Bloom And Borges Sparknotes

Good Essays
Moreover, while Bloom endorses the linearity of influence, and Borges highlights its fluidity, a third distinct perception emerges. Thompson (2014, p.114) utilises David Foster Wallace’s short story B.I. #59 as a framework from which to interrogate Bloom and Borges’ arguments, detecting, “throughout [Wallace’s] fiction, influence comes not only from the past (as in Bloom’s model), or from a future, anticipated text (as in Borges’s model) but also from the cultural present.” Consequently, Wallace’s narrative is inextricably connected to the present, synthesising a “complex network of antecedent sources” (Thompson 2014, p.129). Thompson (2014, p.129) confirms, noting, “Wallace’s fiction also borrows from the cultural present, in all its varied …show more content…
Bell-Valada (1999, p.53) expands, declaring, “[Borges’] precursor Poe was definitely a kindred spirit and even an originator.” Moreover, Borges (1998, p.196) claims Poe “created a genre”, contending all detective novels “came out of Poe; they were all begotten by Poe.” Borges’ assertions support cultural transmissions, as Poe inspired a literary movement that has retained societal prominent. Bennett (1983, p.263) elaborates, labelling Borges a “perpetuator of literary forms pioneered by Poe.” Further, Bennett (1983, p.263) discerns, “Poe is the author to whom Borges returns most frequently in praise, criticism, and explicit imitation.” Ostensibly, phrases such as ‘perpetuator’ and ‘explicit imitation’ reveal Borges was not merely influenced by Poe, but actively imitated his thematic values. Yet, suggesting Borges exclusively imitated Poe is reductive, and belies Borges’ literary skill. Rather, Borges (1998, p.196) comments, “my style … is far different from Poe, since Poe wrote in what we may call a pompous style, and I write in a rather grey, everyday style.” Thus, Borges does not reflect Poe verbatim, but challenges and develops his central notions. Bennett (1983, p.275) echoes this sentiment, observing, “Borges presents the inevitable confrontation of a late writer not only with a major precursor but with the originator of those very forms that are the necessary vehicles and expressions of his vision.” Therefore, the literary relationship between Poe and Borges is not stagnant and/or linear, as in Leavis (1972) and Bloom’s (1973) conceptions. Instead, Borges simultaneously perpetuates and modernises Poe’s ideals, merging these ideals with his own to allow fluid cultural reconfigurations. Similar factors abound in Borges’ influence upon

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Bennett (1983, p.263) expands, labelling Borges a “perpetuator of literary forms pioneered by Poe.” Further, Bennett (1983, p.263) perceives, “Poe is also the author to whom Borges returns most frequently in praise, criticism, and explicit imitation.” Ostensibly, phrases such as ‘perpetuator’ and ‘explicit imitation’ reveal Borges was not merely influenced by Poe, but actively imitated his thematic values, signifying cultural recreations. Yet, suggesting Borges exclusively imitated Poe is…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    His work modifies our conception of the past, as it will modify the future” (Borges, Other Inquisitions 108). He goes on to say “The word ‘precursor’ is indispensable in the vocabulary of criticism, but one should try to purify it from every connotation of polemic or rivalry” (109). His vision of literary tradition is astute.By the inveterate tool of allusion, Borges’s stories examine the possibility that the literary question of one’s relationship to one’s successors runs parallel to the philosophical question of one’s personal identity. To Borges, not only one’s writing but one’s own identity is contingent upon the revisionary perspectives provided by the future generations.Borges deems Oscar Wilde (in the essay “About Oscar Wilde”) to have that rare ability to mix humour and frivolity with intense intellectual depth. Through him, Borges came to believe in comic truth, the truth of fiction which is able to tolerate cyclical and contradictory representations of…

    • 3909 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Edgar Allen Poe is one is a leader in American literature. History has remembered him with his style of writing. Pie has portrayed and incarnated the different elements of literature in all his works. Poe integrated within his works the functions and styles of American literature and the best place to find the elements and the functions of literature in the works of Poe are in his story titled The Cask of Amontillado. Poe composes The Cask of Amontillado.…

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The author is making the claim that Poe’s power of analysis and imagination is something all great minds have- he is not unique (Hannay). Poe wrote fine poetry because, he was writing about his self. Poe was a genius in his calculating (Hannay). In the article of “The Life and Genius the author is saying that Poe included other people in his genius writing “The Raven”. (Hannay) .Carlyle knows that Poe wrote fine Poetry also Poe included a lot of people in his writing.…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Verne was basically raised with the poems of Edgar Allan Poe. Poe’s writing influenced Jules Verne’s taking in a mix of the real world and the fantastic. The relationship between Poe and Verne is a great example of a direct connection in literacy styles. Poe blends the fantastic and plausible stories within the proto-science fiction…

    • 1629 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Point Of View In Fiction

    • 1425 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Point of view, in literary terms, is the perspective from which a narrative is told. The choice of point of view in fiction is probably the single most important decision a writer must make. This choice will bend and shape the narrative, control the storytelling and fundamentally affect the way the reader will respond to the characters. Percy Lubbock called point of view the “relation in which the narrator stands to the story” (Craft Of Fiction 1955 [1921]: 251). Focalization, a term coined by Gerard Genette (1972) as a replacement for the terms ‘perspective’ and ‘point of view’ and can be defined as a selection or restriction of narrative information in relation to the experience and knowledge…

    • 1425 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    These developments subsequently led to the formation of theories such as ‘The death of the Author’. Arguably, Elliot also had an influence on Important figures in Literary criticism such as Leavis and Bloom. There are present mutual notions of perceiving tradition as continuously remade and rethought. Furthermore, critical essays such as ‘Tradition and the individual talent’ and ‘Hamlet and his problems’ have had major influence on the school of New Criticism. These influences have made the study of literary theory what it is today.…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Thus, the implicit autobiographical traces in the narrative “attempt to move closer to the reality of an event by examining the lens through which that event is viewed” (Kraus 292). By narrating “the personal history” and communicating his own intersubjective experience of the historical event of the March, Mailer seeks to subvert the sense of objectivity and to foreground his subjective point of view. By so doing, Mailer skillfully interweaves all autobiographical, historical, journalistic, and novelistic elements into a hybrid narrative that blurs…

    • 1701 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Let us now turn and consider at length the ways in which our narrators relate Absalom, Absalom!’s epic narrative. As we shall see, each begins in medias res, and attempts to tell a tale without beginning or end; meanwhile, the techniques they employ conveying the story orally similarly mirror Konstan and Raaflaub’s assertion that epic “oral poetry is easily lost to history or altered profoundly in transmission” (1). These points considered, we shall see that Absalom, Absalom!, despite its novelistic form, nevertheless comprises an oral epic in the vein of The Iliad or The…

    • 1648 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The primary experimental features of my piece pertain to tone and narrative voice. Mainly, this is evident in the story’s third person stream of consciousness narration, and innately contradictory tone. In undertaking such experiments, my writing exists within, but also develops and challenges, broader social, cultural, and literary frameworks. Thus, to contextualise my project, it is necessary to examine influences on my thematic approach, and the technical intricacies of my writing. Firstly, my work expands upon stream of consciousness narration.…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays