definitions of poverty, propose a conceptual framework that involved the process of how people become impoverished, use the framework proposed to assess literary works on how family poverty affects the youth, and describe strategies to lessen poverty. Poverty is a word not easily defined and completely narrowed down to one category.…

    • 1371 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays