Complete 2 question 1
What is the dilemma facing Palmer?
The dilemma Palmer is facing pertaining to corporal punishment is based on the different views that come to corporal punishment. Some people believe that corporal punishment is "a legalized form of child abuse, which conveys to students that violence is an acceptable method of resolving problems or disagreements" (Essex, 2012, p. 77). In most cases, corporal punishment is the last resort when it comes to discipline in the school system because it can lead to lawsuits. Before implying corporal punishment, most schools ask for permission from the parents first with a written agreement. The case "Ingraham v. Wright, where the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that even more, severe corporal punishment may not violate the Eighth Amendment prohibition of cruel and unusual punishment" (Essex, 2012, p. 78). Before using corporal punishment, Palmer should make sure he has permission from the parent, another staff member present, and assure he doesn’t use excessive force.
Should Palmer proceed with his plan to administer the punishment? Why or why not?
Palmer should not proceed with his plan to …show more content…
"Before corporal punishment is administered, school officials should have formulated rules that provide students with adequate notice that specific violations may result in the use of corporal punishment" (Essex, 2012, p. 80). It is stated that "there is no federal law outlawing corporal punishment in the United States" (Menon, 2017, p. 319). The principal must be sure that the student understands the reason for the consequences and the parents must be notified before its implying corporal punishment. The student should be allowed to have due process, "providing a remedy for students against arbitrary or capricious acts by school officials" (Essex, 2012, p.
What is the dilemma facing Palmer?
The dilemma Palmer is facing pertaining to corporal punishment is based on the different views that come to corporal punishment. Some people believe that corporal punishment is "a legalized form of child abuse, which conveys to students that violence is an acceptable method of resolving problems or disagreements" (Essex, 2012, p. 77). In most cases, corporal punishment is the last resort when it comes to discipline in the school system because it can lead to lawsuits. Before implying corporal punishment, most schools ask for permission from the parents first with a written agreement. The case "Ingraham v. Wright, where the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that even more, severe corporal punishment may not violate the Eighth Amendment prohibition of cruel and unusual punishment" (Essex, 2012, p. 78). Before using corporal punishment, Palmer should make sure he has permission from the parent, another staff member present, and assure he doesn’t use excessive force.
Should Palmer proceed with his plan to administer the punishment? Why or why not?
Palmer should not proceed with his plan to …show more content…
"Before corporal punishment is administered, school officials should have formulated rules that provide students with adequate notice that specific violations may result in the use of corporal punishment" (Essex, 2012, p. 80). It is stated that "there is no federal law outlawing corporal punishment in the United States" (Menon, 2017, p. 319). The principal must be sure that the student understands the reason for the consequences and the parents must be notified before its implying corporal punishment. The student should be allowed to have due process, "providing a remedy for students against arbitrary or capricious acts by school officials" (Essex, 2012, p.