Dworkin's Theory Of Integrity Analysis

Great Essays
Dworkin’s meaning to integrity pertains to judicial decisions by judges on any case, that is, how to use precedent and techniques to determine the outcome of trials. Integrity as a tool, is used for judicial decisions, based of of communal moral standards- starving for a concept of fairness and equality- these decisions are rooted in precedent and discretion of judges; though possibly leading to a divergent from a cohesive voice, the philosophical concept benefits society overall. Integrity has its roots in the communities morals. It stretches, then, to the adjudicative process exercised by judges. This theory does well for establishing a more cohesive identity of the community and its laws. By expressing concerns of the gaps found in this …show more content…
It allows judges to apply the same standards that others have applied, they maintain the original morality of the community; insuring that the law that the community made reflects the trial. The laws and the outcome of the trial will be consistent with the community’s current moral standards. Through the practice of first understanding a moral concept that is not consistent with communal values, like murder, a law is formed that will be read with consistent themes of the community’s ideals. These laws are interpreted by a judge who uses past cases to justify his decisions. He will also use discretion, allowing the law to evolve and reflect the current moral standards. This form of judicial practice maintains the integrity of the law, allowing for a cohesive uniformed voice of the peoples wants to be maintained and implemented by judicial officials. Although the concept of the integrity of law does well to provide fairness for the people; judges may flaw in their interoperation, “no actual judge could compose anything approaching a full interoperation of all of his community’s law at once” (Dworkin 97). There rest the problem of judges coming to different answers based on their discretion and findings; as well as their methods. In this, …show more content…
The morality comes from the unified decisions of the community, what they deem expectable. It is then created into law by language and put into practice through judicial history and inspiration, this allows for the voice to be come cohesive. These decisions give room for evolution so as to always reflect the intended meaning for the current society. Therefore, integrity of law is the state being whole in original intent, and undivided by pure discretion that devotees form precedents. Though that allows for a flaw to occur, judges making various answers by their own interpretations, these answers are basic happenings of law and should always strive for the original intent of the society; reflecting their

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Duel Court System

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Duel Justice Watkins, Robert GCU Duel Justice The United States of America utilizes a duel court system in its judicial system. The two courts systems are federal and state. Courts that exist at the state or local level are established by the individual state, and exist “within states there are also local courts that are established by cities, counties, and other municipalities, which we are including in the general discussion of state courts.” Courts that exist at the Federal level have been established under the United States Constitution and rule on disputes concerning the Constitution and laws that are passed by Congress.…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    1. The Supreme Court decisions in a case affect significantly the entire country’s legal system. Therefore, models of judicial decision making were created to explain the Supreme Court’s behavior and how they influence policies. While the legal, attitudinal and the strategic model are not the only theories of judicial decision making, those constitute the most prevalent hypotheses to explain judicial decisions.…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Applied Utilitarianism The definition of this greatly fascinates me. It got me thinking about Capital Punishment. In society, there are rules that each citizen must follow to be considered a good citizen. The rules put in place are usually determined by an educated group of people who create these rules to benefit their community.…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Nadine El Tanahy Dr. Dina S Lamey Rhet 1010 Oct. 15th Outline I. Introduction to analysis. II. Audience.…

    • 1555 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A judge which takes these arguments into account follows the line of thought of sociological…

    • 1718 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Judicial Tyranny Review

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Judicial Tyranny Review Name: Institution Introduction This books gives insights on the situation of judicial system of America. It enlightens on how the court system has become corrupt gradually since it was granted its mandate. The court has been used for personal matters and too much affiliated to politics. Robertson notes that, morals and libertinism has been corrupted by over use of power.…

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The authors hold vast and prestigious educational and research related ethics. In this article, the authors discussed the moral values, standards, norms and rules in local government and provided real life illustrations related to the subject. The article compares the American justice system with those of the Netherlands, Montenegro and Serbia. The authors provided an in-depth analysis of the constitutional restrictions with a direct look at the Fourth Amendment. The authors directly observed the notion of integrity which is a quality or characteristic of the basic fundamentals of having a meaningful life.…

    • 188 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The True Extent of the Supreme Court’s Constitutional Influence Many Americans currently lack a basic fundamental understanding of the Supreme Court’s origins and workings. The Court is a virtually unacknowledged entity. Unlike the executive or legislative branches, most Americans are only exposed to the Court during a greatly publicized issue—such as affirmative action or doctor assisted suicide. The Supreme Court is entrusted with the Constitution’s preservation through the process of judicial review. This authority means many of the Court’s decisions have a great effect on the American people.…

    • 1734 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For this assignment, I reviewed two articles on the Criminal Justice database library. One focused on bail decisions, and how this can sometimes affect the outcome of the sentencing phase. The other article focused on Capital Sentencing Decisions, that focused on the portrayal of the victim. Both of these articles gave some interesting theories of how judges and jury decide the fate of one’s future. It described how certain factors can influence the judge or jury in their decision making.…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although the creation of judicial review was a significant victory for the Supreme Court, it is also much more complicated than what meets the eye. Judicial review can also be more accurately described as “constitutional review” due to the controversial methods that judicial reviews is carried out (“Judicial Review | Law”) . Such views included what is referred to as “judicial restraint approach” and “activist approach.” In judicial restraint approach, judges are believed to be able to decide cases only on the basis of the language of the laws and the Constitution. However, when looking at the activist approach, judges are able to recognize the principles of the laws or the Constitution and use them in response to circumstances of moral or…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Law originated from majority’s habit, and intended to raise fairness and justice to the world. Just like Roman Empire desired to reinforce its strength by using Law of the Twelve Tables. This ‘code’ from Ancient Rome mainly based on their behavior and their social value back then. However, as more and more people attracted to Rome, the main purpose of this law had been twisted. They began used this law to reinforce their autocracy and oppression toward slaves and women.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What the author has laid down for us so far is that, however offensive it is in the present day and age to say it, there is a common moral ground. However, just because the common moral ground exists doesn’t mean that we understand it fully, and it doesn’t mean that we always follow it, we don’t. Despite what one would expect, it is often used to defend corruption, and to justify misconduct. This common moral ground is the groundwork for natural law, together with some small allegations. While the idea of natural law may give the impression of simplicity, it is hard to face the truths of it, and far har What the author has laid down for us so far is that, however, offensive it is nowadays to say it, there is a common moral ground.…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Australian Legal System

    • 1683 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Legal systems can be dated back to the ancient peoples. There are many different legal systems that have evolved in other parts of the world. There are two types of legal system, the secular and religious legal system. It is argued that the Australian legal system is radically different to other legal systems. This, however, is not the case through findings and comparison with the Madayin legal system and Talmudic Jewish legal system.…

    • 1683 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Media Analysis Critique Paper When dealing with our broken justice was must take the time out to analysis all the aspects that relate to the basis of which on country is founded upon. We as a nation follow the due process model when it comes to trying to seek justice and putting criminals away. The Due process model by definition is the type of Justice System which is based on the principle that a citizen has absolute rights and cannot be deprived of life, liberty, or property without the appropriate procedures and safeguard. The due process model is also the model of the criminal justice system that stresses the possibility of error in the stages leading to the trail; as well as emphasizes procedural rights over system efficiency (Experience…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dworkin on Judicial Discretion in “Hard Cases” Lu Zhao Boyu (Bozy) | A0127866R In the standard courtroom, one could reasonably expect the judge to be the one responsible for the holding of a case. However, does and should the judge exercise his own discretion when deciding cases? Prominent legal theorist H. L. A. Hart claims that judges do exercise discretion, especially in “hard cases”, where there is no pre-existing or unambiguous rule. To this matter, Hart’s brilliant student Ronald Dworkin offers an alternative theory, which argues that judges do not have discretion and should follow principles instead of rules, even in “hard cases”.…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics